3 ms·
The whole notion of "expectation of privacy" and the medieval theology arguments around it, is so BS, and yet people are so conditioned to it. It should be a s
by coldtea 3y ago
The whole notion of "expectation of privacy" and the medieval theology arguments around it, is so BS, and yet people are so conditioned to it.
It should be a set of clear cut cases: "your house is private", "your car is (or isn't)", and so on, and anything private should need a warrant. Courts shouldn't get to decide, or interpret various techniques attempted to bypass this...
- tptacek 3y agoYou'll need to take that up with the authors of the 4th Amendment, who left this matter up to the courts when they gave people in the US the right to be free from "unreasonable" searches, where "unreasonable" is a term of art that effectively means "it's up to the judiciary". More to the point, this theological business of determining where the expectations of privacy are is exactly the business of declaring what is and isn't private that you're asking them to work out.
- coldtea 3y ago>More to the point, this theological business of determining where the expectations of privacy are is exactly the business of declaring what is and isn't private that you're asking them to work out I'm asking for clear-cut hard cases, as opposed to ad-hoc divinations. Oh, and that those clear cut cases not be based on vague premises like "expectation". It should be "these cases are private, enforcing what our society -as represented by lawmakers- believes ought to be kept private". Versus guessing what some founding fathers or amendment authors meant when they said "expectation" and whether this or that place should be "expected to be private" or not. >where "unreasonable" is a term of art that effectively means "it's up to the judiciary". Sure, and this is the problem I'm pointing. "Unreasonable" is an open ended term, that doesn't settle anything, and keeps people guessing. In 2023 this person went to court without knowing whether their car is allowed privacy or not. That's not a 21st century law, that's like some ancient oracle prophesy that can be read 20 odd ways. You know, like that other term of art, about a "millitia", that has lead to centuries of theological arguments about the number of well regulated angels that can stand on the top of a pin.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat you want is a civil law system, rather than the common law system we actually have in the US.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dbtc 3y agoAlso there's a difference between private and secret.