6 ms·
Interesting to see this show up. This was a very formative paper for me. If correct—and it certainly seems correct to me—then it completely dissolves the Fermi
by adastra22 3y ago
Interesting to see this show up. This was a very formative paper for me. If correct—and it certainly seems correct to me—then it completely dissolves the Fermi paradox. And yet nobody seems to be aware of it, and both the popular and scientific press continue with the “where are they?” Fermi paradox headlines.
What I learned was that just figuring out the right answer is indifferent to change people’s minds, even in science.
- jwocky 3y agoWhat was the conclusion of this paper? The link's conclusion was truncated.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoIt's in the abstrct, right at the top
- _zoltan_ 3y agoYou could have just stayed silent.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoWhy, was there a joke I ruined or something?
- yreg 3y agoIt says only >That said, the results indicate that the probability we are alone (<1) in the galaxy is significant, while the maximum number of contemporary civilizations might be as few as a thousand. That's not very useful. The full paper is available on scihub though.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoErr, what exactly were you expecting, their telephone numbers? You got figures and probabilities in the conclusion and I can't see what else you could reasonably hope for.
- yreg 3y agoI (and I believe jwocky as well) expected some kind of rationale. There are no figures nor probabilities supporting the conclusion in the linked article. Of course if one pirates the paper they can learn more.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoAh, the 'method' part. Gotcha. You might email the author and ask for a copy. They're often surprisingly willing to hand out individual copies.
- _a_a_a_ 3y ago> What I learned was that just figuring out the right answer is indifferent to change people’s minds, even in science Seems too strong a conclusion.
- ghaff 3y agoThe Drake equation does let you model numbers you think you know with some certainty, numbers that known to be very large, and some known unknowns. But even leaving aside unknown unknowns, the modeling of some known unknowns can boil to making models that assume numbers that are very small but (obviously) not zero because we're sitting here.
- karpierz 3y ago> And yet nobody seems to be aware of it, and both the popular and scientific press continue with the “where are they?” Fermi paradox headlines. A reasonable explanation here is that the paper is not correct because it relies on unfounded priors, which is generally where most Bayesian work falls flat.
- DennisP 3y agoSo your prior is that Bayesian papers are likely to have unfounded priors. Now I'm wondering how well-founded your prior is.
- _yb2s 3y agoYou have it backwards- the traditional Drake equation relies on unfounded priors, and by using a Bayesian approach they have avoided that problem. Instead of making up terms from nothing like the Drake equation, they are able to represent only the data we actually have, and leave the rest uncertain. The priors are carefully encoding the actual information they have, and incorporating the extreme lack of prior knowledge as uniform or nearly uniform priors over an extremely wide range for the terms we have no data on. That is the basic takeaway here- with almost no knowledge about a large number of factors (as the Drake equation is constructed), there is an extremely high chance that once of those unknown factors is actually nearly zero, even when your expectation value for each (e.g. what would have been used in the traditional Drake equation) is relatively high. N (number of civilizations) therefore approaches zero, even if there is no single term that you are pretty sure is near zero. The Bayesian approach here allows for a rigorous representation of our (extreme lack of) knowledge and gets to the truth of the matter: civilizations face a huge number of possible bottlenecks, each of which we know almost nothing about the probabilities of. This means, there is a strong chance at least one of those is a massive filter, even if we don't know which.
- vlovich123 3y agoWhile I agree with both the approach and result intuitively, the assumption of uniform unknown priors feels like it could be a huge source of errors
- narag 3y agoWhat I learned was that just figuring out the right answer is indifferent to change people’s minds, even in science. The further from experimental confirmation some question is, the bigger chance that people will ignore evidence in favour of their pet belief. There's a kind of people that likes to believe that we're too far away from our nearest neighbors, that we'll never spread to other stars, nobody will come and that we'll get extinct soon. Not sure why they think this way. What I do know is that somehow they find comfort believing that. Fermi paradox is music to their ears because it seems to confirm their mindset.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoIt's ripe for YouTubers cum science communicators to jump on.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> yet nobody seems to be aware of it I'm a rare earthier. But I've never found the Drake equation useful for estimation. The knowns are drowned by the unknowns, which we do not know to even vast orders of magnitude. The probability of abiogenesis or multicellular life forming are simply beyond our present understanding of biochemistry. We know they are rare. But the entire equation turns on whether they are merely rare, or vanishingly so.
- goatlover 3y ago"With so few concurrent civilizations, and such large distances, it is little surprise that the SETI project has not found that alien signal. Our nearest neighbor is 4 light years away, and there are under 100 stars within 50 light years, the total of the project's existence." That doesn't change Enrico Fermi's calculations on how long it might take an alien civilization to colonize the galaxy (max 100 million years). Or spam every solar system with Von Neumann probes. Or build giant radio emitters and send them out to various parts of the galaxy to ensure coverage. As long as there's a decent chance other alien civilizations have emerged before our own in the Milky Way, there is a paradox until we know why they aren't detectable. Or seeing Type 3 civilizations in other galaxies.
- yreg 3y ago>This was a very formative paper for me. If correct—and it certainly seems correct to me—then it completely dissolves the Fermi paradox. Could you please explain it then? Make the argument that dissolves FP.
- adastra22 3y agoThe paper shows that when multiplying seven unknown numbers together, the expected result is much, much less than multiplying seven fixed estimates together. Sagan et al come up with a long sequence of reasonable sounding estimates that when multiplied together result in, say, N=10000, that is ten thousand advanced civilizations in our own galaxy alone. But each one of the terms involved in that calculation was highly uncertain. This paper shows that if you multiply the probability distribution for N_a and N_b together and then sample, you get a value less than sampling N_a and N_b separately and then multiplying, as Drake, Sagan, et al do. If you perform the calculation properly using their very same estimated terms, but multiplying probability distributions instead of pre-sampling, you end up with an aggregate N value very close to 1. Meaning we should expect to be alone, and therefore no paradox.