3 ms·
> A photograph is supposed not to evoke but to show. That is why photographs, unlike handmade images, can count as evidence. While this is mostly a good piece
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> A photograph is supposed not to evoke but to show. That is why photographs, unlike handmade images, can count as evidence.
While this is mostly a good piece of writing, in the real world handmade images (and handwritten notes) are, like photographs, potentially evidence, and the issues raised with photographs are the reasons both photographs and hand-written/hand-drawn items (and all other physical items) as evidence tend to demand supporting (and admit opposing) testimonial and physical evidence of provenance (and, the physical evidence offered for this purpose has the same features, such that ultimately, it all rests on testimonial evidence of provenance.)
I also don't think the first parr of the sentence is true: pictures may be supposed to show, but pictures have been noted for their evocative power long before this piece was written—pictures are in certaim circumstances understood to show, and under other and frequently overlapping circumstances to evoke; there is certainly a common danger in mistaking evocative power for also indicating informative power, but few anywhere have denied the existence of the evocative power of photography.
- rexpop 3y agoThat's a fair critique. One might ask "supposed by whom, exactly?" In English, supposition too frequently implements the unforgivable passive voice.