3 ms·
> the article goes into detail on why the iris hashes are sufficiently private. The problem is that if it something goes wrong, you can't fix things by changi
by JohnFen 3y ago
> the article goes into detail on why the iris hashes are sufficiently private.
The problem is that if it something goes wrong, you can't fix things by changing your biometrics. That means that "sufficiently" private is a much, much higher threshold than it would be in other contexts.
It also requires a lot of trust of the entities gathering the biometric information, and it's hard to come up with any entity that seems trustworthy enough. Especially any entity in the cryptocurrency space.
Even ignoring the extremely creepy aspect of this (something worldcoin amplified immensely with those orbs), this seems like a very bad and dangerous idea. Even if the odds of a terrible mistake are very low, if you roll the dice enough times, you will eventually roll badly.
Personally, I wouldn't touch any of this at all. I'd feel more comfortable having the entire internet think I'm not human than expose myself to this sort of thing.
- xvector 3y agoHow is the hash of an iris scan "sensitive biometric information," any more than a CCTV camera at your coffee shop, or the government minting your ID? It is a hash, for god's sake. It is more privacy preserving than the latter two, or any currently known proof-of-personhood currently in existence - while still accomplishing the goal of proof-of-personhood.
- JohnFen 3y agoThe hash is sensitive because it's a (reasonably) unique identifier that has been assigned to you. > any more than a CCTV camera at your coffee shop, or the government minting your ID? It's not, fundamentally, but that's not an argument in favor of things like this. The less of this sort of thing, the better. But a big difference is that my local coffee shop is, you know, local and not likely to be sharing the images with anyone as a routine matter, and they certainly aren't correlating the images they capture with my identity. The difference with government ID is twofold: it's the government, which means it's not optional. Second, it's the government rather than private entities. I can have some sort of influence over my government. I have zero influence over private entities. So while I don't like it in either case, I prefer the government-issued ID over something done by companies. > while still accomplishing the goal of proof-of-personhood. I'm not sure why this is a goal that is so important that it's worth any reduction in privacy.
- nathanaldensr 3y agoIn today's world of technocratic authoritarianism and regulatory capture, the differences between government and corporations is effectively zero.
- xvector 3y agoThe hash is less sensitive than literally any other proof of personhood currently in existence. Go ahead, try to name a proof of personhood that's more private than a hash. You seem to be framing this as a reduction in privacy but it is quite the opposite.