2 ms·
Walter Benjamin on the Obsolete Book
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe Benjamin quote at the top of this piece is absolutely brilliant. I'd run across it ... somewhere ... in the past day or so, Richard turned it up following an ask I'd put out on the Fediverse. Memorialising that here: “Already today, as the current scientific mode of production teaches, the book is already an obsolete mediation between two different card file systems. For everything essential is found in the index box of the researcher who wrote it, and the scholar who studies it assimilates it in his own card file.” “Und heute schon ist das Buch, wie die aktuelle wissenschaftliche Produktionsweise lehrt, eine veraltete Vermittlung zwischen zwei verschiedenen Kartotheksystemen. Denn alles Wesentliche findet sich im Zettelkasten des Forschers, der’s verfaßte, und der Gelehrte, der darin studiert, assimiliert es seiner eigenen Kartothek." Walter Benjamin - Attested Auditor of Books, in One Way Street (1928) That appears once before on HN as Richard notes, by qznc: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23388285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23388285> I've thought a great deal about information, books, and knowledge as a social construct over the past decade or so. The thought of books as a form of inter-process communication, where those processes themselves are the read- and write-heads of databanks (index cards, Zettelkasten, Wikis, databases, personal organisers, Zotero and Calibre archives, ...) hadn't really occurred to me, though I in fact practice just what Benjamin describes myself. It also seems as if books are struggling to sort out what it is that they want to be and achieve, though I suspect this has pretty much always been the case. Recordkeeping technologies are forward-moving but strongly backward-influenced. The form, style, and structure of books is governed by numerous requirements, audiences, interests, and constraints. To join with another thought I've had recently: we are not defined by our pasts and histories, but we are from our pasts and histories.