3 ms·
I took slight offence at the passage "a live performance of a great symphony, in which musical instruments played by humans are never perfectly in tune and occa
by tgv 3y ago
I took slight offence at the passage "a live performance of a great symphony, in which musical instruments played by humans are never perfectly in tune and occasionally quite far out of tune" after mentioning the Wiener Philharmoniker. I don't think they ever play out of tune.
I did hear orchestras play out of tune occasionally, but it has never been an agreeable experience. It never made me think "how human". Instead, hearing a botched entry in the chorale in Mendelssohn 5 helped me understand the brass players' addiction to beta blockers.
- jefftk 3y ago> ... mentioning the Wiener Philharmoniker. I don't think they ever play out of tune. On the contrary: they never play in tune. They are consistently 12 cents sharp! (They play A=443, when most of the world uses A=440. Joking not joking.)