5 ms·
OKR exist to align and motivate the company. It works top down and bottom up; the executives announce what the company is going to be doing for the next term, a
by esafak 3y ago
OKR exist to align and motivate the company. It works top down and bottom up; the executives announce what the company is going to be doing for the next term, and it ripples down as each org and team sets goals that are aligned with the plan. That's all it has to be; a good thing done right.
Have you worked at a company where you had no idea what the plan was and where the company was headed? I have and it is frustrating. That is the kind of company that would benefit from the alignment that OKRs instill.
- skirmish 3y agoSame happens with OKRs. Once there is a meeting to review them, 2/3 of OKRs have been deprecated and not even started, and everybody talks about all this other exciting new work they did that is not reflected in OKRs at all. Deprecation and new work comes from management. How is that better?
- esafak 3y agoYou should not veer that far off your OKRs, otherwise you spend more time on the process than you get back in alignment. You describe a company with no resolve. The leadership has to want alignment for OKRs to work. I think it is a good practice in any case to set yourself goals, and demand the same of your team or as wide a circle as you can influence. It's just shared planning.
- emptysongglass 3y agoSo align the company, no OKRs required. I'm living OKRs now and they are the biggest waste of time I've ever experienced. They encourage work that fits whatever you've nailed yourself to for the quarter. They give people who are good at dressing up their work in charts a podium. These same people are most often the people who do the least real work. OKRs are unequivocally a disaster for productivity. Real output and its impact is not as simple as any box you can invent to hold it.
- mateo411 3y agoI think it's really hard to do OKRs correctly. It seems like you are working at a place that is not doing them correctly. I've also worked at places that haven't implemented OKRs correctly. At the very least it appears that not everybody has bought into the OKRs and alignment has not been achieved.
- wildrhythms 3y agoWhy don't the OKR advocates tell us how to 'correctly' implement them? Start by telling us who should define the OKRs and how granular they should be for an engineer whose priorities change week to week.
- mateo411 3y agoI don't think there is one way to implement these correctly. It's a people/organization problem. It's a hard to get alignment and buy in from enough people in your organization. OKRs should at least be for a period of time of one quarter. They shouldn't be changing constantly quarter over quarter. When they do change a lot, it indicates that the company is shifting strategy. Companies need to do this from time to time, but it's not a good sign if the company is doing this every quarter. Engineering priorities shouldn't change week to week based on OKRs, because OKRs shouldn't change that frequently.
- esafak 3y agoImplementing OKRs is aligning the company. Following shared Objectives is the definition of alignment.
- emptysongglass 3y agoIt's a piss-poor method of aligning the company for the reasons I outlined.