7 ms·
A simple way to stem most snake oil is to put all payments for snake oil treatments into escrow till the treatment is approved. Then the snake oil manufacturer
by londons_explore 3y ago
A simple way to stem most snake oil is to put all payments for snake oil treatments into escrow till the treatment is approved.
Then the snake oil manufacturer can peddle their unapproved treatment to as many people as they like, but they are losing money on every dose unless the treatment turns out to be safe and effective.
Obviously you need a big team of scientists on the approval panel to make sure no snake oil salesmen are faking trial data to get their payday, but that seems solvable.
- 7e 3y agoBut at the end of the day, failed treatments still kill people. Some may choose the experimental treatment, and die, over the crappy chemo, which gives them a chance to live. Escrow won’t bring them back.
- londons_explore 3y agoTrue. But speeding up the search for a treatment saves many future people. The ethical tradeoff between definitely saving a life now or probably saving many lives later is an age old problem, but one which society hasn't properly converted into laws and processes in medicine.
- echelon 3y agoIf I knew I were going to die, I'd at least want to try something new even if the chances were slim. If it didn't work out, at least it'd be a new data point for those that come after. That means something.
- takinola 3y agoI love the innovative thinking here but I can easily think of a way to game this system. Snake Oil LLC mounts a PR campaign claiming the governmen is trying to shut them down by delaying approvals so they can't get their money so they can't undercut Big Pharma. If Snake Oil (TM) doesn't work, why have patients ponied up $X billion in fees over the years? You have enough stories like this (plus there will inevitably be some mistakes by the FDA that will be shown to be proof of government perfidy) and the conspiracy theories will have a field day and fuel a black market.
- throwaway894345 3y agoI mean, this is just a “sufficient misinformation” argument that could be levied against literally any kind of policy. No policy can survive sufficient misinformation.
- takinola 3y agoThe point I am making is not a rebuttal to this specific proposal but that any such change will have an attack vector. Hell, the reason we are having this discussion is because of the (unfortunate) case of someone not being served by the current policy. Any new change to the policy will have such cases which will lead to this same discussion. Creating an equitable drug approval process is a true dilemma.
- darkclouds 3y ago>A simple way to stem most snake oil is to put all payments for snake oil treatments into escrow till the treatment is approved. It should be a escrow release when a patient is cured. Let the science and knowledge speak for itself instead of statistic doing the talking. The problem is these drugs companies are the stealth chemical weapons development program for the military.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoIt should be a escrow release when a patient is cured. This just winds up being cruel. We don't understand a number of diseases, and we don't know how to cure them. But we can treat symptoms, and sometimes prevent them even if it isn't a cure. It's OK to make Insulin Plus that keeps diabetics alive longer. I have MS, and freaking trust me, I want my non-cure medicine. Without that medicine, my chances of having a very poor quality of life full of discomfort increases pretty dramatically. Lots of things are like this: No real cure, but we make folks lives better by treating symptoms or preventing some damage and things like that. The only way to not be cruel is to give treatments that work even if they aren't a cure.
- darkclouds 3y agoSymptoms are used to diagnose, ergo is a treatment of symptoms a cure? Lets not forget the expansion of the DSM which pretty much incorporates every human being as having a mental health issue or sexual deviancy fetish. There is no normal in the DSM, so would some medical experts start dialling back on diagnosing new conditions to pad out their careers and income?
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoThat bit about the DSM is a pretty obvious layperson's point of view: It is easy to say that you fit the criteria when you forget that the symptoms need to have negative consequences on your life. And there is 'normal' - normal is a range. There is a huge difference between being down after a loved one's death and finding yourself feeling that way for no reason or not coping 2 years later. Considering that - there is no way to answer the last question. That's just a "what if" argument and fails to take into consideration that there is a shortage of mental health experts, and there is absolutely no need for someone to do that sort of thing. And no, no everyone has a "sexual deviancy fetish", just for the record. As far as 'treating symptoms'... I have MS. I take medication that slows the disease. If I had fatigue or pain, they would try to treat that too. If it causes depression - which it can - they'd try to treat that. No matter what treatments I get for symptoms, I still have the disease. There is no actual cure.
- krisoft 3y ago> A simple way to stem most snake oil is to put all payments for snake oil treatments into escrow till the treatment is approved. Even simpler is to prohibit payments for these experimental treatments, but let people who whould die anyway participate in them as long as it is free for them. In return the drug companies could use the outcomes as data points towards their aproval applications. Why would a drug manufacturer do that? Why would they offeir their advanced but as of yet unaproved drugs for free? It is true it would cost them the manufacturing cost of the drug, but what they get in return is data on how efficient/safe the drug is. Assuming the drug works well they could use that data to prove their case and get approval. And if it is safe and has the desired effect they get their aproval and they could then charge for their drug as usual. This sets the right incentives for the drug company. If they know they are selling snake oil they would be crazy to offer it for free, especially because all it would do is to prove that it does not work. If they think it can work they gamble with their own money. Which is good because the drug company knows the most about their own drug. The patient in general is not knowledgeable enough to evaluate the chances of an experimental therapy, but the drug company is.
- seqizz 3y ago> Even simpler is to prohibit payments for these experimental treatments, but let people who whould die anyway participate in them as long as it is free for them. In return the drug companies could use the outcomes as data points towards their aproval applications. Hell I'd even approve my tax money to go to those companies which end up saving lives as reward.
- CogitoCogito 3y ago> Even simpler is to prohibit payments for these experimental treatments, but let people who whould die anyway participate in them as long as it is free for them. In return the drug companies could use the outcomes as data points towards their aproval applications. That would never happen for good reason. Drug companies would have every incentive to bias the results towards approval by giving the drugs to detain patients. I’m not exaggerating when I say this might be the worst idea I’ve read in this entire thread.
- CogitoCogito 3y ago> A simple way to stem most snake oil is to put all payments for snake oil treatments into escrow till the treatment is approved. I doubt any company anywhere (legitimate or not) would provide drugs under such conditions. It would make much more sense to just focus on getting approval instead.