4 ms·
> it shifts open source from a community concept to something that a company lets you have with a bunch of conditions. Because you think that Protobuf, Android
by palata 3y ago
> it shifts open source from a community concept to something that a company lets you have with a bunch of conditions.
Because you think that Protobuf, Android, Chromium, and all the other open source projects by Big Tech are there for the community? It's about control.
Not saying it's fundamentally bad, but you can't deny that the fact that Android exists means that it is very difficult to get adoption for an alternative "open" mobile OS, and Google benefits greatly from it. Same for Chromium, and basically everything.
When Big Tech open sources something, it's a strategic decision. Not philanthropy.
- Shawnj2 3y agoThe LLM world has been really good at bootstrapping models so I’m sure this will be used to create something exactly or more powerful than it without using any of its existing code.
- psd1 3y agoProtobuf seems like the odd one out. I understood that googlers created it for their own benefit and tossed it over the wall because "why not". Am I mistaken?
- palata 3y agoI don't know about the actual decision, but I can see the result: Protobuf is ubiquitous. Now take it like this: if Protobuf was not open source, wouldn't there be an alternative? I would say probably, since there are already alternatives (just not as popular as Protobuf). So from Google's perspective, not open sourcing Protobuf does not really give them an edge: alternatives exist. However, by open sourcing it, they end up with a ton of devs who learn Protobuf outside of Google. That makes it easier for Google technology to be adopted if they release something new, and when they hire a new engineer, it's a win if he already knows Protobuf. Same applies to gRPC and others.