3 ms·
I had to do a one-off brokerage (where I don't have a personal representative) transfer fairly recently and, although they loosened up a bit during COVID, they
by ghaff 3y ago
I had to do a one-off brokerage (where I don't have a personal representative) transfer fairly recently and, although they loosened up a bit during COVID, they were back to basically requiring me to show up at a brokerage branch in person. In theory, I could have gotten a Medallion Signature from my bank but it turned out they couldn't do it at my local branch and getting their central system to do it failed, so I just drove the 40 minutes or so to a brokerage branch.
This is the problem with things like account recovery. If you really want to minimize social engineering etc., you'll do something requiring a physical presence and various sorts of government issued ID and will probably cost money. And people won't like that. (And the companies won't like it because there's a lot of overhead.)
- MichaelZuo 3y agoA passport, or some other difficult-to-forge document, could be used right?
- ghaff 3y agoThat's how it works in the US. You show the notary your passport or driver's license, they go "Yup, looks like you," you sign the doc in their presence, and they apply their stamp.
- noodlesUK 3y agoYeah, but even notary seals are forged with alarming frequency. They are usually just a stamp after all.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoThey do keep a record of document signed (not an actual document tho)
- ghaff 3y agoBut, at some point, what do you do to absolutely 100% guarantee your bonafides to a complete stranger located across the country? The answer is you probably can't so you put a system in place that protects against all but the most serious and determined attacker who is willing to spend significant effort and money to impersonate you. It's true that you can physically go to the institution in question and prove your bonafides to them so no intermediate is involved but you start to add a lot of friction to all but the most serious transactions.
- noodlesUK 3y agoI mean, some kind of PKI would be a nice start. Preferably with a registry at national level.
- shortcake27 3y agoOnly physically though. Many years ago, possessing the values on a passport constituted verification. This data was stored and after a significant number of leaks, this data alone was useless as it became public knowledge. The next step was requiring a photo of the document. The photos were stored, and after a significant number of leaks, the same thing happened. The next step was ID selfies. Then the same thing happened. Now it’s selfie videos with the ID. This too will become useless when those videos are leaked. It’s a never ending battle. A passport is a physical document and should only be used physically. Online, we need public/private key authentication. It’s the only way.
- dzhiurgis 3y ago> Online, we need public/private key authentication. It’s the only way. Your credit card already has contactless chip and it's been ID verified. So does your smartphone. Why can't we just marry the two together?
- ghaff 3y agoAnd then private keys will leak. Nothing's perfect. Requiring physical presence is a pain but it's probably tolerable for sufficiently high value transactions. Only works within the US. There's a related process with more hurdles for international.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoI assumed this was only in regards to higher value interactions where meeting in person always makes sense. I'm having trouble imagining a scenario where such a high level of assurance for real identity verification is required but is not worthwhile to meet in person. Can you name a few examples?
- mindslight 3y agoOnline account recovery could go a long way by bootstrapping off the notary system, and then having a waiting period to mitigate forgeries. But companies don't want to add the complexity where a user could commit to a less convenient process for more security, so we're at an impasse. Also they'd have to hire someone to verify the authenticity of incoming physical documents, and having skilled labor do things that aren't "scalable" is verboten.