2 ms·
Is there a chance for an Everything alternative? That's the awesome tool that would allow you to ignore the depth/breadth completely find any file literally ins
by eviks 3y ago
Is there a chance for an Everything alternative? That's the awesome tool that would allow you to ignore the depth/breadth completely find any file literally instantly (the power of instant feedback is unapralleled)
Do non-NTFS systems (even the modern ones) not offer this?
- ksherlock 3y agoMac OS spotlight has more-or-less instant file search. Command-F in finder or mdfind in the terminal.
- eviks 3y agoExcept it's neither instant nor comprehensive, and those two features are what make Everything awesome
- toxik 3y agoI think you never actually used the mdfind search, only the bastardized version that is now available as Spotlight. That interface used to be good, now it’s so bad and slow I don’t know why they let this happen. But try mdfind with filenames, it is incredibly fast. Also for file content searches it is very fast also.
- mytec 3y agoI tried a quick search between mdfind, bfs, and find to locate all README.md files in my home directory. bfs and find both found 2930 files and took 8.5s and 47.5s respectively. mdfind took 0.1s but found only 2400 files.
- eviks 3y agoso what's the query to find a file anywhere on my hard drive, including hidden folders/files?
- tambourine_man 3y agoI don’t know what problems people have with Spotlight. It finds everything instantly for me. It’s my launcher, calculator…
- heyoni 3y agoFor starters, it hides system files by default.
- tambourine_man 3y agoI think that’s a good default. Most people don’t need to be messing with system files, the ones who do, can go through the extra trouble of checking a few preferences, using command line tools, setting up plist flags, etc.
- eviks 3y agoOh so you do know what problems people have with Spotlight, you just don't care about those problems to offer anything useful (your generic list isn't that since there are no preferences, cli tools, plist flags that would bring Everything to life on a Mac)
- tambourine_man 3y agoNo, I learned from this problem just now and think most users shouldn’t be messing with Library folder, etc, which is why it is hidden, and rightly so, IMO.
- abrookewood 3y agoJust adding the Everything is ridiculously fast - nothing comes close. https://www.voidtools.com/en-au/support/everything/ https://www.voidtools.com/en-au/support/everything/
- IggleSniggle 3y agoAnything that accesses the MFT directly will be faster than Everything, since Everything goes through the OS. That said, Everything has a superb design and indeed is extremely fast.
- wander_homer 3y agoEverything is using the MFT as well.
- leeman2016 3y agoHow about FSearch in Linux? [http://cboxdoerfer.github.io/fsearch/ http://cboxdoerfer.github.io/fsearch/]
- eviks 3y agoYes, FSearch is the one I use, but it's not as great, per FSearch's dev: > However, FSearch doesn't automatically detect changes made to the file system and update its index then. This is on the roadmap (it's called inotify support) but it'll never work as smooth as Everything on Windows, because the Linux kernel isn't particularly good at reporting filesystem changes https://github.com/cboxdoerfer/fsearch/issues/26 https://github.com/cboxdoerfer/fsearch/issues/26 Everything is comprehensive + instant + always up-to-date, that's so awesome a combo it's a pity it's Windows only
- mozball 3y agoDoesn't everything need to rebuild its database on every reboot? Was a minor annoyance the last time i remember using it.
- wander_homer 3y agoNo, upon start Everything loads its database file into RAM and queries the USN journal for all file system changes since the last time it was running. By applying those changes to its current database it automatically gets a consistent representation of the current state of the file system. This usually is much quicker than a full rebuild. Only when the USN journal doesn't go back enough in time will Everything rebuild its database by parsing the MFT (which is also much quicker than traversing the file system).
- mozball 3y agothe 'locate' command is faster than everything but arguably not as convenient (being a commandline tool). It seems to support non-ntfs (meaning it doesn't support ntfs) linux filesystems. edit: catfish is a gui front-end available for locate.
- pedrovhb 3y agoThere's plocate too, which is a bit faster still according to the authors.
- wander_homer 3y agolocate is much slower than Everything and it also has a much less powerful query language. With Everything you usually get results in way less than 100ms, whereas with locate it's several hundred milliseconds for a database with more than a million files.
- 112233 3y agoI have not used Everything, is it aomething similar to SwiftSearch (bypasses fs and parses ntfs disk directly, so no indexing and instant results) ?
- capableweb 3y agoIf the parent is talking about the Windows search software Everything (https://www.voidtools.com/ https://www.voidtools.com/), it does index the files (but unsure of how, it's relatively quick compared to other Windows tools that does the same, so probably some magic involved?) at startup, then continuously indexes (as far as I can tell) but then after that the searches are instant. Edit: Found some answers (https://www.voidtools.com/faq/ https://www.voidtools.com/faq/): Re indexing: > How long will it take to index my files? > "Everything" only indexes file and folder names and generally takes a few seconds to build its database. A fresh install of Windows 10 (about 120,000 files) will take about 1 second to index. 1,000,000 files will take about 1 minute. Re changes: > Does "Everything" monitor file system changes? > Yes, "Everything" does monitor your file systems for all changes. Your search results will update in real-time to reflect any changes. Everything will automatically keep your NTFS indexes up to date with the NTFS USN Journal. Changes will not be missed when Everything is not running as the system maintains the NTFS USN Journal.
- eviks 3y agoYes, exactly the principle as SwiftSearch - bypassing the slow fs and getting instant results (but ntfs only), and checking fs logs directly to keep track of all the updates