3 ms·
It seems like our world is getting more dystopian every week that goes by. I can't wait until this pendulum starts swinging the other way.
by JohnFen 3y ago
It seems like our world is getting more dystopian every week that goes by. I can't wait until this pendulum starts swinging the other way.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhat makes you convinced that it still can swing the other way?
- JohnFen 3y agoMostly because history indicates that this is a pattern that repeats over time. But also because if I don't have at least that small hope, the despair would be hard to handle.
- jacquesm 3y agoOk. I'm a bit concerned that the ways the pendulum has historically swung back are more or less closed off because of all the ratchets in place now. You'd have to upset a very large number of applecarts to get to the point where you can reverse the swing because with these tools it is now possible to identify the agents that would cause the swing to reverse. Breaking that is very tough, essentially once power is entrenched to that level it is unassailable. The DDR comes to mind, they had an iron grip on the populace and if they had access to today's tools I have no idea how any kind of dissident could even begin to get a movement off the ground before being identified and hauled off. The same for the various underground movements during WWII, they wouldn't have stood a chance. China may well get there first, (if they aren't there yet) and we'll get to see how doable this is, I really fear the worst.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt looks to me like what's happening now isn't really anything new. In terms of "ratcheting" and the like, we've seen the same thing happen repeatedly throughout history. And, eventually, things do swing back. The only question is how long the cycle takes (it may very well take much longer than a single generation) and how much work is required to get there. The famous paraphrase does (so far) appear to be correct: the arc of history bends towards justice.
- jacquesm 3y agoI don't know if that's true. When you get to the point that you can pinpoint your prospective dissidents in their teens it becomes possible to contain any kind of potential source for a future revolution long before it is even visible to the participants. And given enough crimes on the books you could make them go away practically forever when using this sort of pre-crime detector, after all there is always something that will serve to put someone behind bars for a couple of decades in a properly organized dictatorship. The next bad government to come to power in the developed world may well be the last.
- more_corn 3y agoIt’ll swing, I worry about how violently it’ll swing.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, this is the question. Historically, it can be very violent.
- bob1029 3y agoYou can still buy battery-powered angle grinders for $130 at your local hardware store with cash. All of these fancy AI systems rely on the sensors on the ground in your community (aka those solar panel + webcam pole combos randomly scattered about). It would take some teenagers on bikes one weekend to cripple a municipal minority report network. Sensors on major roadways are more difficult to tamper with, but not a whole lot of our land is a major roadway so that's not a huge deal. Some even argue all of our modern infrastructure will fail on its own despite our best efforts. Complexity is a hell of a thing. A tiny bit of brute force applied might be all it takes in the end.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoWhat I really want, is a small electronic device that can fool the gunshot detectors. I realize that the easiest way would be some kind of hopped up firecracker, but the use (even minute amounts) of explosives would probably be bad. This device might only get 1 or 2 uses without recharge, that'd be ok. But I'd like for it to be light enough to be carried by drone. And if somehow they could be programmable to sound like different calibers, even better. They could just go out on night missions, running the cops ragged.
- jacquesm 3y agoThere is a Gaston La Gaffe episode along those lines, where parking meters are equipped with fireworks when they expire they launch a rocket. This drives the local policemen bonkers because they are running from one end of the city to the other to try to keep up.
- fragmede 3y ago> Sensors on major roadways are more difficult to tamper with The second amendment says no, not really.
- lobf 3y agoIf you’re suggesting people fire at small targets on the freeway with guns, then it has absolutely nothing to do with the 2nd amendment.
- gigel82 3y agoLOL... they're boiling the frog while we wait for things to get better. Spoiler: we're the frog.
- JohnFen 3y agoBut you know that in the real world, that frog thing doesn't work, right? The frog will, in fact, get out when the water gets too hot no matter how slowly the heat increases.