3 ms·
There are 1.5 billion cars in the world, and they all drive on a single plane on a very small percentage of the surface. Now increase the circumference by a lot
by paxys 3y ago
There are 1.5 billion cars in the world, and they all drive on a single plane on a very small percentage of the surface. Now increase the circumference by a lot and add a whole new dimension. I think we'll be fine.
- tasn 3y agoNot disagreeing with the conclusion, but cars are almost always stationary (parked) and when they do move they are many orders of magnitude slower than satellites. Which means it's not an obvious 1:1 comparison.
- ericpauley 3y agoCars also collide constantly despite best efforts to proactively avoid that. Not the sort of thing that’s desirable for satellites.
- albert_e 3y agoAnd cars are very maneuverable -- can stop, start, and turn in seconds; and can safely pass within inches of each other. (Most) cars also have one human each paying full attention to where it is going and controlling its path. Satellites don't have so many degrees of freedom. A bad way to extend the cars analogy is to compare with people. There are 8 billion of us and we walk around all the time but almost never get damaged by running into each other.
- martyvis 3y agoSatellites follow a extremely well known path and are tracked by the operators to a ridiculous level of precision. I can't imagine us needing more than 10 providers of 100K sats each at an upper limit. You could fit them all in a few (10 say) large football stadiums if you piled them up (a sat is probably 5m³ at most, a stadium is 100x100x50m so 500000m³)
- MegaDeKay 3y agoThere have already been six "Unintentional high-speed collisions between active satellites and orbital debris" [0], the most recent of which was in 2021. There is more to worry about than just tracking satellites following "extremely well known paths". You could have a situation like Intelsat 29e [1] where a satellite is torn to pieces, creating a debris field with parts too small to track. You can't avoid what you can't see. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_collision [1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/04/new-video-of-intelsat-29e-satellite-reveals-dramatic-anomaly/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/04/new-video-of-intelsa...
- robbiep 3y agoIt’s a great analogy but to nitpick a little I wouldn’t say the circumference is expanded ‘a lot’ - they’re generally in LEO at 5-600km so an additional 1000 km which is essentially 3,141.5 ish kilometres on top of 40,000ish - under 8%? Of course, each additional orbital plane is basically another set of roads but for all the internet sat constellations being planned extra distance = lag, hence we’re going to see the most growth in that LEO category
- placesalt 3y agoI looked it up, and LEO = <2000km altitude, and rEarth = ~6300m, so surface area of a sphere with r=6300km => ~500,000,000 km^2 surface area of a sphere with r=8300km => ~860,000,000 km^2 so roughly 1.5x the surface area at max LEO compared to earth's surface (feel free to correct me if my arithmetic is off :)
- Cogito 3y agoUnfortunately it's the wrong comparison to make. Two cars sitting still in a car park won't collide with each other, but there's no way to sit still in orbit. Any two circular orbits at the same altitude will intersect at two points. You have to be very careful to make sure objects in such orbits will not collide with each other. It's far easier to make the orbits slightly different sizes or shapes, so that they don't intersect at all. In any case, the need to be in an orbit to stay in orbit severely restricts your free choices for where to put your objects, so there is not as much free space as you might expect.
- robbiep 3y agono problems with that, but the internet sats all seem to be aiming for 500-600 (Starlink) up to 1000km. it's lots of 'space' :)
- zulban 3y agoOne critical thing you're missing is that when cars smash into each other, the debris stops moving soon, and a spec doesn't completely destroy other cars a week later.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAnd most debris from a VLEO collision deorbit in under an hour. Kuiper isn't in VLEO, but any larger constellations likely will be.
- elif 3y agoAlso car interactions are seldom between competing space programs or warring nationalities with their own interests and limits on maneuvering capability and energy expense quotas. Collision avoidance at spaceX is largely automated but for most operators there is a wide variety of response capability
- SilasX 3y agoBut cars constantly have traffic jams, so this doesn’t work as an argument a fortriori (basically, showing that a generous bound has been loosened).
- raydiatian 3y agoI’m excited for the part where interstellar travel stops being a viable human endeavor because we littered LEO with more of fucking Jeff Bezos’ boxes.
- larperdoodle 3y agoAren't all these communications satellites in a low orbit that will decay in 5-10 years?
- raydiatian 3y agoare they? That’s a promising thought actually
- jkmcf 3y agoBut, think of the astronomers! These LEO satellite internet companies need to pay a tax to fund more space telescopes!