2 ms·
> I'm quite certain that even the current generation of AI could already make 10-20% of first-world jobs obsolete I often ask people how we could modify a econ
by godelski 3y ago
> I'm quite certain that even the current generation of AI could already make 10-20% of first-world jobs obsolete
I often ask people how we could modify a economy to support 10% automation of the workforce. Where 10% of people are not only displaced, but that we do not gain an additional 10% of new jobs which could be filled by humans.
The most reasonable answer I've ever gotten was jobs programs. But I don't think this actually solves things, and neither did that person. It's just a tax and prevents people from... being the most human they can be. It also prevents us from reaching post scarcity.
Now I don't actually believe that 10% of jobs in Western countries could be replaced. There's 135m people employed in America and AI can't even replace the 2.4m janitorial staff that we have. AI isn't needed to replace the 3.8m retail staff (#1), 3.4m cashiers (#3), or 3.2m fastfood workers (#4), where the first two have already seen significant disruption and the latter is still unsolved since AI can't "flip burgers" good enough yet (yes, I know there are burger flipping robots, you're missing the point). But they still can't replace health care aids (#2), nurses (#5), or even movers (#8). I'd really encourage you to check out the most popular jobs[0] and ask yourself if you truly can disrupt them. Because if so, you should probably apply for a y-combinator seed round. Or AI just isn't as far as many people think it is. Replacing the one cashier and one person working the drive-through (both people multi-task btw) isn't going to significantly reduce the 8 people working during any given shift at a taco bell.
[0] https://www.careeronestop.org/Toolkit/Careers/careers-largest-employment.aspx https://www.careeronestop.org/Toolkit/Careers/careers-larges...
- zarzavat 3y agoThis is a common fallacy that I see often on HN. People are used to technologies that have a certain set of capabilities, where people find new ways to apply this technology over time. For example smartphones basically do the same kind of things they did 10 years ago, but people have found many more industries to apply them in (by writing apps). AI is fundamentally different because the capabilities of the base technology are growing rapidly, at the same time as people are finding more applications for it. So when you look into the future, you don’t just have to forecast increased applications of AI, you also have to forecast broader capabilities of the base technology. It is no use to take GPT-4’s capabilities and cast those into the future.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"It is no use to take GPT-4’s capabilities and cast those into the future." This is true, but we cannot say "ChatGPT is huge now, and in 5 years we will have the tech to replace humans" when we have no real evidence that that is the case either...
- godelski 3y agoAI is different because it can act intelligently, getting the nuance that humans are able to. That is, it can do everything a human can do. But we're nowhere near that yet.[0] Past technology didn't directly replace human workers, but rather changed the way things were done. The difference is a self-checkout vs a janitor robot. The former is a paradigm shift, displacing the worker by shifting how the job is done and who is performing the tasks. The latter is a direct replacement of the human worker, drop in. Of course current AI will get better, but this idea has been around for decades, and like François says, people have assumed many of these problems would be solved far sooner than they have been. The thread is worth a read. We are talking about the opinions of a high ranking AI/ML researcher who extensively writes about the nature of intelligence and current limitations. Don't be fooled by fancy demos. [0] https://twitter.com/fchollet/status/1683200588782379008 https://twitter.com/fchollet/status/1683200588782379008 [1] https://fchollet.com/ https://fchollet.com/