2 ms·
> As it stands now the "fediverse" resembles a collection of islands with various shifting bonds between coalitions where those from coalition A shun those from
by rsynnott 3y ago
> As it stands now the "fediverse" resembles a collection of islands with various shifting bonds between coalitions where those from coalition A shun those from coalitions B and C.
Hrm, what makes you believe that? There are a _few_ largely disconnected instances, but, in particular, the vast majority of instances in terms of usership (excepting intentional islands like Truth Social and Gab, and that one Japanese one) do federate with the giant instances like mastodon.social and similar, tying the whole thing together. In general, if you're using a "normal" instance (ie either one of the big ones or one moderated in a similar way) you can see most other users and most other users can see you. It's only if you're on either a service which everyone wants to block (rare, mostly small Nazi-oriented ones or ones which tolerate cryptospammers) or a service who blocks practically everyone (overly trigger-happy; these tend to rapidly wither and die) that you're isolated.
> it would be far less damaging to the structure of the "fediverse" if that blocking was user-based instead of site-based
Both are options. Defederation, for most instances, is the nuclear option, not the first tool in the box.
I do think at some point it's somewhat likely that there'll be a Muskian 'free speech' shadow fediverse (ie the sort of place Mr Cat Turd would be proud to call home), which will be largely detached from the main one but will federate amongst itself. There's some indication this is kind of developing already (many of the instances that nearly everyone blocks do federate with _each other_). Lots of viable islands seems less likely, though.