> But analyzing his mental condition is sure as shit not up to me or to anybody else. Why not? Am I unallowed to suggest that Howard Hughes had OCD? That Kurt

> But analyzing his mental condition is sure as shit not up to me or to anybody else. Why not? Am I unallowed to suggest that Howard Hughes had OCD? That Kurt Gödel was paranoid? Submitting a hypothesis about some’s mental condition is a reasonable thing to do, given that you have a substantial body of evidence in the form of behavioural reports. I don’t find the above argument convincing, but only because it’s vague and lacks specific examples - not because it’s ”not okay.”