5 ms·

Anyone know how this compares to Maddy (written in Go)? Seems like Stalwart has more features just from a cursory glance

Avamander 3y ago
EDIT: Missed a section of the readme. Ignore the following. Maddy mentions actual security features (DMARC, MTA-STS, DANE, DNSSEC, DKIM) in its overview and compatibility with rspamd etc. (which is rather vital if you want to properly handle spam).
- singhrac 3y ago
  Are we reading the same Github repo? All of those acronyms are in the second bullet.
  - Avamander 3y ago
    Ahh, I scrolled down to "Security" and missed that it was listed above.
cuu508 3y ago
Maddy (also) has a single maintainer. Development activity seems to be low, but the couple PRs I submitted (documentation fixes and cleanup) did get accepted.
- eddieroger 3y ago
  Of note, this project also has one maintainer. It is cool to see individuals interested enough in mail to be putting effort in to it these days. > Stalwart Labs Ltd. is a very small team consisting of just one developer, who has been implementing email software in C since the mid-90s. https://github.com/stalwartlabs#team https://github.com/stalwartlabs#team
  - ttul 3y ago
    The developer is a beast. This is a huge project to build from scratch. So much territory to cover.
sdesol 3y ago
Here's some community information regarding Maddy and Stalwart https://devboard.gitsense.com/stalwartlabs?repos=imap-server,imap-to-jmap,jmap-client,jmap-server,mail-auth,mail-builder,mail-parser,mail-send,mail-server,smtp-proto,smtp-server https://devboard.gitsense.com/stalwartlabs?repos=imap-server... https://devboard.gitsense.com/foxcpp?repos=go-jmap,maddy,mailsec-check https://devboard.gitsense.com/foxcpp?repos=go-jmap,maddy,mai... Not sure if Stalwart recently got funding, but the number of participants shot up in the last week. Stalwart's popularity (stars/watch events) also shot up like crazy about 5 weeks ago. Note, I'm not indexing the code history for both projects right now (they are queued but they probably won't be indexed for another hour or two) so the community insights is incomplete. Full Disclosure: This is my tool

Avamander 3y ago

EDIT: Missed a section of the readme. Ignore the following. Maddy mentions actual security features (DMARC, MTA-STS, DANE, DNSSEC, DKIM) in its overview and compatibility with rspamd etc. (which is rather vital if you want to properly handle spam).

singhrac 3y ago
Are we reading the same Github repo? All of those acronyms are in the second bullet.
- Avamander 3y ago
  Ahh, I scrolled down to "Security" and missed that it was listed above.

cuu508 3y ago

Maddy (also) has a single maintainer. Development activity seems to be low, but the couple PRs I submitted (documentation fixes and cleanup) did get accepted.

eddieroger 3y ago
Of note, this project also has one maintainer. It is cool to see individuals interested enough in mail to be putting effort in to it these days. > Stalwart Labs Ltd. is a very small team consisting of just one developer, who has been implementing email software in C since the mid-90s. https://github.com/stalwartlabs#team https://github.com/stalwartlabs#team
- ttul 3y ago
  The developer is a beast. This is a huge project to build from scratch. So much territory to cover.

sdesol 3y ago

Here's some community information regarding Maddy and Stalwart https://devboard.gitsense.com/stalwartlabs?repos=imap-server,imap-to-jmap,jmap-client,jmap-server,mail-auth,mail-builder,mail-parser,mail-send,mail-server,smtp-proto,smtp-server https://devboard.gitsense.com/stalwartlabs?repos=imap-server... https://devboard.gitsense.com/foxcpp?repos=go-jmap,maddy,mailsec-check https://devboard.gitsense.com/foxcpp?repos=go-jmap,maddy,mai... Not sure if Stalwart recently got funding, but the number of participants shot up in the last week. Stalwart's popularity (stars/watch events) also shot up like crazy about 5 weeks ago. Note, I'm not indexing the code history for both projects right now (they are queued but they probably won't be indexed for another hour or two) so the community insights is incomplete. Full Disclosure: This is my tool