4 ms·
> The quality of their product has ceased to matter. Most people don't go to the theater (or even stream) to watch "quality," they go for entertainment. Artsy
by satvikpendem 3y ago
> The quality of their product has ceased to matter.
Most people don't go to the theater (or even stream) to watch "quality," they go for entertainment. Artsy films might have a lot of artistic quality (like The Green Knight, for example) but most people don't care, they'll watch the latest blockbuster, which is where studios make the most money. For the people who do watch artsy films, understand that the blockbusters make the bulk of the revenue to even greenlight artsy films; without the mass market films, there wouldn't even be any artsy films (of a sizable budget like 10 to 50 million dollars, not true indie or art house films).
Interestingly, it would be ironic if, were these strikes to go on for a longer time, studios would simply think to invest more into AI which doesn't have the sorts of problems mere humans might, hastening the demise of writers and actors. This must be why it was reported that negotiations broke down as soon as AI was thrown in there, they definitely want to bet on that as the future and I'm not sure what leverage actors and writers have, honestly. It seems like whichever way the strike goes, studios won't budge on that issue.
Edit: removed art house label as it was inaccurate.
- OO000oo 3y ago> Most people don't go to the theater (or even stream) to watch "quality," they go for entertainment. A tell-tale sign of a decadent society where people are depressed and unfulfilled, more interested in escape from life than engagement with life because everything they might live for is compromised in the name of profit at the expense of everything else. I don't know what point you think you're making, but it's not helpful and there is nothing about this that anybody should be proud of.
- dooraven 3y ago> A tell-tale sign of a decadent society where people are depressed and unfulfilled, more interested in escape from life than engagement with life because everything they might live for is compromised for profit at the expense of everything else. Not really, where exactly am I going to get dragons in real life?
- OO000oo 3y agoHow are you contradicting my point? It's historically very abnormal for adults to be so fascinated with dragons and other escapist features. We are living in strange times and it's not coincidence. We have lost capacity for art that engages with sincere human experience, a concerning situation for a society to find itself in. It means we are losing capacity to engage with ourselves; it is no laughing matter.
- selimthegrim 3y agoYou’re basically calling them all the adults who read the young adult books
- Vecr 3y ago> It's historically very abnormal for adults to be so fascinated with dragons and other escapist features. For some reason dubious psychologists had a thing for King Arthur stuff for quite a while and I'm not really sure there's any dragons in there, there's weird fisher kings and stuff. I think someone is rich enough and has enough free time (probably over a billion now, but similar people existed in the past in lower numbers), they would find some weird thing to work on or think about.
- rblatz 3y agoOr just maybe I don’t care that people think I’m too old to enjoy the things I like, and don’t force myself to suffer through some art house cringe fest because some guy on the internet thinks it’s a sign of living in a capitalistic hell scape while posting on a site specifically targeting capitalists.
- blargey 3y agoTruly, these are strange times. We need to go back to the times where adults scoffed at the robots of Asimov. I mean the time machines and vampires of Wells and Stoker. I mean the electrically reanimated corpses of Shelley. I mean the ghosts and fairies and witchcraft of Shakespeare. I mean the demigod superheroes of Homer. I mean…
- satvikpendem 3y agoPanem et circenses has been around a long time, it's not a new concept that you're implying. People like entertainment, which is sometimes but not always a proxy for quality. We can deny that at our peril or accept that that's what the majority of people like and cater to them. That's what studios do now, whether we artsy media watchers like it or not.
- sdsd 3y ago>Panem et circenses has been around a long time, it's not a new concept that you're implying. He doesn't seem to be implying that this is new. Rather, that this is something that happens to any decadent society society where people are depressed and unfulfilled.
- satvikpendem 3y agoBased on this comment it seems they are implying that we are in some new sort of society: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36767978 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36767978 Which I find ridiculous to be honest, every generation laments the downfall of society, it's nothing new at all.
- OO000oo 3y ago[flagged]
- satvikpendem 3y ago> It's _historically_ very abnormal for adults to be so fascinated with dragons and other escapist features. We are living in strange times and it's not coincidence. Note the emphasis on "historically." This implies, to those reading, that you assume the current society is "abnormal" and "strange" somehow, to which I replied that it's nothing new. Now you can take that as you wish and maybe you didn't intend that implication and think you are "precisely" saying what you intend, but it's not so precise when multiple people disagree with how you laid out your comment. It would have been more precise if everyone actually understood you, even if they had disagreed.
- afavour 3y ago> they definitely want to bet on that as the future and I'm not sure what leverage actors and writers have, honestly The fact that AI is by definition just going to create recycled, derivative content. If the industry replaces writers and actors with AI it’ll be their demise because audiences will get very, very bored very quickly.
- satvikpendem 3y agoHow is it "by definition?" Just because it trains on known data doesn't mean it does not mix and match ideas in novel ways. Even AlphaGo a few years ago played a completely novel move in the game that was never seen or even considered by master Go players, so I'm not too worried about AI's "creativity." I'm also not necessarily talking about AI creating the entire movie from scratch, it's a useful tool to help guide decisions. Personally I'm more looking forward to seeing indie filmmakers making something on par with a Marvel film in terms of CGI, without having to hire actors, rent studio space and time, etc, because the product at the end of the day is all pixels, data that can be generated line by line by a computer if only it knows what color to make each pixel. It sounds far-fetched today but in due time, everyone will have that power.
- afavour 3y agoYou don’t see the difference between playing Go, a game with strictly defined rules and limited moves available at all times, and the process of creative writing? I’m impressed by what AI is capable of but it feels like we’re making the same mistake everyone made with self driving cars. It can drive down an empty road in a desert? Well it’ll surely only be a couple of years before they’re everywhere! ChatGPT can generate a paragraph of prose? Well it’ll surely only be a couple of years before it’s coming up with inventive show concepts, developing characters and planning season arcs!
- satvikpendem 3y agoI agree, it might take some time, perhaps years or decades (although I doubt the latter based on current progress it seems), but it is not an insurmountable challenge, as long as you are a physicalist, I philosophical terms.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThis is wrong in so many ways. > the blockbusters make the bulk of the revenue to even greenlight art house films; without the mass market films, there wouldn't even be any art house films (of a sizable budget like 10 to 50 million dollars, not indie films). Your assumption seems to be that big studios somehow use the profits of blockbusters to subsidize arthouse films. That would be wonderful if true. It's false, though. Art films are financed from different suppliers of funds, and they even play in different theaters. > there wouldn't even be any art house films (of a sizable budget like 10 to 50 million dollars, not indie films). I don't know what this means. Before you were talking about arthouse films but now it's low-budget studio films??? What are you saying?
- satvikpendem 3y agoMy mistake, I shouldn't have said art house, you're right that I'm talking about low budget studio films that are more serious in tone or have something unique about them and aren't just another action film. I don't mean indie art house films literally.
- AlbertCory 3y agoOK. Studio finances are too murky to understand, but I suspect the blockbusters that succeed mainly finance the ones that don't. But you could be right; maybe in hard times they clamp down on ALL the spending.