6 ms·
Byte Fanless Mini PC – Built for Linux
- ggm 3y agoMy primary use case is ZFS but none of these devices seem to package SATA multiples, and getting a PCIx<n> eg 3 or 4 so you get full speed access across the drives is complicated by crap chipsets. Great wee device. Just not good fit for my project. I love fanless: lavalier microphones pick up rediculous amounts of throb from fans! (I'm on a radxa 4 drive USB to SATA bridge hat on a pi4, so all the pain of USB and a jmicron SATA bridge which isn't being upgraded.)
- rhn_mk1 3y ago"Uncompromisingly secure", yet contains an Intel CPU with an unpatchable mystery blob. Just put an unlocked ARM CPU in there already.
- AshamedCaptain 3y ago> Just put an unlocked ARM CPU in there already. As if that existed. Also, I ponder what is the threat vector presented by an "unpatchable mystery blob" that is not already present without one.
- rhn_mk1 3y agoi.MX8 series, as used in MNT Reform and the Librem 5. Rockhip chips as used in the PinePhone. Mediatek chips from some Chromebooks. Those let the OEM choose whether they want to lock TrustZone or not. Let me explain what unique threat the blob poses: https://securityaffairs.co/58656/hacking/intel-management-engine.html https://securityaffairs.co/58656/hacking/intel-management-en...
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoFor the record, these chips do not have AMT in the first place, and even then they come with coreboot, for which ME is not really a concern. I thought you were talking about proprietary microcode, which all of these chips you mention do come with. Or even worse, since they are all SoCs.... You'd have to e.g. avoid using the Ethernet controller on them (which generally has flashable eeproms with code) which would also happen to be an effective prevention of any ME issues even if were running an ancient version of ME. I.e. the only threat vector you mentioned does not apply and can't possibly apply. A mac shares more firmware with your average intel laptop than this.
- rhn_mk1 3y agoWhich is exactly the point. No AMT, one less problem.
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoThese chips as in non-laptop non-vpro intel chips like the one used here.
- scarface_74 3y agoAre there any good ARM processors and related hardware that you can buy that are available on the open market for use by OEMs?
- adrian_b 3y agoThe only boards or computers with non-obsolete ARM CPUs and that are cheaper than the boards or computers made with Intel Alder Lake N CPUs, like this N200 or like the cheaper N100 CPU, are made by various smaller Chinese companies (Raspberry Pi have always been using obsolete ARM CPUs). There are good ARM CPUs, like in the NVIDIA Orin modules, or in some boards offered by MediaTek and Qualcomm, which are derived from their smartphone products, but all these are very expensive in comparison with the Intel products. If you are not scared by much higher than Intel prices, you can look e.g. for products including these: https://www.mediatek.com/iot/products/genio1200-devkits https://www.mediatek.com/iot/products/genio1200-devkits https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/autonomous-machines/embedded-systems/jetson-orin/ https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/autonomous-machines/embedded-sy... (at the NVIDIA site you must ignore any module or devkit that does not include the word "Orin" in the name, everything else is too old junk, even if it appears to be cheaper) For cheaper than Intel, but with performance at the level of the previous Intel Atom CPUs (i.e. Tremont-based, like Jasper Lake and Elkhart Lake) there are many products using the Chinese Rockchip CPU RK3588, for which much more public information is provided than for any Intel or AMD CPU, so I would trust it much more for implementing a secure appliance like a firewall, but not all of those products are well designed and some are overpriced (i.e. anything more than $200 for a complete computer with RK3588 is grossly overpriced).
- scarface_74 3y agoThen that begs the question, what is the advantage of ARM for the type of consumer who would be in the market for this PC or for a desktop in general? The advantage of ARM in laptops are clear - the battery life/performance/heat tradeoff is better. It’s also clear for server farms. But if I’m just running Linux on a desktop anyway, why would I care about ARM vs x86 unless I’m targeting my builds for other ARM computers.
- jamesy0ung 3y agoBasically a nuc with same old intel processor but coreboot.
- bartvk 3y agoSince Intel quit the nuc business, it could fill a niche.
- uvesten 3y agoI wonder if it has 10gbe though, probably not. I want all my new computers/peripherals to support 10gbe, but it’s surprisingly hard (and expensive) to find.
- thewilliamist 3y agoWould be that much more expensive just to put an SFP+ (or ideally) SFP28 onboard? I've wondered about that before.
- adrian_b 3y agoThere exists such a small computer, R86S: https://www.servethehome.com/the-gowin-r86s-revolution-low-power-2-5gbe-and-10gbe-intel-nvidia/ https://www.servethehome.com/the-gowin-r86s-revolution-low-p... That review is old, meanwhile R86S has been updated to use the newer Intel CPUs, N100 (4-core) or i3-N305 (8-core). However it has some flaws, e.g. it is not fanless.
- jacquesm 3y ago> I want all my new computers/peripherals to support 10gbe, but it’s surprisingly hard (and expensive) to find. That's because it is top of the line and very few devices actually need that kind of bandwidth. For switch-to-switch links I can see the point (and for specialized datacenter applications) but for home use it is mostly overkill.
- dsr_ 3y agoIt's not even clear what chip is driving the "RJ45" ethernet -- in quotes because normally you see a nominal speed rating, 1Gb/s or 2.5. That's not what I want from a vendor. I want clarity.
- lmz 3y agoIf you expand the specs you'll see it's Gigabit.
- adrian_b 3y agoIn small computers or laptops you can always choose those that have USB 4 a.k.a. Thunderbolt ports. There are adapters from USB 4/Thunderbolt to 10 Gb/s Ethernet. Moreover, when 2 computers are close enough, you can connect them with a Thunderbolt cable and you will have the equivalent of a fast Ethernet connection. The operating systems will show extra network interfaces that can be configured and used for communication between the two computers. Now all new Intel and AMD low-power CPUs include a controller for two USB 4/Thunderbolt ports, so there are no good reasons for any new small computer or laptop to not have them. If the USB 4/Thunderbolt ports are not occupied by a monitor or power supply, so both are free, you can daisy chain a large number of small computers in the equivalent of a 10 Gb/s Ethernet network, without expensive switches, adapters or NICs.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoAm I missing it because I'm not awake yet, or does it really not specify the speed of the ethernet port anywhere? I only see "RJ45" but no specs.
- nubinetwork 3y agoA search on a review site says they're both gigabit. https://www.cnx-software.com/2023/07/14/star-labs-byte-mk-ii-processor-n200-linux-mini-pc/ https://www.cnx-software.com/2023/07/14/star-labs-byte-mk-ii...
- wildekek 3y agoI wonder who this is for. It could be a great homelab server, but only 16GB of mem ruins that idea.
- binary_ninja 3y agoWhy do you think 16GB is not enough for a home server? I am currently running a NAS with SMB, NFS, Nextcloud, LDAP, mail server, Roundcube, Uptime Kuma and a couple of websites and using around 1GB of RAM. Just curious what other people is doing.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoProbably stuff it to the brim with virtual machines, that kind of usage
- binary_ninja 3y agoWell, yes, if you go full enterprise with 6 VM's and 30 Docker containers I can understand how you'd aim for 64GB of RAM but then, why would you want to use a fanless mini PC for it?
- jacquesm 3y agoFanless, mini and 64 GB or RAM in a single device is going to be a tough challenge anyway.
- trustingtrust 3y agoI think super micro makes such edge devices. But then we are talking a different category now.
- jacquesm 3y agoInteresting! https://www.ahead-it.eu/en/shop/servers/embedded-iot/intel-atom-processor/supermicro-sys-e302-9a-nr-fanless-cse-e302il-a2sdi-4c-hln4f-rohs https://www.ahead-it.eu/en/shop/servers/embedded-iot/intel-a... Those? Technically they are fanless but I wonder how well they would work outside of a rack with high ambient, they seem to be fanless themselves but still rely on having plenty of air pulled across the casing. Mounting them vertically might work. 850 euro though!
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoNo idle power measurements, which I think is a rather interesting metric for a PC this size.
- acd 3y agoLooks like a good for home firewall / router.
- Arch-TK 3y ago"Open warranty" - this is just a normal warranty except without the unenforceable scaremongering nonsense.
- dtx1 3y agoAnd its even less than they are required to provide by law in the EU anyway
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy only one USB C port and why a DisplayPort and HDMI? If there were more USB C ports, you would have more flexibility and you can have video over USB C. I have a portable external display that gets power and video over one USB C port. Or is video over USB C a Thunderbolt thing and not a USB C 3.0 thing? On another note, this is why it was never a big deal for Intel to get out of the NUC market, another company would fill in the niche.
- CTDOCodebases 3y agoVideo over USB C is supported by “alt mode”. It’s not just a thunderbolt thing.
- rewmie 3y agoThanks for pointing that USB-C supports alternate mode specs such as DisplayPort and HDMI. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB-C#Alternate_Mode_partner_specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB-C#Alternate_Mode_partner_s...
- bee_rider 3y agoI wonder what the steady-state clock frequency under passive cooling is. 3.7Ghz seems way too good to be true.
- simfoo 3y ago1.00GHz quad-core Intel Alder Lake N200 Turbo Boost up to 3.70GHz, with 6MB Smart Cache
- bee_rider 3y agoI’m not sure what this tells us. Base clock is 1Ghz, turbo 3.7Ghz, but somewhere (hopefully between the two, but technically it could be less than 1Ghz) there’s a clock speed that the chip can run that produces less heat than the passive cooling solution can dissipate.
- esperent 3y agoPresumably it depends a lot on the outside temperature and humidity. It's the reason I'm very wary of buying anything fanless since I live in a tropical part of the world.
- mfwit 3y agoWhy would I buy this over the massive amount of options, at better prices, from companies like Minisforum and Beelink?
- lmz 3y agoCoreboot or a general distrust of the Chinese.
- glimshe 3y agoAmazon and other vendors have literally dozens, if not over a hundred, alternatives these days, starting close to $100. You can find N100s for $179 new and that is supposed to have fairly close performance to the N200 (20% difference?). It's a tough market for this to compete in.
- trustingtrust 3y agoI just searched for N100 on Amazon and I could find ones for 160$ with 8gb ram and 256gb ssd. What an incredible value. Compared to this I’ve spent well over 80$ on my raspberry pi 4gb (cases ssd cooling charger etc). Sure a pi4 is low power. But I find it less appealing for those wanting simple cheap home servers now that things like these consume less power and are much faster with much better I/O and cooling. Not to mention upgradable memory.
- seanp2k2 3y agoAlso things like MinisForum and BeeLink with Zen4 “Phoenix” 7945HS models that can take 64GB DDR5, have strong igpus, dual M.2, dual USB4, 2.5GbE…I’m building up a maxed out one now to replace an old 6th-gen Intel NUC that runs my HomeAssistant and other things.
- plugger 3y agoI just ordered a Bosgame Ryzen 3 Mini PC (U32) with 8GB DDR4 RAM and a 256GB M.2 drive for $160 USD. And it comes with Windows 11. I'm blown away by how much you can get for so little these days.
- fuzz_junket 3y agoI had a very unfortunate experience with Star Labs. I had their StarLite IV laptop and it was wonderfully slim and light. I was delighted with it. The CPU is no powerhouse, but it did exactly what I needed. Then eight months later it started experiencing power issues (e.g. when I picked it up, there was a power blip and it froze). It took four months going back and forth with them before they finally refused to fix it under warranty and demanded I pay for it. Full disclosure: they said I broke it. My side of things is that it's stayed on my desk or in a bag most of the time. It never got subjected to rough handling, and this has never happened with any other laptop I've owned. I think it was an issue with build quality if even gentle handling can break it. The whole experience was very disappointing. I'd really hoped that supporting a smaller company like this would mean I'd get more personal support, but that wasn't the case with Star Labs. This isn't a reflection on the Byte mini PC, of course, but just be cautious about dealing with companies if their products break easily and they don't offer good customer support.
- linza 3y agoI had very good experience with Protecli (https://protectli.com https://protectli.com), for both products and customer support. Seems to me both are for similar use cases. I'm using mine as firewall appliances for example.
- sdflhasjd 3y ago> DC-IN The annoying thing with a lot these mini-PCs is the external power brick which ends up being nearly as large again. I'd like to seem more with an integrated power supply
- happymellon 3y agoI wouldn't mind USB-C powered, my laptop USB chargers are tiny.
- nordsieck 3y agoI would strongly prefer this as well. The downside for the company is that they'll have to field complaints from people who use underpowered power supplies. Although I suppose that could mostly be prevented by shipping an approved power supply with the computer.
- esperent 3y agoSame with laptops. I feel like every review should always lead with a picture showing both the power supply and the device. I recently got a couple of Asus Deskmini X300s. Great little machines. But the power supply is 1/3 of the size of the machine and has really long cables on both sides.
- sdflhasjd 3y agoThe new GaN chargers are nice and compact, but for some reason only available as third party accessories. I'd have thought laptop manufacturers would be jumping on the tech, but even Apple are still shipping bulky power supplies.
- elliottkember 3y agoApple’s just released a new 70w GaN charger
- esperent 3y agoMy laptop was advertised as being 2.4kg. But the charger weighs 900g, so it feels almost like a scam to claim that (it's a 240w charger and it's the size and weight of a literal brick). The real weight of the laptop + charger + plug is 3.5kg. It's become a kind of hobby of mine, once a month or so, to search AliExpress to see if there's any way I can replace my 240w MSI charging brick with a GAN version yet. I keep finding GAN chargers that almost work - either not quite powerful enough, or don't have the right adapter.
- shortrounddev2 3y agoWhat is the use case for these types of machines?
- tiew9Vii 3y agoThey make good low powered virtualization machines (proxmox)/firewalls (opensense etc)/linux desktops. Network doesn't seem great on this though, most of the Aliexpress N200 boxes support 2.5G and fanless.
- tmoertel 3y agoDoes anyone know of an off-the-shelf mini PC that supports ECC memory? As memory capacities increase, I don't know why ECC isn't becoming more common.
- ysleepy 3y agoI believe the, slightly larger, asrock deskmeet x300 supports ECC with ryzen pro APUs. It has 4x DDR4 slots, and can be cheaply equipped with 128G ecc memory nowadays.
- flagged24 3y agoI got a similar priced, but slightly larger form factor, an AsRock X300 mini-STX. A silent Noctua fan, 64GB RAM with an AMD Ryzen 5700G (about 77% faster than the Intel N200 in this mini pc) it idles at 12 Watt but can go up to 133 Watt if required. I think the mini-STX form factor is more serviceable and doesn't take up that much more space. It's "fanless" on idle but can spin up the fan when it needs to. You can get a lot more bang for the buck with a custom build.
- bee_rider 3y agoI had a NUC for a long time, I liked it because it fit in my bike’s under seat bag, or in the bigger pockets of my cargo pants. More portable than a laptop, I didn’t even need a backpack—assuming I was going somewhere with a keyboard and monitor (or I could ssh from my cellphone, with a fold out keyboard, but that is a pretty cramped experience). Which is just to say it is a different niche than any desktop.
- grigio 3y agoBitcoin payment do not work
- frazar0 3y ago> Fanless 0 dB design Note that 0 in dB scale indicates a 1:1 ratio with something, and not a zero in linear scale. Indeed, a zero in linear scale corresponds to -infinity in dB scale.
- crackedbassoon 3y agoFor sound, dB is shorthand for dB SPL, or dBs above 20 μPa, which is roughly the threshold of human hearing. So 0 dB means 1:1 with that threshold, or essentially “silent”. I think most people would intuitively conclude as much without knowing the specifics, so it’s not unclear or wrong to label this device as 0 dB (unless it actually does produce an audible sound, or course).