6 ms·
Why America stopped building public pools
- synetic 3y agoDesegregation occurring when the push to dismantle government run services was gaining traction caused the loss of public pools. Americans acquired an irrational fear of government in the 70s and 80s. We lost public pools, publicly run ambulance service, publicly run garbage collection. Police departments no longer service their own vehicles.
- neaden 3y agoI think it's important to remember how linked these are. In many places the response to desegregation was to dismantle as much public infrastructure as possible and replace it with private infrastructure that was legally integrated but functionalaly segregated.
- hyperliner 3y ago[dead]
- gagged_s_poster 3y ago>irrational
- synetic 3y agoYes it was irrational of Americans to fear government run ambulance services and whatnot. All governments are capable of doing bad things. The reaction to this fact ought not be the dismantling of those government services that worked and provided tangible benefits to the people. Certain politicians decried government inefficiency and said that government can’t work. Once elected they did everything they could to prove themselves correct.
- twoodfin 3y agoWhy should police departments do automobile maintenance? Other than to add more sinecures for the politically connected…
- synetic 3y agoWhat is the benefit of outsourcing that to a private company that pays its workers much less in salary and a benefits? The money spent on maintenance is roughy the same but now the jobs for the workers are less desirable less well paid. The money now goes to the business owner. All the business owner is doing to squeezing money out of the workers to enrich themselves. There is no benefit to society in doing this. Indeed it is a loss for the community. Are you under the impression that government contracts for vehicle maintenance are immune to becoming sinecures for the politically connected? Only mechanics are subject to this possibility?
- SamReidHughes 3y agoGovernment agencies that serviced their own vehicles just ended up with a fleet of non-working vehicles. At least that was true for those for which the vehicle fleet was of secondary concern. And for something like a police department, the efficiencies disappear with modern vehicles which need less maintenance.
- newaccount74 3y agoPublic pools are also disappearing in my country (Austria). It's mostly a cost issue. Towns see the huge maintenance bill and decide to close their pool. Half the indoor pools I went to in my childhood are now closed. No new public pools have been built. When I was a kid, I had swimming classes every other week in school. My kids have swimming classes 4 times a year because the few remaining pools that schools can go to are overbooked. The completely predictable result is that the number of kids and adults who can't swim is growing every year.
- mongol 3y agoUnrelated but thought to follow up. When I grew up, in the 70s - 80s, I have fond memories of going to the public indoor swimming pool where I lived in a suburb to Stockholm. The smell of chlorinated water, the sounds of kids playing echoing on the tiled walls, sweating the sauna afterwards. Above all, a strict hygiene regime. No underwear in shower, sauna or pool. Just swim pants in the pool, naked in the sauna. Somehow, this has changed. Kids don't give a shit and swim with their underwear underneath their swimpants. I don't know what the staff are doing but seems they have lost control. I am disgusted and will not visit public pools anymore. I wonder if this is a more global trend.
- culopatin 3y agoWhy is underwear more disgusting than the bare body that it contains? It’s not like taking your underwear off makes you sterile no?
- dalke 3y agoSwedish pools at the time required you to shower, naked [1], before entering the pool, and to use soap while showering, with special attention to the hair, armpits, crotch, and feet. This helps get rid of the dirt and urea (which when combined with chlorine makes the 'swimming pool smell'), keeping the pool clean and with little odor. It is difficult to wash underwear with the same thoroughness. I have not seen people laundering their underwear before swimming. [1] Our local pool changed to allow showering in one's bathing trunks. I personally don't like the rule, as I think people will skimp on washing their crotch before entering the pool.
- AgentOrange1234 3y agoIf you want to go deeper on this, Heather McGhee’s “The Sum of Us” is an astounding book.
- femboy 3y agoIt's in the name. P
- NikkiA 3y agoLidos went out of fashion globally sometime around WW2 anyway.
- petsormeat 3y agoThere's an intriguing line in this article that I wish were explored further: what is the role of increasing liability and insurance costs in the withdrawal from public amenities?
- neilv 3y agoRegarding the racial integration protests and violence that the article mentions, Mr. Rogers (coming along later) famously addressed this, to children: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6O_Ep9bY0U&t=1m27s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6O_Ep9bY0U&t=1m27s That clip continues at 2m20s.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoInteresting that CNN mentioned Martin Luther King Jr in the article as the City of Atlanta spent a big chunk of downtown Atlanta's TAD (same thing as TIF) money on the MLK Aquatics Center. But the byline says it came from CNN's New York office so maybe they don't know much about Atlanta. I also wonder if like so many other primarily outdoor activities (the MLK pool happens to be indoors), there's a generational decline in interest.
- srgpqt 3y agoWell yeah, the kids can’t easily use their smartphone while swimming. So they prefer not to swim.
- khazhoux 3y agoThey’re expensive and demand is lower than in the past. All the racial content in the article was unnecessary.
- jt2190 3y agoText only version: https://lite.cnn.com/2023/07/22/business/public-pools-extreme-heat/index.html https://lite.cnn.com/2023/07/22/business/public-pools-extrem...
- jt2190 3y agoThe answer is right here: > Public pools are costly for cities to maintain and insure. > Cities also have struggled to staff pools with lifeguards. High-school and college students have more summer job options and are less likely to pick up a job as a lifeguard over the summer than they once did, [Kevin Roth, vice president of research, evaluation and technology at the National Recreation and Park Association] said. The article also doesn’t mention the rise of the “splash pad” as a cheaper and safer alternative for cooling off in the hot summer months. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splash_pad https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splash_pad
- Waterluvian 3y agoThinking about where I grew up, every public pool I went to was basically subsidized by being attached to hockey arenas. None of them are gone yet luckily.
- SamReidHughes 3y agoA major reason is because homes became air conditioned.
- paul_funyun 3y agoAround here we just drive to the lake or river. Who wants to swim in a public pool when you could swim in a lake or river with no rules? Better swimming in the lake, bridges and rope swingsbeat diving boards any day, and you can crack open a beer if you're so inclined.
- WkndTriathlete 3y agoYeah, if "around here" means what I think it does, three people died recently doing just that because they hadn't learned how to swim properly. And while you can learn to do some basic swimming in a lake or a river, it's a lot easier to teach and learn it in a pool.
- paul_funyun 3y agoBut nobody wants to go to public pools, given the option. With a public pool available, those people probably would have done the same thing. Nobody with a choice is going to a public pool.
- jemmyw 3y agoI'd rather go to a pool. There are rivers and swimming holes around where I live but the public pools are more popular