3 ms·
The fire department turns up when your house is on fire, sprays water on the house, and goes home when the fire is out. Their work is well defined and self-con
by cperciva 15y ago
The fire department turns up when your house is on fire, sprays water on the house, and goes home when the fire is out. Their work is well defined and self-contained.
Medicine is a completely different situation: As people get sicker, you can dump practically unlimited amounts of money on them to extend their lives by a few more days. If you're not willing or not capable of deciding who is worth treating (aka "government death panels") and don't want unsustainable government spending, the only solution is to not get into the business at all (and let insurance companies take the blame for saying that little Johnny's cancer is too expensive to treat).
- dclowd9901 15y agoExactly. The problem with health care is that a person's life is worth as much as they're worth. It's easier to say, "I'm sorry ma'am, we can't send anyone into that burning house, otherwise, they'll be killed," than it is to say, "I'm sorry ma'am, but at best, we can do this experimental procedure with a 10% chance of extending his life for a year, but it's prohibitively expensive. This is, obviously, and extension of the problem of those with the resources (money) not wanting their life to be weighed equally with someone who has little or no monetary value associated with their continuing existence.
- angersock 15y agoThen we probably need to come to terms with losing our loved ones, because this is intractable. I'd rather have "death panels" than the current situation.
- cperciva 15y agoI agree. I just hope we can have panels which weigh diseases impartially. The UK did this for a while via their National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, measuring the cost per QALY, but now the politicians have stepped in and decided that cancer treatments are "special" and should be funded up to a higher limit -- which is really saying that they're willing to kill two people who don't have cancer to save the life of one person who has cancer.