3 ms·
> blank check by-all-means research Sorry to derail, but I'm utterly confounded that cancer research, life extension research, brain-computer research, etc. h
by echelon 3y ago
> blank check by-all-means research
Sorry to derail, but I'm utterly confounded that cancer research, life extension research, brain-computer research, etc. haven't been given this "by-all-means" approach. It's one thing to defeat a geopolitical rival, it's quite another to escape annihilation for just a bit longer.
One might assume religiosity is the cause, but atheist nations aren't investing in it either.
If anything was deserving of another moonshot / Manhattan project, I think that would be it.
- ghaff 3y agoEven the Manhattan project didn't have an unlimited pool of top-level scientists. At some point, pouring in more money [ADDED: especially to somewhat vague goals] doesn't give a lot of incremental results. I'd be a lot more convinced if there were evidence that there were top-level, productive scientists in important fields that would be producing world-changing results if they were only given more money. (Of course, they all would like more money and resources.)
- bena 3y agoDon't confuse results with effort. "Cancer" is a nebulous area. You can't really study "cancer". Cancer isn't a disease. It's a class of diseases characterized by a breakdown of your own cells' reproductive process. Not to mention, it's a breakdown that can just happen. You can take every precaution, avoid every carcinogen, and still get cancer. The biggest predictor to whether or not you will get cancer is time. The longer you live, the greater your chances. And we might "get" cancer far more often than we realize. It's just that our bodies do have ways to excise cancer from our own bodies. It's just that sometimes, it's not enough. And there is a lot of research that goes into cancer prevention and treatment. But it's not like one day we'll have the anti-cancer pill. That's just magical thinking. Life extension research is also in a weird place. Because, like cancer, there isn't just one thing that ends our life. It's a host of things. And a lot of those things are being looked into. And we've already made amazing strides. We are able to get way more people to advanced ages than before. Prior to modernity, it was basically luck as to whether or not you'd make it to 60. And I don't even know what you want to mean by "brain-computer" research. But I assume it would eventually involve fucking around with living brains. You absolutely cannot make a mistake there. You don't go poking around in the brains of healthy people unless you want to make them very unhealthy, very quickly. So each of the things you've picked out are vague and/or fraught with their own perils. Chucking a meat-filled metal tube at a space rock and getting the meat back is an objective with a clear goal. And also, I'd like to point out, that failure was an option. Michael Collins was trained in everybody's job just in case he had to come back alone. During the first orbit, when he was out of contact with everybody for 48 minutes, he had no idea what he would find when he came back around. That and this was a process of years. The mission that landed on the moon was Apollo 11. Preceded by the Gemini program, whose main purpose was to lead into the Apollo program. 8 years for the singular goal of having a man go to the moon and return. "Curing cancer" is not the same. "Brain research" is not the same. "Life extension" is not the same. Pick one thing. One simple goal. Not "cure cancer", but something like "make non-nauseating chemotherapy". Then dedicate 8 years to achieving that one task, no matter the cost. Which is something they do do. Any time you see something about "targeted cancer medications", that's to end-run around chemotherapy. Because chemotherapy is kind of like setting your house on fire to get rid of termites.
- DoughnutHole 3y agoIt’s because there’s no roadmap to success here. The Manhattan project and the moonshot were implementation problems, not theoretical ones. By 1939 we knew that a runaway nuclear reaction was possible and Werner von Braun probably could have worked out the fuel you’d need to get to the moon on the back of a napkin. It took a lot of ingenuity to get there, but both problems seemed achievable given enough resources. On the other hand, we don’t even know where to begin to “cure cancer”, because it’s thousands of different diseases with different causes and prognoses. There are cancers that essentially are curable with enough of a headstart. Of the ones that we’ve “cured” there’s little in common in their origins and they all have wildly different treatments. Curing cancer isn’t dumping money at solving one achievable problem - it’s an open-ended investment in tackling thousands of independent problems. There are ideas for universal treatments for cancer and aging - hundreds of them. Which ones do we dump our billions and billions into investigating?
- light_hue_1 3y agoOf course we know how to begin. We're doing it as we speak! Cancer survival rates are constantly getting better. The payback for investment in biotech research has been huge and even bigger dividends are on the horizon. Look at the Hepatitis drugs and weight loss drugs that actually work. These along will address the leading causes of death today. Coming soon is xenotransplantation. Already we're experimenting with hearts. The outlook is that in 10 years we'll routinely be doing this. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10143783/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10143783/ > There are ideas for universal treatments for cancer and aging - hundreds of them. Which ones do we dump our billions and billions into investigating? There really aren't. The basic technology is mostly the same. And we have a system for deciding what to spend money on: scientists write grants, get some funding, show results, and then we repeat at a bigger scale seeing who can deliver the best results. It's not perfect, but it works. Cancer deaths today are a choice we make as a society to not invest in research. We can't "cure cancer" tomorrow, but even with the tiny resources allocated today we're making significant progress. We could do so much more! For example, in the 70s 5-year survival across all cancers was 58%. Now it's 85%.
- 3y ago
- abecedarius 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_cancer I'm pretty sure Apollo was a political model for this ongoing "war on cancer" launched in 1971.