3 ms·
wonder if there is a perceptual color system that accounts for the rare fourth color receptor... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrachromacy#Tetrachromacy_in_c
by LoganDark 3y ago
wonder if there is a perceptual color system that accounts for the rare fourth color receptor...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrachromacy#Tetrachromacy_in_carriers_of_CVD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrachromacy#Tetrachromacy_in...
don't know if that would be reproducible on a regular RGB display, though
- orbital-decay 3y agoThere isn't even a way to account for individual differences, let alone for things like tetrachromacy. Color blindness is probably easier (at least crudely), but AFAIK it also varies between the same types. So unless you profile your perception individually, we're stuck with the biggest cluster of the "average human vision system".
- cubefox 3y ago> don't know if that would be reproducible on a regular RGB display, though It wouldn't, and also not with standard camera sensors. The RGB subpixels correspond to the main wave length sensitivity of the three color cells in the eye. I think for tetrachromy there is a fourth cell for UV light with shorter wavelength than blue. There is no way to support this with our current tech stack.
- LoganDark 3y agothis reminds me of how designing for "the average human" leaves out anyone with even slightly superhuman capabilities, and how frustrating this is for us when our capabilities surpass what designers thought were good enough. for us, this happens frequently with monitor PPI and HMD PPD, but i can imagine someone with tetrachromy theoretically being able to perceive colors that computers can't reproduce, and wondering why computers lack these colors, only to find that this is supposedly an impossibility that was optimized out as an example, apple's new HMD advertises things that simply can't possibly be true, so we probably won't be getting one any time soon. there's zero reason to upgrade from a simple hp reverb g2 when the only difference between two blurry headsets is that one of them costs four times more. we'd rather be conscious of this than try to fix it when no solution currently exists this isn't saying displays for tetrachromy should have been the norm, as that's very wasteful on most people. but maybe displays for tetrachromy could have existed, somewhere, in some market, just like tech devices with placebo-level specs tend to exist in some market
- cubefox 3y agoI was surprised by your pronoun usage, then I clicked on your profile. Reminded me to think of the ambiguity of the English "you", in contrast to "I"/"we". Edit: To add a bit to the topic. Tetrachromy seems a quite interesting example for "superhuman" sensory ability. Normal people have three cone cells, and the maximum/minimum activation of each cell gives rise to 2^3=8 "primary" subjectively dissimilar colors: 000 (black), 001 (blue), 010 (green), 011 (cyan), 100 (red), 101 (magenta), 110 (yellow), 111 (white). All the others look like blends of the former. But for tetrachromy there are 2^4=16 different such "primary" colors. That's a substantial difference.
- LoganDark 3y agoyeah i wish there were an easier way to say we have DID than making multiple HN accounts, we were even personally recommended to do that by HN's moderation team but opted not to because we need the shared rep and comments. including a disclaimer in every comment (which we have to do if we include a signature, because then people will ask what the signature means) is also somewhat tiring, so right now the pronoun usage is a bit of an unsolved problem, hehe. glad to see the profile did its job though as for the edit, another commenter says there's still no evidence that people with true tetrachromy have a fourth primary color. that's not to say they don't, but just that it may be years or decades until a study conclusively proves its existence, if there is one
- blincoln 3y agoTLDR: A display for people or other creatures with true tetrachromatic vision (not just an additional receptor, but the ability to perceive it as a distinct primary colour) would need to be able to output that fourth primary colour, but there doesn't seem to be enough data to determine conclusively at this time if women with a fourth type of cone perceive a fourth primary colour. The one study I've been able to read the full text for that involved determining spectral sensitivity of a woman with distinctly tetrachromatic vision[1] indicates that she had some cones with a peak in-between what most people would see as red and green,[2] and could consistently and accurately discriminate between colours that would appear identical to most people.[3] Unfortunately (and surprisingly, IMO), it doesn't discuss her subjective perception, i.e. does she perceive a true fourth primary colour? It seems like a very, very rare gift, so IMO it's hard to even determine if the women who have it respond in similar ways, which would be a prerequisite for developing a display for them. Everyone else the authors tested who had a fourth type of cone couldn't actually discriminate between colours beyond someone with the typical three types. It would be interesting to see if they gained the discrimination ability by wearing glasses with extremely narrow bandpass filters for their cones' center wavelengths, like the ones that give men with red/green colourblindness the ability to distinguish between red and green. [1] https://jov.arvojournals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2191517 https://jov.arvojournals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2191517 - which cites a much earlier paper by two of the same authors (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8351822/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8351822/) that also included the subject "cDa29". [2] Search for "Simulated cone fundamentals for cDa29" in the first paper linked in [1] [3] "one participant cDa29 [...] behaves as if she has access to an additional cone signal: she made no errors at any value of (R670 / (R670 + G546)) [...] and her response times not only are faster than those of other participants [...] but are roughly even across the stimulus space"
- LoganDark 3y agothank you <3