11 ms·
> Gambling tends to spur much greater ethical concern and regulatory scrutiny, yet overlap – in practice and even game design – is becoming increasingly evident
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Gambling tends to spur much greater ethical concern and regulatory scrutiny, yet overlap – in practice and even game design – is becoming increasingly evident.
This seems like the understatement of all understatements. These games are almost exactly like casino games in all ways, visually, game mechanics, incentives, except there's actually no monetary payout so suddenly it's not gambling and therefore not regulated by gambling laws? Lawmakers around the world are asleep at the wheel.
- kwanbix 3y ago100% agree. My youngest son got hooked into a game called Mech Arena. By the time I realized he had spent 200 dollars (my fault 100%). Games like this should be forbidden or made forbidden for people under 18 years old.
- leetcrew 3y agoI'm not a parent myself so maybe I'm talking out of my ass here. but how is this even possible? my parents never gave me direct access to a credit card as a child. eventually I got a debit card to spend my own allowance chore money, but if I blew it all in something dumb that was my own problem. no pizza/movies with friends until I built it back up
- kindatrue 3y agoIf you're not careful about in app payment settings, your kid can rack big bills with just a few taps. I know parents in Silicon Valley who have had this happen.
- bamfly 3y agoSet up store on device before kids, or when they're very young and not gaming. Do not set require-password because putting it in with a controller for every single should-be-locked-to-kids action is very slow and annoying. Forget to change that when the kids start messing with the device.
- RajT88 3y agoI'm trying to find something which explains it clearly (so I could be wrong), but I don't think you can give a person the ability to hail Uber rides without also giving them the ability to do microtransactions in a mobile game. The former is highly useful for parents and from what I can tell very common, not just for independence, but also safety reasons.
- asah 3y ago? just enter your credit card info into Uber separately from other apps? also, there's credit cards that require approval for each transaction: https://www.google.com/search?q=parental+control+credit+cards https://www.google.com/search?q=parental+control+credit+card...
- scarface_74 3y agoYes, you can. Uber doesn’t go through in app purchases (Apple gets a 30% cut). You have to set up a separate account with payment information. On iOS devices, you can use Apple Pay for Uber (standard credit card charges). But I doubt many parents are putting a credit card on their child’s phone where they can just tap to pay at any store.
- hiatus 3y agoWhen you were a kid your N64 wasn't hooked up to the internet with an app-store to which a credit card was already provided to pay for your monthly multiplayer-access subscription.
- johnnyanmac 3y agono but my cable was. My parents sure made sure I couldn't enter a password and buy those totally educational biology documentary channels I was curious about. Even then, any and all payment options on my phone are bound to a password, I make sure I have to enter that password or fingerprint every single time.I do find it a bit strange that others, especially with young kids, wouldn't have similar securities. I'd probably be even more secure if I did.
- indymike 3y agoFor a long time, there were not parental controls on purchases, and some platforms would force you to lie about age, and give access to the family card to allow children to play games (that were clearly not adult content). Some may still have that antipattern. Parent friendliness by app store: Amazon(best), Apple(meh), Google(beware yer wallet)
- PaulHoule 3y agoMy sister-in-law who is an elementary school teacher and a good parent in many respects would let her preverbal toddlers play with her phone which is problematic in many respects.
- lozenge 3y agoThe kid's phone was set up against the parent's account and the stored payment methods were applied. Or the kid was borrowing the parent's phone. Kids apps pull/pulled all sorts of tricks to prevent people from understanding the modal purchase confirmation dialog (eg https://www.mactrast.com/2019/04/apple-adds-an-extra-confirmation-prompt-to-in-app-subscription-purchases/ https://www.mactrast.com/2019/04/apple-adds-an-extra-confirm... )
- err4nt 3y agoI would have to beg my dad to use his credit card to make an online purchase, even if I had the cash equivalent in my hand to give to him right then! If I new kids would be using any device I would make sure it had no payment information accessible. Which may mean the inconvenience of adding and removing payment information before and after making purchases. I can't imagine letting a child have access to a device which can spend your money, it's essentially like letting them hold your wallet, and we probably wouldn't trust them to do that if they were in an arcade, or theatre, or shopping mall, etc.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoI remember buying my Runescape memberships and eventually Minecraft that way. Not having the freedom to spend my own money on the things that I actually wanted was weird.
- watwut 3y agoSometimes it is simply parents game console or parents stream account. For years. Then, one they they borrow it to kiddo and just don't realize the risk, because they have been buying last time months ago.
- bamfly 3y agoLost about $100 a while back because my 8-year-old didn't realize he was spending real money in some F2P game on an at-the-time unlocked PS5 (though I didn't realize it was so unlocked that you didn't need a password to make purchases—I do most on my phone, for all consoles, because it's much smoother than wrestling with on-console game stores). Shame on me for not locking it sooner. Shame on every goddamn company that knows for a fact this is happening—probably a lot—and prefers to keep robbing people rather than do something about it (say, something ethical—like shut down their company). $100 doesn't mean much to me (like, I'm not well-off enough that I don't think a thing of spending $100, but unexpectedly losing that much every now and then has basically zero effect on my life) fortunately, but that could really screw over a lot of people, in a ruin-their-whole-month kind of way ("why do they even have a playstation to begin with if $100 can really mess them up?!" PS4s are pretty cheap, used, or may have been handed-down for free or very cheap from a better-off relative or friend, and have basically the same store and most of the same games—besides, a planned expense is very different from an unplanned one)
- ryaneager 3y agoShame on the company? Sir this is America where Capitalism is king. Profits come before all else. Doesn’t matter if you deceive children or exploit your workers those profits must rise!
- asah 3y agoCheap education!
- tacocataco 3y ago> "why do they even have a playstation to begin with if $100 can really mess them up?!" People want something to take their mind off of things. I am glad to hear your life is good and something you want to experience. Not everyone has that privilege.
- nomat 3y agoHey not sure why you felt it was important to reply to this line out of that entire paragraph when the next line is more than clear. just kind of seems like concern trolling.
- indymike 3y agoMy (at the time) 9 year old daughter once bought $7,200 worth of dragon in game content on her Kindle Fire (before amazon had parental controls to stop this). The good new is that Amazon INSTANTLY refunded all of it as soon as I explained 9 year old daughter to their support team. I'm sure there's a game publisher that is still disappointed that their whale was more of a guppy.
- lmm 3y ago> My youngest son got hooked into a game called Mech Arena. By the time I realized he had spent 200 dollars (my fault 100%). Games like this should be forbidden or made forbidden for people under 18 years old. I actually think the opposite. Spending $200 as a kid and having nothing to show for it is a lesson you won't forget in a hurry, but not life altering. We should let kids experience the risks and consequences of gambling while they still have a safety net, rather than setting them loose at 18 when it's for real.
- JuanPosadas 3y agoI don't think you really learn anything when it's your parent's $200 and maybe you're not even old enough to understand you spent money at all.
- 3327 3y ago[dead]
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt can cost almost $500 to roll for a character you want in this game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fate/Grand_Order https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fate/Grand_Order some fans have such strong connections to the characters that they'll spend that much. One fan spent $70,000 https://www.destructoid.com/a-look-into-a-dude-who-has-spent-70000-on-fate-grand-order/ https://www.destructoid.com/a-look-into-a-dude-who-has-spent... Contrast that to having a $10 a month Love Nikki habit.
- hooverd 3y agoI think Hoyoverse (formerly Mihoyo) has the formula down. You don't have to spend money on their games. They play just fine without. But you think "wouldn't it be nice to have Ganyu or Hu Tao". I think the drop rates are better than FGO at least.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> I think Hoyoverse (formerly Mihoyo) has the formula down. You don't have to spend money on their games. They play just fine without That only makes it more tempting to start playing. You can't get hooked on these games if you never play them in the first place, so making it 'easier' to start playing is a big part of the problem.
- ethbr0 3y agoThat was the realization that turned me off video games. What is any modern, non-boxed sales model videogame selling? Artificial scarcity. And who is in absolute control of that scarcity? The developer. Why addict yourself to something your counterparty has every incentive to abuse you over? Or as I asked in terms of my EVE Online experience, "Am I actually enjoying every moment of playing, or am I doing work I don't enjoy just so that I can get something?"
- HWR_14 3y agoArtificial scarcity controlled by the developer is what pretty much all software, movies, tv shows, streaming, etc. are selling.
- hx8 3y agoI'd like to see some numbers about how many people struggling with gambling addictions compared to how many people struggle with in-game-purchase addictions. Both share the negative reinforcement of spending money. In exchange one gives you the positive reinforcement of playing a game. Another gives you the positive reinforcement of money. I have the feeling money is a 10x more potent reward. This is to say, the gaming industry makes games that are a problem for some people but I'd like to see some hard numbers comparing it to gambling before I would say the product is as dangerous as gambling on a population level.
- prometheus76 3y agoIt's not just the winning that is addicting to gamblers. More often, it's the losing. Losing recapitulates the feelings of deep shame that they feel, but don't feel are necessarily justified. So in order to re-justify those feelings, they gamble away money and "act shamefully" so to speak. This same pattern is behind a lot (if not all) addictions. It's not just a physical addiction or a dopamine rush, and it's not generally the upside that addicts are addicted to.
- worrycue 3y agoShame has nothing to do with it. It’s the variable ratio reinforcement schedule that such games employ.
- prometheus76 3y agoYou should read more about addiction. You're right about the mechanism employed, but that mechanism does not addict most people. There are genetic and social profiles that make one more vulnerable to addiction, and trauma from the past that results in deep, internalized shame increases those odds dramatically.
- bradford 3y ago> one gives you the positive reinforcement of playing a game. Another gives you the positive reinforcement of money. I'll assert that dopamine is the actual reinforcement in both cases.
- ponderings 3y agoI fear it might be the other way around. The ingame rewards are real while the payout pretty much doesn't happen. It's a carrot on a stick, the donkey gets nothing. It seems to me that one can have a much greater sense of progress if there is actual progress.
- autoexec 3y agoThe ingame rewards are real only until the game goes dark, your device is no longer supported, or their servers shut down and suddenly you're left with nothing. At least real life gambling can leave you with something tangible.
- falcolas 3y agoRewards are also frequently devalued to push you into getting new rewards. Either by power creep in released rewards or active nerfing of existing rewards.
- doctorwho42 3y agoI think another aspect that my friends and I talk about, seeing the evolution of micro transactions over the past decade or two, is the fact that gambling or making transactions for what is essentially an artificially scarce thing that can be duplicated ad infinitum without much cost.
- numpad0 3y agoIt's not helping that Apple - of all companies - is making banks off softcore porn lootbox games. They had war on gaming, and got lootbox gaming eat out the platform. Congratulations, Mr. Jobs.
- Tao3300 3y agoApp Review guidelines still ban: > 1.1.4 Overtly sexual or pornographic material, defined as “explicit descriptions or displays of sexual organs or activities intended to stimulate erotic rather than aesthetic or emotional feelings.”
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- YurgenJurgensen 3y agoI suspect that if the "emotional feelings" being stimulated are Apple's cut of hundreds of millions in revenue, they'll decide that it's not porn. Those regulations are notoriously inconsistently applied.
- WorldMaker 3y agoI've wondered many times how close videogame companies are to accidentally repeating the Pinball Prohibition. There was a period of time when all pinball machines were forbidden, because lawmakers throughout the US couldn't easily enough tell the difference between which ones were gambling and which ones weren't. (That was an extinction level event that bankrupted a bunch of pinball manufacturers and nearly ended several industries.) On the one hand, a lot of the specific loopholes that games claim come directly out of the results of the Pinball Prohibition and contest laws (can't win cash back, must have winning odds posted but it can be in the fine print, things like that) so it is unlikely to repeat exactly like it happened before. But on the other hand, some of what is going on with current whales is so blatant that some have been famously referred to gambling addiction counseling and we do seem close to that political brink that "somebody must do something" and if it happens as the wrong sort of mob mentality panic, politicians are just as likely to use a sledgehammer to the entire industry than a scalpel to the worst offenders just like the Pinball Prohibition. (I sometimes worry, too, about the role that Steam's Trading Cards and Inventory items play into their Auctions might impact any sort of "videogames are gambling panic". Those systems' interaction with Steam Wallet is even dangerously close to feeling like "cash back" sometimes, though you can't actually cash it out and it is more of a gift card. [Though gift card-based gambling/embezzling is another potential panic of its own.] It's hard not to imagine politicians preferring a sledgehammer when even the largest, most trusted videogame store on personal computers wasn't immune to adding gambling-like elements and making extra money from whales.)
- fbdab103 3y agoFor those who had never heard of the Pinball Prohibition, here is an article about it[0]. Features a great photo of the authorities smashing machines like it was the 1930s and eliminating a speak easy. [0] https://www.history.com/news/that-time-america-outlawed-pinball https://www.history.com/news/that-time-america-outlawed-pinb...
- nonfamous 3y agoThere’s also the recent film, “ Pinball: The Man Who Saved the Game (2022)”, which is a fun watch.
- scarface_74 3y ago> Gambling tends to spur much greater ethical concern and regulatory scrutiny, yet overlap – in practice and even game design – is becoming increasingly evident. The government hates competition. They want to be the only ones that can swindle money out of whales via state lotteries.
- hristov 3y agoState lotteries were actually specifically designed to discourage whales and big spending. That is why tickets are relatively low priced and there are no high priced super tickets. It is very difficult to impulse buy a mass amount of tickets. They were also designed to replace numbers -- a similar game run by mobsters that took money from the poor. The rates of return of lotteries are much better than the old numbers games. Of course some states have gotten greedy and have changed the rules to encourage more impulse spending.
- scarface_74 3y agohttps://bigthink.com/the-present/poor-americans-lottery/ https://bigthink.com/the-present/poor-americans-lottery/ The poorest households spend 9% of their income on the lottery https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/amazing-the-poorest-households-spend-9-of-their-income-on-lottery-tickets/255304/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/amazing...
- jstarfish 3y ago> They were also designed to replace numbers ...by rebranding to "Keno." > Of course some states have gotten greedy and have changed the rules to encourage more impulse spending. I can't complain; state lottery collections paid scholarships for 2 of my degrees.
- scarface_74 3y agoAt the expense of mostly poor people playing the lottery.
- coding123 3y agoIf 855 people are going to these therapists for overspending... shouldn't they be going to a therapist?
- rodgerd 3y ago> Lawmakers around the world are asleep at the wheel. Lawmakers are actively pandering to the gambling companies, as the likes of Epic successfully push to make it illegal to have controls on gaming devices under the rubric of "breaking walled gardens" and such.
- GuB-42 3y ago> except there's actually no monetary payout so suddenly it's not gambling Yes, and it is extremely important. The monetary payout is what ruins lives instead of "just" wasting time and disposable income. The added monetary payout creates an incentive to play even more to cover for the losses. In video games, when you make an in-game purchase for instance, the money is gone, so if you do that instead of paying the bills, you know you won't be able to pay the bills, this is usually enough to limit the spending. If, as in casino games, there is hope for you to get your money back, and more, there is temptation to play just to cover your losses, which will eventually result in a downwards spiral. That is, you already can't pay the bills, so you take a loan to play more. After all, it was a bad losing streak, you will win the next one, that's for sure...
- jchw 3y agoAlthough I do agree with what you're saying, it's worth noting that even though there are no orthodox ways to turn virtual currency/winnings in video games most of the time, there are plenty of under the table ways to sell virtual assets for real money. A cynical part of me wonders if the hope with NFTs from game developers was actually that it could run around this problem and provide a more direct way to allow monetary payouts without running into issues with regulations on gambling.
- ianferrel 3y ago>there are plenty of under the table ways to sell virtual assets for real money. But are there any games where you can plausibly put real money in and generate excess gains in virtual assets in a short time? You can double your money in a casino in seconds, but the only way I know to extract money from video games (even play-to-win video games that milk whales for a lot) is arduous and slow gold-farming. I agree with your take on NFTs. They would have been used that way if the NFT games hadn't basically all been Ponzi schemes. Like the pachinko gambling loophole.
- AussieWog93 3y ago>But are there any games where you can plausibly put real money in and generate excess gains in virtual assets in a short time? CS:GO
- jgilias 3y agoThe sound too, they even sound like slot machines.
- OnlyLys 3y agoI think the worst one was NBA 2K20 which had a literal slot machine in the game: https://youtube.com/watch?v=46MQ1ZMZ-l4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=46MQ1ZMZ-l4 (0m 55s)
- jasonfarnon 3y agoLawmakers around the world are asleep at the wheel. I think China banned popular video game websites during certain hours some months ago? Not sure how that worked out.
- hnick 3y agoChina banned under-18s from playing online games more than an hour a day, and only on Fri/Sat/Sun and holidays. Online games are far more addicting in my experience, but it's always easy to waste hours offline as my 90s childhood shows. That's from a recent article - not sure if it changed since. https://apnews.com/article/gaming-business-children-00db669defcc8e0ca1fc2dc54120a0b8 https://apnews.com/article/gaming-business-children-00db669d...
- Zetice 3y agoAgreed, and all one needs to do is look at the annual revenue of gaming vs. gambling to understand the real issue…
- doctorpangloss 3y agoVirtual slot machines are not fun games, and Apple and Google could ban them with a stroke of a pen. They certainly should. Apple, Meta and Google could also prevent developers from advertising them, again with the stroke of a pen. You don't have a right to make them, and they are doing little for the gaming and app ecosystems by having them around. Slot machine victims and politics are poorly aligned. Something like 1/11 of the top grossing apps on the App Store are virtual slot machines. Nonetheless the number of active users total across all virtual slot machines globally may number as low as the hundreds of thousands. This is from my experience as a game developer and publisher. What to do in this scenario: extremely high revenue but few users? As other commenters have said, Apple's deep seeded indifference to gaming has created this beast. Apple Arcade, while generally publishing good games, is a financial and ecosystem failure: there are no breakout hits, and everyone who publishes into Apple Arcade had finished their game before showing it to Apple or had previously successful games, so they didn't help anything come to be that would have come to be already. There are dozens of commenters here complaining about their kids buying IAP. Personally, I find the assignment of blame for something that pisses you off kind of a moot point. You wouldn't give a fuck if there weren't real money involved, indeed there are maybe even a billion people on this planet playing some kind of free game and having fun. The worst that they are doing is wasting time. But Apple could give you a refund - it is, after all, imaginary, there's no scarcity - but they don't. It's their store. Steam gives refunds. So how about write some angry e-mails to Tim Cook, or run for office. As a game developer, I would love for virtual slot machines to go away. The law can do that, if not Apple. But nobody can force Apple to take real risks with Apple Arcade, or force users to pay for my game. There is the problem.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI don't understand how monetary pay-in's without payouts is less scrutinized than with payouts, as at least in the latter the consumer could (with a low likelihood, but still) get something out of the transaction. In contrast, just pay-in means that only the company makes money and the consumer gets nothing, besides some virtual garbage.
- elif 3y agoI think it's even more nefarious to have games that /don't/ resemble gambling but utilize the same psychological tricks. I got taken by legend Richard Garriott on a slippery slide of feeling like I was supporting a historic studio, making digital investments, holding onto key digital real estate, and being part of an exclusive gaming club, all while being coerced into 5 payments per month and incessantly repeating the same in game activities for hours per day. It took 8k for me to never trust game developers ever again. I can't even buy battle passes without feeling like a sucker now.
- thelittleone 3y agoTotally agree. Was watching son play clash Royal yesterday and was immediately thinking of card machines at casinos. Not a good situation.
- majani 3y agoVideo games have been gambling adjacent since the arcade era. A lot of casinos even used to have a casino floor for adults and an arcade floor for the kids
- adriang133 3y agoWhy regulate gambling? Reading the article about the addicted woman, she's perfectly aware of what she's doing and she's perfectly aware she's blowing money away on nothing. There's nothing to be regulated. Conscious adults can make their own decisions. How ridiculous is it for her to ask Zynga to close her account and then still try to log into it later? This isn't a regulatory issue, it's a willpower issue. Might as well regulate how much/what food you can buy so people don't get fat.
- rwnspace 3y agoAbsolutely baffling take. I hope you never get seriously addicted to anything or your mindset that "it's all willpower" will destroy you.
- adriang133 3y agoBut it IS all willpower. The other take is baffling to me - the notion that "we"(the smart people/ the regulators/ the ones above the masses) need to protect weak people because they are too weak to do something about it. It's a ridiculous proposition in my opinion. First, it's intractable - Zynga closes the woman's account, she'll find other ways to blow her money away. But the biggest problem is not even that - the proposed solution of regulation, which nowadays is a universal hammer for absolutely every problem, takes freedom away from me and you in order to protect her. Even though as I've said it doesn't really protect her. Regulation is a terrible solution to any problem, almost all of the time.
- rwnspace 3y agoAh, I though I was talking to a political zealot, thanks for confirming. You clearly have no reference for the experience of a severe addiction and how reduced access and affordances can reduce the chances or severity of relapse. I hope you enjoy eating your heavily regulated dinner tonight before you sleep in your building-regulated abode atop your fire-safety-regulated mattress.