6 ms·
I think that’s dead on arrival in the US. Having been raised in a conservative evangelical church, there’s the notion that in the “end times”, this kind of thin
by kstrauser 3y ago
I think that’s dead on arrival in the US. Having been raised in a conservative evangelical church, there’s the notion that in the “end times”, this kind of thing (referred to as the “mark of the Beast”) would be required to buy and sell goods, at the cost of eternal damnation for getting the mark. The linked webpage is nightmare fuel for the many tens of millions of Americans in such churches. Everything about it is a giant “here come the end times!” dog whistle, even if it wasn’t meant to be.
Also, why do we suddenly need to prove who’s an actual human? Is that going to change how I talk to chatbots on company websites? Is there the laughable notion that this won’t be immediately subverted by social media bot accounts so they can prove that they’re real people? What exact problem does this solve?
Also also, sucks if you’re blind, I guess. Now having eyes is new our fundamental definition of being a human. I’ll snag a few of these for my pets, who’ll be happy to know they can be official people on the Internet.
- xvector 3y ago> What exact problem does this solve? Voting on a decentralized platform. Decentralized governance and decentralized UBI in general. > Also also, sucks if you’re blind, I guess. Blind people tend to have irises. Even when both eyes are missing - the article mentions other ways to verify proof-of-personhood (at the expense of privacy compared to iris scans.)
- kstrauser 3y ago> Voting on a decentralized platform. That begs the question, presuming that voting on a decentralized platform is good. > Decentralized governance and decentralized UBI in general. I can parse those words, but I don’t see how they’d depend on the widget from the article. > Even when both eyes are missing - the article mentions other ways to verify proof-of-personhood (at the expense of privacy compared to iris scans.) “Privacy for the normal people!” Oh, I can’t imagine that starting a firestorm (and for good reason).
- xvector 3y ago> That begs the question, presuming that voting on a decentralized platform is good. A decentralized platform is verifiable and less prone to being rigged. All that's missing is proof of personhood. > Decentralized governance and decentralized UBI in general. Governance on decentralized platform can typically be approached via a few ways: - weighting votes by compute power - weighting votes by volume of ownership (eg of a coin) - weighting votes by number of identities/wallets The first two only serve the rich (the people that can afford GPU farms or equity), and will lead to an oligarchy. The last doesn't work because one person can create infinite accounts (eg public/private key pairs.) The last, however, can work if one person can only ever be linked to one account. > “Privacy for the normal people!” Oh, I can’t imagine that starting a firestorm (and for good reason). You are picking a really tiny edge case and saying the entire system can't work because of this. You aren't considering the possibility that the edge case can be adequately resolved with enough thought and investment.
- kstrauser 3y ago> A decentralized platform is verifiable and less prone to being rigged. All that's missing is proof of personhood. That seems to be an extraordinary claim, and I'm skeptical that 1) it's true, and 2) that's all that's missing. In short, I've voted for many things in many contexts in the existing world. I don't think I've ever bumped into a problem with voting that any form of a decentralized platform would have improved. > You are picking a really tiny edge case and saying the entire system can't work because of this. It's just the first example I thought of. I'm sure that 8 billion people could crowdsource all source of other edge cases. > You aren't considering the possibility that the edge case can be adequately resolved with enough thought and investment. I wasn't the one making the proposal. The onus is on the proposer to explain how they're going to deal with the edge cases and convince the rest of us that this is a real, thought-through idea.
- xvector 3y ago> That seems to be an extraordinary claim, and I'm skeptical that 1) it's true, and 2) that's all that's missing. Are you aware of how decentralized computers work? Every computation can be verified by every participant. It's objectively true that such a platform would be less prone to being rigged.
- lesuorac 3y ago> Having been raised in a conservative evangelical church What's their stance on Usury [1]? I have no doubt that if say tax credits were tied to having World Coin as opposed to a SSN that they would end up going along with it. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury
- hinkley 3y agoTo the best of my recollection, usury is not mentioned in Revelations.
- kstrauser 3y agoI never said they were consistent. But to channel the scary pastors of my youth, “that’s also a sin, and people shouldn’t do that, but I’m not going to sit back and let the One World Government roll out the mark of the Beast!” If you want to see how quickly a quarter of the US can organize and mobilize, things like this are a great way to find out.
- hinkley 3y agoUse your guide dog as your iris scan! On the internet, nobody knows you're a dog.
- all2 3y agoSo you need a new ID every 10 years? How would this work out practically? I the parent is a bit facetious, but I'm still curious.
- hinkley 3y agoGreat news. We can't seem to use the same tech for more than about 6 years so just switch platforms every time you get a new guide dog. (and yes, I'm being very facetious)
- thinkmassive 3y ago> why do we suddenly need to prove who’s an actual human? Voting and UBI are often cited as valuable use cases. It will definitely be subverted if it becomes widespread enough to be impactful.
- Tade0 3y ago> Now having eyes is new our fundamental definition of being a human. Well, alternatively, everyone has a skull - it's the most human symbol imaginable. Getting a reliable image of that repeatedly might prove tricky though.