6 ms·
> Adulation of the Spartans is less about historical exactitude and more about creating a model that everyone can look to in order to build esprit de corps. Ve
by qsort 3y ago
> Adulation of the Spartans is less about historical exactitude and more about creating a model that everyone can look to in order to build esprit de corps.
Very good, but why does it have to be a brutal -- for the standards of the time -- slave state that wasn't even particularly good at war?
The current situation in Ukraine should be proof enough that the myth of manly men doing manly things does not produce armies that are actually effective. Almost everything Sparta fanfiction does is actively counterproductive.
- johngalt_ 3y agoCould you expand more on your view about the current situation in Ukraine?
- antupis 3y agoI think stuff like how Russian VDV https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Airborne_Forces https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Airborne_Forces was portrayed before war and what they actually have accomplished example of this.
- fmajid 3y agoSparta was a totalitarian state well beyond the wildest dreams of Hitler or Stalin. Bertrand Russell does an excellent job The History of Western Philosophy of showing how depraved they were (as does Devereaux), how they influenced Plato (himself a disgruntled Athenian aristocrat who resented his social class' loss of power when Athens became a democracy, then collaborated with the Spartan occupation of Athens after the latter lost the Peloponnesian War).
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Sparta was a totalitarian state well beyond the wildest dreams of Hitler or Stalin It was also a polis with rudimentary constitutional checks on its dyadic monarchy and a public ekklesia that notionally approved legislation. > a disgruntled Athenian aristocrat who resented his social class' loss of power when Athens became a democracy This is true. He also had prescient complaints about direct democracy as Athens practiced it. Of course, at that time we didn't know direct democracy doesn't work--it careens towards partisan overdrive and ricocheting majoritarianism.
- backtoyoujim 3y agoAccording to the histories levied by the Athenians. The Spartans left no written record and hardly any archeology.
- morelisp 3y ago> The Spartans left no written record and hardly any archeology. Which also suggests they kind of sucked.
- vasco 3y agoOr that they oriented their society towards war rather than writing things down. Sparta was a state of total war before total war was even defined.
- morelisp 3y agoJust like we look to Somalia and Uganda today for the highest calibre soldiers.
- Two4 3y agoTotal war is distinct from civil war or regional conflict - none of the parties you mentioned are completely committed at every level possible to victory (or at least the other side losing). Britain and Germany can both be thought of as being in states of total war at varying times during WW2.
- morelisp 3y agoIf you draw this distinction it doesn't apply to Sparta either.
- vasco 3y agoThey are not drawing the distinction, this is a specific definition that you decided to take offense to for some reason: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_war https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_war It's not some political statement, all that was meant was that their whole society participated in the war effort and their education centered on fighting and survival rather than writing things down.
- jhanschoo 3y agoWhy do you cite Russel's philosophy book written for a lay audience and that has received criticism (see wikipedia), rather than, say, a classical scholar?
- fmajid 3y agoBecause classical scholars tend to brush this under the carpet out of misplaced deference or reverence for Plato (or perhaps because they quite enjoy the conceit of the philosopher-king). You have to go to Russell or Popper for an explanation of how evil Plato's ideology is, even though it is there black on white in The Republic: - "noble lies" and propaganda as the basis of the state - strict separation of the population into castes - taking children away from their parents and brainwashing them - killing of political dissidents Even in Orwell's 1984 parents kept their children, even if they were indoctrinated into squealing on their parents. If anything, it looks more like John Boorman's Zardoz.
- jhanschoo 3y agoLet me repeat your argument back to you. You are saying that classical scholars, purely out of deference for Plato, cannot be trusted to investigate properly just how depraved Spartan society was; and hence Russell is a better authority?
- fmajid 3y agoClassics is not the same as history and no serious historians dispute what Sparta was, it’s philosophy or Ancient Greek ones. I suppose since you have Holocaust denier “historians” like you have British Empire revisionists, there must be some Sparta fans lurking under a rock somewhere.
- morelisp 3y agoHere's a good article by a classical military scholar which covers many of the same topics: https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/07/22/sparta-popular-culture-united-states-military-bad-history/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/07/22/sparta-popular-culture-...
- Waterluvian 3y agoAfter all those trampoline axe throwing videos, I’m shocked, shocked I tell you, to hear that Spetznaz were wiped out at an airport on day one.
- FormerBandmate 3y agoMaybe through the lens of culture war nonsense the Ukraine war proves that. Ukraine's army isn't more effeminate lol, they're just less associated with Fox News
- hwillis 3y agoYeah pretty sure they're referring to Russia's army being so pathetic
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoUsing the imagery of a people who were a historical loser does not necessarily imply that you, too, will lose battles. After all, things like Apache helicopters are named after historical losers, but one can still win battles with them.