3 ms·
I would love for all lawmakers to be limited to market index investing. Say, asset allocation (other than their home and a Washington pied a terre) of 50% US s
by neilv 3y ago
I would love for all lawmakers to be limited to market index investing.
Say, asset allocation (other than their home and a Washington pied a terre) of 50% US stocks index, 20% non-US stocks index, 30% US bonds index.
No stock-picking. No sector-picking. No real estate other than through the indexes. No private company ownership. No trusts. No circumvention.
Alignment with ordinary people's retirement funds seems great.
- jefftk 3y agoEven broad market trends are something they could have inside information on, if they have advance notice of major legislative efforts success.
- awestroke 3y agoThen restrict them so that they can only buy/sell once per year, and need to declare their investment choice 1 month before the yearly buy/sell date
- neilv 3y agoFixed asset allocation aligned with ordinary American, and no moving back and forth from cash. (Just cash for modest bill-paying, emergency fund, home, big child-raising expenses like college tuition.) They're generally incentived to keep all 3 indexes up.
- pc86 3y agoGoing from "no individual stock picking" to "we feel you have too much cash, you have to buy index funds!" is quite the leap.
- neilv 3y agoMoving huge sums between index funds and cash can constitute trading on insider information, and/or on conditions that a lawmaker is able to manipulate.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoThis is a good suggestion. Outright banning ownership of stock might limit the number of people who choose to run for office. This is a fair compromise.
- datavirtue 3y agoThey would be allowed to own indexes (pool of managed stocks).
- spacemadness 3y agoThey’ll get around it somehow. It might just be an extra step for them to do hidden trades through extended family or some such.
- r3trohack3r 3y agoOn the surface this seems pretty decent game theory wise, particularly if you implement annual or bi-annual trading windows with a delay in trade execution (I.e. a trade must be publicly declared 120 days before it is executed) and if those restrictions stay in place long after their tenure in office to discourage prioritizing short term returns over long term stability. AFAICT, forcing lawmakers to invest in total market index funds (with only buy/sell and maybe stop-loss; where total market is defined as an index fund tracking every publicly traded stock in proportion to its value) where it is difficult to make short term trades with insider knowledge of major market moving events would align their incentives with both our retirement accounts and improving a major slice of the economy. One might say law makers would circumvent this regulation by having friends and family make the trades on their behalf, an outcome Id welcome; it’s easier to catch them making illegal trades when they have to coordinate to make it happen. I think it would also mean a significant portion of your compensation as a lawmaker is a direct result of developing the markets. In some ways, regulation like this looks like performance based compensation.
- Xorakios 3y agoOr just US treasuries.