4 ms·
> I really mean self-awareness and consciousness. > Isn’t that a metric we use to determine the intelligence of animals and such? Depends what you mean by tho
by ben_w 3y ago
> I really mean self-awareness and consciousness.
> Isn’t that a metric we use to determine the intelligence of animals and such?
Depends what you mean by those words.
"Do they pass a mirror test" is, as far as I know, the best idea anyone's had so far for self awareness, and that's trivial to hard-code as a layer on top of whatever AI you have, so it's probably useless for this.
> Does GPT love its creators the way we love our parents? Does it mourn a loss the way we do?
I'd be very surprised if it did, given it wasn't meant to, but then again it wasn't "meant" to be able to create unit tests for a Swift JSON parser when instructed in German either, and yet it can.
Trouble is… how would you test for it? Do we have more than the vaguest idea how emotions work in our own heads to compare the AI against, or are we mysteries unto ourselves?
Or can we only guess the inner workings from the observable behaviours, like we do with elephants? But "observable behaviour" is something that a VHS can pass if it's playing back on a TV, and we shouldn't want to count that. Is an LLM more like a VHS tape or like an elephant? I don't know.
LLMs are certainly alien to how we think; as it's been explained to me, I think it should be thought of as a ferret that was made immortal, then made to spend a few tens of thousands of years experiencing random webpages where each token is represented as the direct stimulation of an olfactory nerve, and it is given rewards and punishments based on if it correctly imagines the next scent.
> I don't strive to become a better in the world person for some reward.
Feeling good about yourself is a reward, for most of us.
But I think this is a big difference between us and them: as I understand it, most AI have only one reward in training, while humans have many which vary over our lives — as an infant it may be pain va. food or smiles vs. loud noises, as a child it may be parental feedback, as an adolescent it may be peer pressure and sex, as a parent it may be the laughter vs. the cries of your child… but that's pop psychology on my part.