3 ms·
This seems like the type of thing that feels good, but I don't buy that it is good without more justification. I've never read any compelling support for the id
by hayst4ck 3y ago
This seems like the type of thing that feels good, but I don't buy that it is good without more justification. I've never read any compelling support for the idea, it is almost always presented as obviously a good idea with little justification. It's proponents rarely seem to feel like it needs justifying and I greatly disagree.
The "revolving door" seems problematic. The politician -> industry bribery pathway seems like it would be strengthened by policy such as this.
The root problem is corruption, not experience. Corruption is a force that is happy to work on any system and I see no reason to believe that term limits would do anything to reduce corruption, only modulate it.
If the positions themselves are limited, it just pushes power and seniority into supporting positions such as staffers or the party apparatus itself, potentially even the think tanks/lobbyist groups that are often the entities that write the laws anyway.
The greater issue is that you are describing an idea of how to reduce corruption in terms of what politicians need to do. An iron law of reality is that you cannot control other people, at best you can influence them.
If you want to solve political problems you must ask "what can I do?" because talking about what politicians should do is glorified masturbation.
The answers are at least:
Get directly involved and run for a position of power and don't be corrupt when provided the opportunity to be
Never choose loyalty to a person over loyalty to ideas. Loyalty is the unit of corruption.
Get directly involved in the bureaucracy and use your position to do good and stifle bad
Use your position at work to practice professional ethics
Get involved with a union to provide consequences via striking, show solidarity
Get involved with investigative journalism to uncover corruption and speak truth to power
Get involved with campaigns to get candidates you don't believe are corrupt into positions of power
Get a good grasp on what fighting authoritarianism with force requires and meditate deeply on the use of guillotines or analogues
When someone else puts themselves at risk or sacrifices themselves to fight power, venerate them
Understand that "If none of us is prepared to die for freedom, then all of us will die under tyranny."
Educate yourself on the history of revolutionary movements and try to make complex ideas simple and viral
Understand that cynicism is coerced consent and that cynicism does not change anything