4 ms·
Or alternatively don’t drive ancient polluting cars in heavily populated areas with fantastic public transport?
by Havoc 3y ago
Or alternatively don’t drive ancient polluting cars in heavily populated areas with fantastic public transport?
- Dig1t 3y agoEnforcing such a policy via mass surveillance is a bit Orwellian though isn't it?
- hhh 3y agoNo value judgement here, but how else would you enforce it?
- mock-possum 3y agoMore cops! More traffic stops and checkpoints! More inspections and fees! No wait fuck nobody likes any of that. Okay what about buyback programs. What about trade ins. What about tax breaks and government subsidies for buying newer vehicles with less hem fuel emissions? What if instead of paying to enforce a law, you paid to change the conditions that lead to the problems that the law was created to address in the first place?
- hugh-avherald 3y agoEvery tax break is a tax increase for someone else. Buying polluting vehicles would encourage people to buy harmful things because they would expect the government would eventually pay them off (or equivalently would discourage people from buying less polluting vehicles early, lest they miss out on a bailout).
- wcoenen 3y ago> Okay what about buyback programs Already in place. https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/ultra-low-emission-zone/scrappage-schemes https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/ultra-low-emission-zone/scr...
- c4ptnjack 3y agoIs that more Orwellian than say anti-theft camera systems or red light cameras at stoplights?
- Dig1t 3y agoIt depends on who controls the cameras, but yes generally every added means of surveillance by a centralized power takes us closer to an Orwellian society. anti-theft cameras less so, because they are controlled by individual people, but as seen with Ring doorbells, the government can still access them, so it's pretty creepy.
- mock-possum 3y agoSeems about on par to me
- thedrbrian 3y agothe ULEZ is in London
- valdiorn 3y agoA rather naive take that ignores a lot of history. I drive a diesel 2016 VW Passat. A very "average" car by UK standards. My car does not qualify for the ULEZ and I'd have to pay the toll. I don't drive a giant gas guzzling truck. Not do I drive a 20 year old banger. I drive a "responsible" family sedan. Yet this is not enough to escape the toll. When I bought that car, diesel cars were heavily favoured as the more environmentally friendly option by the government. People were encouraged to buy them, there were subsidies and various incentives to buy a car like mine. Then Dieselgate hit and everyone went running away from diesel. Now consider that the government is extending the ULEZ to cover a huge area including millions of people. Those people are all being told "cough up £12.50 EVERY DAY or buy a BRAND NEW, expensive car". Well, not everyone has 20 grand to drop on a new electric, so they're just shit out of luck. 12.50 is an hour of their salary post taxes. That's an HOUR every day that poor people need to work extra, just for the privilege of getting to and from work. How angry would you be if you were forced to work an extra hour a day just for the privilege of getting in and out of your own neighbourhood? Also, regarding your take on public transport; public transport is great in central London. If you go to any of the neighbouring towns, where the ULEZ is being extended to, it's a different story. Train lines only go one direction: towards London. If you're going from town A to town B and public transport is your only option, you may find yourself needing to go into London and then back out again. That takes a long time and is very expensive. People need cars to get places in those towns. Also, as someone who recently became a parent; public transport and infants do not mix well. In short; it's a tax on the poor (doubly so for people with small children), with a side order of revisionist history punishing those made responsible purchasing choices 5 years ago.
- hulitu 3y ago> Train lines only go one direction: towards London. If you're going from town A to town B and public transport is your only option, you may find yourself needing to go into London and then back out again. This plagues public transport in a lot of countries. Want to go with public transport in 2 neighboring towns ? You might need to go a couple of tens of kilometers through another town because there is no direct connection.
- moeffju 3y ago