8 ms·
> Nobody really expects to be able to find anything of value in a Google search now This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only make
by Aurornis 3y ago
> Nobody really expects to be able to find anything of value in a Google search now
This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only makes sense when you're in a deep bubble and entirely removed from the average person's use of the internet.
Deliberately removing yourself from Google is fine for the author who is more concerned about taking an ideological stance than they are about being discoverable, but removing yourself from Google is terribly bad advice for anyone who wants to help people find their content.
Many people do use Google to find content and people, even if you don't.
- epolanski 3y agoI guess it is kinda true for the author, average person isn't looking for his content and his public will find other ways.
- codetrotter 3y agoIf everyone on HN stopped using Google and started using DuckDuckGo. And we told all our friends and family to do the same. Would it have an impact?
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y ago> If everyone on HN stopped using Google and started using DuckDuckGo *Bing, DuckDuckGo's own indexing is fairly limited compared to other search providers like Brave. Most of DDG's index comes from Bing.
- FireInsight 3y agoI used to love Brave search for this reason. Now I can never seem to find what I'm looking for, even for a simple search for some product a bit more obscure or smth the results are always wayy off from what I'm looking for. It is sad if it's due to their usage of entirely their own index, I was happy with that mix of Bing&Brave.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoEveryone on HN isn't enough to have an impact. And telling friends and family isn't good enough because changing default behaviors is very difficult in practice and they would listen do you, but ultimately keep doing what they're doing.
- OO000oo 3y agoI agree, but when my 70 yo mother was visiting last month I watched her look something up on her ipad and she typed in "duckduckgo.com" to do it! I was amazed and asked how she learned to do that. Apparently, she learned it from me! She said she thinks it gives better results. Then I set it to her default search engine so she wouldn't have to type it.
- reaperducer 3y ago70 yo mother was visiting last month I watched her look something up on her ipad and she typed in "duckduckgo.com" If you want your mother to bake you cookies, tell her she only needs to type "duck.com," not "duckduckgo.com." At least until today. Now I get: Application error: a client-side exception has occurred (see the browser console for more information).
- JoshTriplett 3y agoddg.gg still works.
- codetrotter 3y agoddg.co as well :D
- kulahan 3y agoBro, I'M about to bake you some cookies for this shortcut.
- dewey 3y agoNot even on HN people are united in preferring Google. Personally I tried to switch many times and always made my way back, and I'm not even really in the Google ecosystem unlike others.
- scrum-treats 3y agoGoogle Search was awesome until it was ruined by Ads. Such a shame. There's dorking, however Google is actively de-indexing content, so much so that it makes you wonder what (monetary) motivation Google is serving with Search because it's not "information for all" anymore. The term "sell out" comes to mind, which sucks when you think about how cool Google was (i.e., the best and brightest doing the most so you could also do the most).
- mrguyorama 3y ago>because it's not "information for all" anymore. Anyone who has thought google was doing anything good after they bought doubleclick is living in fantasy land. They pretty much immediately started playing advertising extortion games and they optimize for more viewed google ads with things like AMP and making ads harder to notice. Google stopped caring about "information for all" the second after they made their original research paper and realized they had a significant competitive advantage to make some money with.
- code_duck 3y agoI have been using DDG as the default on all of my browsers for several years. However, there are still searches where I am not finding exactly what I want, and using the !g to perform the same search on Google comes up with better results. I don’t use Google unless I have to, and agree it has been degraded, but the idea that it’s now useless is unrealistic.
- bigbacaloa 3y agoIt would have an impact. None of us would find anything of value at all.
- scrum-treats 3y agoKinda... DuckDuckGo allows for supplement of Google Search, as does Brave, and other search engines. Google freaked out after the ChatGPT release (rightly so) and padded their hand a bit. Impact would probably be Ads via Google Search Engine. Which, great, because Google Ads-generated results remain a huge vulnerability in terms of active phishing attacks. Maybe it's gotten better in the last month, however I don't really use Google Search anymore, to avoid phishing attacks. And, this is one reason why I like Brave, because I can control what content cannot appear in my search results, to better mitigate phishing attacks.
- Aurornis 3y agoGoogle has over 4 billion monthly active users. HN has about 1/1000th of that. They do not click every link or make decisions in unison, so the number of people who would interested in such a boycott is probably 1/100th of that. Maybe less. So, no.
- xwdv 3y ago> This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only makes sense when you're in a deep bubble and entirely removed from the average person's use of the internet. The average person isn’t going to google an individual to find their blogs or whatever. The first stop is figuring out their social media destinations. You would hardly expect to find really anything about a person on Google that isn’t a link to their socials. Or perhaps an article related to some crime.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 3y ago>The average person isn’t going to google an individual to find their blogs or whatever. I guess I'm not the average person but, sure I would. (Though I might look on LinkedIn first especially if I knew their employer.) A Google search would presumably return social media handles among other things.
- deltarholamda 3y ago>This is a categorically false premise This is accurate, somewhat. A lot of people do expect to find things of value when the use Google to search. But people who are more technical know it's a bit of a faff and bother to get Google to spit out what you're actually looking for, outside of "who is Chloe Grace Moretz" or something equally banal. And Google-the-Company does treat the Internet like it is their corporate property. Alphabet won't change unless it's made to do so.
- distortedsignal 3y agoI'm not sure that I agree. My brother tried to set me up with a girl last week. She has a pretty uncommon name. Googled her. Found... a lot of stuff. I have a VERY common name. Think multiple (relatively) famous people (photographers, US Medal of Honor winner, enough lawyers to choke a court system for DECADES), but if you google my name and the city I live in (1,000,000+ people), my LinkedIn is like the second result. For everyone saying that Google has gotten worse over the time they've been using it, these two use cases (which are pretty challenging) do really still work.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoAnd did you Google yourself on a clean computer?
- distortedsignal 3y agoTried this test three ways - from my wifi, on my phone's LTE connection, and via a VPN that my family uses, all in private windows to prevent Google using my local cache. All found my LinkedIn in the top 2 slots. It seems pretty stable to me? How could I make this cleaner?
- ghaff 3y agoThat sounds pretty thorough for the purpose. I think the parent's point was just that if you naively Google yourself without doing anything special, your own results will tend to percolate to the top more so than if a random person were to Google you.
- jijji 3y agoGoogle from 10 years ago is much different from the Google that we see in use today... results are much different it's hard to find what you're looking for.... then of course you have the first page covered with ads so that makes it that much more difficult... then there's the negative changes that they made to the instant searching where you type in keywords and then it provides suggestions which are completely not related to anything that's popular that you might be searching for... The one example that is still true today is when typing "men can", google instant will still show "men can get pregnant", "men can lactate", "men can have periods" as the top results...
- greiskul 3y agoThe web from 10 years ago is very different from the web today. High quality content is found more and more in closed gardens like Discord. The spammers have gotten better and better tools to automate their production of low quality trash more and more. A lot of tech people have started to use the trick of adding reddit to their query, since it is one of the few bastions of actual human beings talking in volume in the open web. But even that might stop working, if reddit decides to close itself to google, and the way their leadership is doing things, I wouldn't doubt it.
- ghusto 3y ago> This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only makes sense when you're in a deep bubble and entirely removed from the average person's use of the internet. I'm not convinced, though accept that this could be because I am in that bubble. I can't imagine this average person searching for me on Google, finding nothing (which they won't, because I did the same as the author long ago), and concluding that there is nothing to find. Especially since nobody who has tried to find information about me after real life encounters has stopped at Google. The more persistent ones did eventual find bits and pieces, but admittedly they were more technically inclined. Even so, none of them — technical or not — presumed that there _wasn't_ anything to find.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt may depend on the audience you want to reach. I've blocked webcrawlers from my websites for years now, so you can't find them on Google (or most other search engines). But plenty of people find them anyway because my audience shares links with each other, puts links on sites that are indexed by search engines, etc. If I were addressing a more general audience, this might not work as well.
- srsQ 3y agoFrom my reference frame, “being discoverable” is an ideological stance. You can have your tribal perceptions and others are allowed theirs. Social norms are immutable physics. Other people’s content is over rated; I’ve been soaking it up for years and frankly none of it has been as moving as the effort of making my own. Social codependency at scale is proving toxic to the species. We can intentionally “great filter” by winding down globalism. Whether or not humanity does eventually won’t be up to us; appeals to preserve our BS are appeals to some greater good. No one will owe us that after we die.
- all2 3y agoI find this opinion to be solipsistic, but also relevant to the discussion because it moves the focus from consumption to production. I find the focus on producing goods/services/etc. to be more palatable than the consumption focused mindset we often see. Yes, we're all looking for information, but should we only consume as a way of life? I'll leave that as an open-ended question.
- bachmeier 3y ago> This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only makes sense when you're in a deep bubble and entirely removed from the average person's use of the internet. I mean no harm by this comment, but I think you're the one living in a bubble. Do you watch high school students using the internet? Where do they go for information? Reddit is the first place they look. Then they look for a Discord server. Google is a last resort, but since they know it's probably just going to return crappy SEO spam articles, they may give up entirely without even trying Google. Your answer is technically accurate, but only in the sense that it disproves the "nobody" part of the statement because of the population of users age 45+. Google has lost their place as the site to use when you want to find information.
- l33t233372 3y agoIf a highschooler is using reddit to find information, I guarantee they find the thread through google.
- pperi11 3y agoI literally search "xyz reddit" on google if i want reddit refs lol
- dmoy 3y agoTo be fair reddit internal search is terrible
- Arrath 3y agoA truth since time immemorial: built-in search for forums sucks, terribly.
- dylan604 3y agoto be fair, the argument that people don't use google while someone is saying they use google while limiting to a specific site is more the point. while reddit's internal search is terrible is not really the point even if a motivator. googs is still being used nullifying whatever the point of the start of this topic was
- devilsAdv0cate 3y ago[dead]
- myth2018 3y ago> This is a categorically false premise. The kind of statement that only makes sense when you're in a deep bubble and entirely removed from the average person's use of the internet Not entirely false, I would say. I see more and more non-techies getting tired with their search results, instinctly expecting to see a variety of poorly-formatted, extremely poorly-written, ad-ridden sites. I believe more and more people will wake as Google pushes the boundaries of good sense. This will lead to a decrease in qualified traffic, but that won't demotivate Google -- anyone who already ran ads targeting a niche public knows that Google will burn your monthly budget, and they won't hesitate to override your parameters to make that happen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- m463 3y agoI use ddg, but I'm weird.
- wolverine876 3y ago> categorically false What does categorically false mean?
- pickingdinner 3y agoFalse category. Like saying an apple is a vegetable. Categorically false. Here, the category of "no one" is incorrect. Correct category may be, as per the comment, "those taking an ideological stance."
- sciyoshi 3y agoBecause I was curious about this: the use of "categorically" in the phrase "categorically false" doesn't directly relate to the concept of "categories" as groups or classes of things. Turns out it's actually related to the philosophical use of the term which originated with Aristotle and was further developed by Kant (see "categorical imperative" on Wikipedia). "categorically" in this situation is used to emphasize the absolute, unambiguous, and unconditional nature of the falseness.
- softsound 3y agoYeah agreed. People who are not good with tech with certainly use Google especially if they grew up with it. Yes, search results are bad, but are you using duckduckgo instead? No, you are still using a Google search to get somewhere even if it's just to use it to find a another site with better pages. Maybe you are using Bing though I know some folks were liked Bing... Now if you want to argue people are using TikTok as a main search engine now that's a bit different (that's of course not accurate as it has terrible search just like reddit) But yeah even Google knows people are only using it to find Reddit pages now (which is Reddit started the whole API issue) and why Google and Reddit are fighting a little.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ricardobayes 3y agoI agree, Google is still pretty good when it comes to ranking. Tried a few alternative search engines are the results are weird at best.
- snyda 3y ago[flagged]