4 ms·
> Sooo… that’s 30 * 48 / (24 * 7) = 8.60/hour. Literally still more than some other jobs, and meanwhile by this math you're getting paid while you're asleep or
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Sooo… that’s 30 * 48 / (24 * 7) = 8.60/hour.
Literally still more than some other jobs, and meanwhile by this math you're getting paid while you're asleep or drinking with your friends.
> Without overtime: 70 normal hours * $30 = $2100
What typically happens: Farmer hires 75% more people so none of them get overtime but now they each make 57% as much money because they've each had their hours cut.
> So yeah, raise the price of asparagus by 21%, to reflect the actual cost of picking, or better yet have the owners take a 21% pay cut.
Food is a global commodity. The margins aren't 21% and if you try to raise the price buyers will just get it from someone in a different country.
- kennywinker 3y agoAs someone else pointed out, it would be far far less than 21%, since labour is not the only cost of production. A 21% increase in labour costs doesn’t mean total costs go up by 21%. > Literally still more than some other jobs, and meanwhile by this math you're getting paid while you're asleep or drinking with your friends. This is big “a pizza party is good compensation for overtime” energy, my guy. If you’re AT work you’re working.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> As someone else pointed out, it would be far far less than 21%, since labour is not the only cost of production. A 21% increase in labour costs doesn’t mean total costs go up by 21%. > Labor accounts for half of the costs The margins aren't 10.5% either, and they can't go below the market rate of return or the farm shuts down because the land and equipment is worth more than it generates. Which it was already so close to before this happened that many of them already have. This isn't Apple, it's a farm. > If you’re AT work you’re working. Slogans-as-hard-rules that don't take into account context is why labor laws consistently hurt workers. Can you see why a worker might prefer this arrangement to one in which they're paid e.g. $12/hour for 40 hours, and are consequently upset at having it be prohibited?
- kennywinker 3y ago> > Labor accounts for half of the costs The actual quote is: > Labor accounts for half of the costs, he says Unless he shows me his books, I’m not gonna believe that on just his word. Neither should you. > The margins aren't 11.5% either Again, I’d have to see his books before I concluded that the margins didn’t leave room for a <11.5% raise in labour costs. Remember - it would be less, since as he said only the most skilled cutters are earning +$30/hour.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Labor accounts for half of the costs, he says "He" is the farmer. Who else would even know? > Again, I’d have to see his books before I concluded that the margins didn’t leave room for a <11.5% raise in labour costs. Books are just spreadsheets. They contain no authentication. You don't trust his word but you trust him to give you accurate numbers? We don't need some specific farmer's accounts to know which businesses have low margins. Farming is a notoriously competitive industry with razor-thin margins because the product is a fungible global commodity. > Remember - it would be less, since as he said only the most skilled cutters are earning +$30/hour. The 21% increase comes from paying 50% more for 30 of 70 hours, (0.5 x 30)/70 = 21%, the same percentage regardless of the base hourly wage. But it's actually worse than that, because for the overtime hours it's a 50% increase. Which is why they immediately get cut.
- mcphage 3y ago> What typically happens: Farmer hires 75% more people so none of them get overtime but now they each make 57% as much money because they've each had their hours cut. Wouldn't that also increase rates, since you need to hire more laborers, which means the demand for labor increases? Another possibility, is lower peoples' rates to $24.80—40 hours at $24.80/hr + 30 hours at overtime = $2108, so the same as they were being paid before. Or something in between.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Wouldn't that also increase rates, since you need to hire more laborers, which means the demand for labor increases Only if farm work is such a large proportion of the market for unskilled labor that it would move the entire market, which it isn't. And even if it was, paying more would raise costs which would cause marginal farms to fail and lower labor demand again. > Another possibility, is lower peoples' rates to $24.80—40 hours at $24.80/hr + 30 hours at overtime = $2108, so the same as they were being paid before. Those people don't want to work for $24.80/hour instead of $30 for most of the year just to be able to get overtime during harvest season. You might offer to pay them less during that time for the same kind of work, but this is the sort of thing the government sometimes gets mad at you for, because then you're transparently thwarting their inefficient price controls. And you have to ask what's the point of the law if the best case scenario is that you can find a way to cause the rule to have no effect.
- mcphage 3y ago> And you have to ask what's the point of the law if the best case scenario is that you can find a way to cause the rule to have no effect. I was looking for a way to have the rule cause no harm—everybody works the same hours, and gets paid the same.