4 ms·
Insurance companies are trying to bail on the California market and using any excuse to do so. The state insurance commissioner (an elected official) is said to
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Insurance companies are trying to bail on the California market and using any excuse to do so. The state insurance commissioner (an elected official) is said to be asleep at the switch, to the point that there is a grassroots movement to recall him, which to my knowledge has never happened.
The drone/aerial surveillance is the headline here, but the real issue is that insurers are unilaterally canceling policies without any sort of grace period or remediation possibility. Bear in mind that if you lose your home insurance and don't sign a new policy, a lender can and usually will foreclose upon it.
- sgerenser 3y agoI’ve never heard of a lender foreclosing for no insurance. Usually they’ll force sign you up for some captive insurance company or insurance of last resort, and add the cost onto your monthly payment.
- pwg 3y ago> Usually they’ll force sign you up for some captive insurance company or insurance of last resort, This has been my experience when the lender screws up and fails to accurately record the insurance information. Then, near the expiration date, when they check, and find nothing, one gets a nasty-gram in the mail berating one for failing to maintain insurance, and indicating that if they don't get proof of insurance within 15 days of the date on the letter (of which at least five days has usually already lapsed), they will apply their own insurance, to the tune of 4x the cost of the actual insurance that is still valid and active.
- Simulacra 3y agoBear in mind that if you lose your home insurance and don't sign a new policy, a lender can and usually will foreclose upon it. That should be illegal for the foreclosure. There should be a grace period. What if your insurance company goes bankrupt, or some other calamity?
- mgraczyk 3y agoI would prefer not to subsidize other people the way you're describing.
- xadhominemx 3y agoOf course there is a grace period. Lenders lose a lot of money on the typical foreclosure and are in no rush to foreclose upon a property. They will work with the homeowner for a while to resolve any issues before resorting to foreclosure.
- alistairSH 3y agoI understand your sentiment, but the mortgage was issued conditional on maintaining home insurance. Without an active policy, the lender is subject to much greater risk. If the house burns down sans insurance, the lender is now SOL. And as the sibling response states, foreclosure is rarely a fast process. The problem is it can be very hard to find a policy if there's a gap in coverage, even more so if insurers are leaving the market.
- ljf 3y agoI don't know about the US but in the UK you can sort out new insurance in a few minutes - though one of the questions is usually 'have you ever had an insurance policy canceled or refused' - answering yes to that can cause significant issues. Lying and getting found out later causes even more problems.
- alistairSH 3y agoSimilar here (varies by state). Switching from an active policy to a new policy is usually easy. Gaps in coverage, especially when a policy was canceled for cause, can be a problem. CA and FL have their own problems due to local weather/climate (fires, hurricanes) and insurance regulations. Insurers are jacking up rates in FL and leaving that market. I'm not as familiar with CA, but it sounds like they're doing the same there.
- hobotime 3y agoIf this continues, property values in California could sink because you have to purchase them with non-borrowed funds.
- constantly 3y agoWho is saying the commissioner is asleep at the switch?
- Zircom 3y agoPresumably the people trying to recall him?
- anigbrowl 3y agoSorry, forgot to include a link about that. I don't have a strong opinion on whether the insurance commissioner is at fault or not. https://www.kpbs.org/news/economy/2023/07/07/californias-homeowners-insurance-crisis-is-growing-and-spreading-to-car-insurance https://www.kpbs.org/news/economy/2023/07/07/californias-hom...
- madsbuch 3y agowhy are they trying to get out of California?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LorenPechtel 3y agoNormally they'll do a forced placement rather than foreclose. You'll get a bad deal on the insurance but there will be insurance on the house (not necessarily on anything else, though!)
- JohnFen 3y ago> Bear in mind that if you lose your home insurance and don't sign a new policy, a lender can and usually will foreclose upon it. But if this happens in sufficient numbers, then lenders will likely rethink that policy. No lender wants to foreclose, and particularly if there's no chance that they'll be able to sell the property for enough to cover the costs of foreclosing.
- AustinWentz 3y ago>Bear in mind that if you lose your home insurance and don't sign a new policy, a lender can and usually will foreclose upon it. Are you sure this is correct? In this situation, lenders will usually do something called a force-placed insurance: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1024/37/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/102....
- LorenPechtel 3y agoIt's not that he's asleep at the switch. Rather, people blame the insurance commission when insurance gets expensive. However, when companies are leaving the market it's clear rates are too *low*. Note that this is sometimes the result of those in high risk situations managing to get the legislature to require the risk to be spread to others to keep their rates from being insane. (Florida is a prime example--they're spreading the cost from property on the front line for hurricane damage across wider areas, so now everybody's insurance is high rather than some being completely uninsurable.) While I have not kept up with the California situation I suspect something of the sort is going on, they aren't being allowed to look at local wildfire risk in setting premiums.
- 2020aj 3y agoThis is exactly the case. The commission won't let companies take adequate rate, so most companies are unable to make a profit in the state and are pulling out. Doesn't make sense to stay in a market where you're forced to lose money most years. (I work in pricing for a large insurer)
- MichaelZuo 3y agoMarket forces always win in the long run.
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoNo sane company wants to leave a market the size of California on the table. They are leaving because the risk is just too high. There is nothing Commissioner Lara can do about the risk analysis associated with the previous 20 years of wildfire. IF Californians don't change their collective behavior around addressing the issues related to wildfire risk, its unlikely they'll be able to maintain coverage.
- anigbrowl 3y agoBut the guy isn't in a wildfire risk zone. He just has a slightly untidy yard in a suburb. And I do mean 'slightly', go watch the news report. It's not a junkyard and the company's argument here isn't credible.
- rasz 3y agoIts not untidy, but it is an open air workshop on residential property.
- anigbrowl 3y agoLast time I looked people were entitled to work on their own possessions on their own land. The guy has some neatly stacked spare tires and replacement wheels for his two motor vehicles and a work bench, he's not running a smelter or manufacturing explosives.
- navi0 3y agoI'm not going to win points for defending a megacorp, but if this person wants to self-insure (and owns his home outright), then he would be entitled to do so. But until the mortgage is paid and he is able to self-insure, the insurance company sets the rules. Put differently, if a fire were to happen and this open air mechanics/tire shop were to ignite and destroy the three neighboring properties, is this homeowner entitled enough to pay all damages caused by his negligent storage of combustible materials? [edit] Plenty of notice should have been provided so the property owner had an opportunity to address the issues found, which may or may not have happened. We only have one side of the story here.