3 ms·
More scholars should write in his vein. Academics who write exclusively for other academics (especially in more abstract disciplines like philosophy) often seem
by anigbrowl 3y ago
More scholars should write in his vein. Academics who write exclusively for other academics (especially in more abstract disciplines like philosophy) often seem more interested in winning arguments about the right way to split hairs than providing their readers with anything useful (even at the risk of being found wrong later). There's a style of moral philosophy that dresses itself in the inevitability of mathematics or pure logic while constructing soaring theoretical edifices on bog-like foundations.
- lordleft 3y agoThis is what much of Greco-Roman philosophy, in the Socratic vein, focused on: practical philosophy exploring how we ought to live
- anigbrowl 3y agoYes, I'm fond of that too. A problem I have with much of modern analytic philosophy is that while it nominally addresses this question, it's often policy advocacy in pseudo-objective wrapping. I've got books which have interesting ideas and whose propositions I largely agree with, but which would have been better off as an earnestly argued 10 page essay instead of a lumbering and tedious 150 page apologia.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThere's a loooong history of philosophy-as-political-advocacy, going back to Plato's Republic, and arguably before. Not just in the Western tradition either --- 孔夫子 (Kǒng Fūzǐ, a/k/a Master Kong, a/k/a Confucius) comes notably to mind. al-Kindi, Avicenna, Averroes, Ibn Khaldun , Machiavelli, Moore, Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau. And not just the overt stuff either, but a whole slew of religious philosophy, ethics, aesthetics, metaphysics, and more.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI'm fine with that, it's the turgid pseudoscientific style of argument I have an issue with. I'm tired of reading stuff like 'Question X has been neglected since the Rawlsian turn. In this work I propose a method for inscribing a Zizekian comparator within a Derridiean framework, allowing us to navigate a Bordieu-Bataille field...' That's a pastiche, but I have a shelf's worth of such badly written theory which seems to mistake density for depth.
- dredmorbius 3y agoFair enough. Stugeon's Law holds. There's also the whole publishing / academic clique environment which incentivizes such styles. And there are refreshingly clear and accessible authors in philosophy from both the present time and the past. I've been following a number of podcasts for a few years now which tend to be both reasonably high quality and quite listenable: Peter Adamson's History of Philosophy, Stephen West's Philsophize This, a set of podcasts each from Nigel Warburton nd David Edmunds (Philosophy Bites, Philosophy Sites, and a few more) and David Runciman (Talking Politics, History of Ideas, Past Present Future, etc.). Bertrand Russell's History of Western Philosophy and Will Durant's Story of Philosophy are also engaging. A number of these are surveys of philosophy rather principle works, but there's at least work in the genre that's readable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]