3 ms·
Thinking as a libertarian, To me there seem to be two practically inseparable parts to thinking as a libertarian, when applying it to a practical issue. The id
by netcan 18y ago
Thinking as a libertarian,
To me there seem to be two practically inseparable parts to thinking as a libertarian, when applying it to a practical issue. The idea that Government intervention is amoral & the idea that government intervention is counter-productive.
The former is really an assertions in an area where it is hard to rationally reach an kind of a foundation. This applies equally to most ethical frameworks. I'm not singling out libertarians. The latter often seems to be motivated by faith associated with the former.
You don't here many socialists admitting that while libertarians are morally wrong, their economic models produce a lot more wealth. You don't hear much the other way either.
In fact, those that accept that morally superior & practically effective are often independent. What I am saying is that I don't think that many without an ideological attachment to 'laissez faire' economies would be arguing your position.
The incentives & market signals may not have been perfect. There may have been some distortion coming from the possibility of state intervention. But there was & remains a clear incentive to succeed & a clear disincentive to go bankrupt. The major forces at play leading to a 30/1 leverage are market forces. But eliminating the chance a bailouts are a small drop in that ocean. How about eliminating the possibility of bankruptcy or legal liability? Those are probably bigger
The paper economics is built on lots of assumptions & axioms nailed in with common sense & on average or defining away problems. Consumers make rational decisions=> Define utility creatively. On average & in the long term people are perfectly informed.
Anyway, technical discussions aside, I think it is important for people to look at what parts of the 'ideologies' they subscribe to are independent of each other.
Does it follow from agreeing that socialism is a morally superior concept to capitalism mean that there are no problems inherent in state controlled institutions? Does believing that a coercive state is a bad thing mean that everything you want from an economy can be achieved without it?
I think that the anti-welfarists need to accept for example that sometime, somewhere laissez faire markets may produce a situation where a good chunk of society is undernourished. And more to the point that it may not always produce the economically most efficient outcomes.
- sokoloff 18y agoFor the record, I do "accept that sometime, somewhere laissez faire markets may produce a situation where a good chunk of society is undernourished." I think that it's the pro-welfarists and socialists that seem to have a problem accepting that. To me, wanting minimal government interference in private choices is purely a matter of practicality, not one of morality. I'd prefer that the government not be a nanny to the entire population, constantly at the ready to wipe the nose and dry the tears of anyone who gets hurt. I do agree that if the government is going to serve that purpose, then they'll pretty much have to take away the rewards for good choices, as both a disincentive to take large risks and equally importantly, because it's going to be damned expensive to prop up everyone who chose poorly, someone's got to pay for it, and only those who chose well can afford it. We're pretty far afield of hacker news at this point, and I suspect we understand each other views at a gross level and simply disagree on where the optimal point for a society's government to strive for is located. If it's any consolation, despite having made good choices, I have no say or sway in the matter and that people who think more like you are in power and are determined to wipe the noses that "need" wiped and dry the abundant damp eyes, so you'll get your way anyhow...
- netcan 18y agoYo're right I did hit far off the point I was making which is: Hard libertarians read this story as market signals were distorted by government. We might as well be burning silos of wheat. Social Democrats are predictably reading this as an example that markets do not protect themselves against unacceptable results. But it seems that anyone without an ideological attachment is siding with the latter. Of course this is dangerous as it probably means a wholesale swing towards that side which comes with a whole lot of completely unrelated stuff.
- anamax 18y ago> Social Democrats are predictably reading this as an example that markets do not protect themselves against unacceptable results. Yes, but Social Democrats haven't figured out that regulation doesn't eliminate risk. Financial regulation in particular concentrates risk. The "most effective" reduces the probability of a loss but increases the magnitude even more, increasing the expected value (which is the product of the probability of a loss and the loss's cost if it occurs). This can be a bad thing if the expected value is catastrophic, as we're seeing. We're much better off with continuous small failures than we are with occasional large ones.