I wasn't sure how to verify that I recognized my keys at first. To save anyone else a bit of time googling, you want to run "ssh-keygen -lf your_key.pub" agains

I wasn't sure how to verify that I recognized my keys at first. To save anyone else a bit of time googling, you want to run "ssh-keygen -lf your_key.pub" against your local copy of the key to generate the fingerprint and compare that to what GitHub shows you.