5 ms·
Finland introduces the world’s first phone-free tourist island
- nicbou 3y agoThis is so paternalistic. You know what I love? Identifying plants, looking things up and reading ebooks. I don’t take many pictures, but I appreciate having them as a way to situate an experience in time. I am fine with this way of using technology in nature. Let me enjoy nature how I damn please. My experience is valid too. You do you, I do me.
- skellyclock 3y ago[flagged]
- leipert 3y ago> For those apprehensive about giving up their devices, the “digital fasting” is entirely voluntary – the island has a fully functioning mobile network.
- nicbou 3y agoThen there is no story
- josephcsible 3y agoCan't you voluntarily choose to not use a phone anywhere? What makes this island special then?
- eesmith 3y agoIt's a publicity stunt, like how Sommarøy a few year back declared it was the world’s first time-free zone. https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/norway-sommaroy-island-publicity-stunt/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/norway-sommaroy-islan...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- totallywrong 3y agoSo go to literally anywhere else in the planet. This is a great idea I really hope it sets a trend.
- dumpsterdiver 3y agoRight? We're so sorry that you can't stand the thought of other people not being on their phones in order to find out what plant they are looking at, but there really is a very simple solution. Don't go there, and don't be one of those people looking at those plants.
- nicbou 3y agoYou write as if I'm foaming at the mouth typing this. I'm using the comments section to comment about something. I think it's dumb and I won't think about it ever again. In any case it's not actually phone-free, just a publicity stunt.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dumpsterdiver 3y agoThe way that I phrased my comment was a little rude. I apologize. I was meaning to agree with the parent poster, but in doing so I was uncharitable with my interpretation of your comment. I shouldn't have taken such a dismissive attitude, that doesn't really help anything.
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoThey put a sticker on people's devices and ask them top pretty please not use them. Anyone can still go there and use their phones as much as they like. It's another social advertising campaign by 'Parks and Wildlife Finland', intended to be spread around internet forums and social media. Doesn't cost them anything, it's a clever idea. And some food for thought, you'd never know about it if you weren't online, nor would you ever have heard of this random island. Of which Finland has hundreds of similar ones.
- AlbertCory 3y agoYou can do you at almost every place on the planet. Why can't there be one place where you don't choose to go?
- gyulai 3y agoThe converse is also true: If someone likes to be without phone, couldn't they go literally anywhere on the planet, and just choose to leave their phone at home without that place they're going to officially encouraging them to do so? Or is it about the disturbance caused by other people using their phones? ...or maybe to have a plausible story to tell the people who tried to reach you? ("Sorry you couldn't reach me at the weekend, boss, I was at this island in Finland where ...").
- kristiandupont 3y agoI can't speak to GP but I would definitely say that phones everywhere are a nuisance. Google "Ruined by Instagram" for plenty of lists. I think this is a lovely initiative and I think it would be great if it could cause a bit of a trend.
- strken 3y agoThe nice thing about places that were supposedly ruined by Instagram is that most of them were already overcrowded and boring anyway. As an Australian it's hilarious to talk to tourists and hear they're going to get a bus from Melbourne to the 12 Apostles and back, which is an 8 hour round trip, but aren't planning to spend time at the rest of the spectacularly beautiful coastline or national parks in between. The most popular tourist destinations all seem to be like that: you go there to cross them off the list even though comparably beautiful and much less popular attractions are nearby, for the sake of going somewhere recognisable. There's nothing wrong with going to a few well known spots in a holiday, but if you just go straight from tourist trap to tourist trap you'll miss all the most enjoyable things.
- Amiable5326 3y ago[flagged]
- tired-turtle 3y agoIn your moral framework, am I allowed to use my smartphone when I’m out trail running? Caltopo has helped me not get lost on long loops where turning around isn’t an option.
- mulmen 3y agoPro tip: if you start a statement with "no offense but" that is an admission that you know what comes next is offensive.
- Mashimo 3y agoNo offense, but I like dogs.
- _hush_ 3y agoThis is super offensive!!
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoNo offense, but that soccer team just can't score any goals!
- midoridensha 3y ago>... a lot of the problems we have in the West is ... obvious that smartphones are terrible for people especially when they are trying to relax in nature. Over here in the Far East, everyone has a phone with them, whether they're in the city or up in the mountains enjoying nature. If you get attacked by a bear or have some other emergency, not having a phone means you'll probably die, so not carrying one is a good way to get a Darwin Award. So weird when people try to blame things on "the West".
- UberFly 3y agoYour response sounds rebellious-teen juvenile. The place isn't meant for you then obviously. No one's telling you to clean your room.
- dumpsterdiver 3y agoWhen you make belittling comments like you just did, it really takes away from your point. It wasn't necessary to lower the conversation into name calling (i.e. rebellious-teen juvenile). You could have made your point without lashing out.
- ffhhttt 3y agoTo be fair this is just a marketing campaign some people on this thread seem to be taking way to seriously for some reason…
- nicbou 3y agoThis can be a pleasant community if you follow the guidelines and avoid this sort of name-calling. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- solardev 3y agoSoooo... don't go there?
- beebeepka 3y agoNo, no, no. That's too paternalistic. The poster has to identify plants, and maybe take pictures with their zombie phone. Do they also use their device to block stairs or crosswalks? If their first reaction to this was "but I need it", then maybe.
- klyrs 3y agoIt's like that time my mom bought a VIP ticket to a Drake show so she could talk to him afterwards and tell him to his face that she doesn't much care for rap music. (this anecdote is a complete fabrication but I had fun writing it)
- dumpsterdiver 3y ago(your mom) "Drake! I don't appreciate your music." (Drake) "Oh, I'm... sorry." (your mom, nodding emphatically) "I came here to give you a piece of my mind. I paid $740 to get me and my children in here so I can say this to your face." (Drake, nodding) "Madam, please... it is your right." (your mom) "Well I didn't like it! I don't like any of your music!" (Drake, nodding again) "Ma'am, I'm not sure I like it either. I'm just selling records here."
- nicbou 3y agoThe point of a comment system is to discuss the content of an article. This is what I did. The likelihood of me going there either way is pretty small.
- solardev 3y agoSure. We're discussing it. We just don't agree with you.
- lost_tourist 3y agoSo don't go to the island?
- Giorgi 3y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- awestroke 3y agoYeah, if they can't scroll tiktok they might die!
- blowski 3y agoI imagine some people worry how they would deal with getting lost or being injured. It’s a fair point because so much now assumes you will have a smartphone with you at all times. That’s why it’s nice having somewhere that doesn’t assume that.
- blowski 3y agoA few years back, unstated on a farm with no electricity and I couldn’t got phone signal. As a result, I had no phone for a week. I loved it. The days passed more slowly, I wrote more freely, read more deeply, and spent more time being aware of what was around me.
- throw_pm23 3y agoI haven't had a smartphone for ~7 years. I love it. I have a dumb phone hardly anyone calls, so often I leave it at home.
- Moru 3y agoMy mother has a dumbphone too. Sweden is soon shutting down the 2G and 3G networks so then it will certainly be quiet.
- Zitrax 3y agoI don't have the full overview, but there are new "dumb" phones made that has 4G/5G, no? (Nokia 8210 seem to be one example, Punkt MP02 another)
- timeon 3y agoBut is Edge still available then?
- distances 3y agoSource for the 2G closure? 3G is getting silent in many areas but I've understood 2G usually stays to provide calls & sms in low coverage areas.
- sattoshi 3y agoThis is entirely voluntary. I’m not sure what this is beyond saying “if you want, you can put your phone away!” You always had that option everywhere. Are people more tempted to phone if they see other people on their phones? I never felt that.
- rhn_mk1 3y agoThink of it this way: you can wear a silly hat anywhere you want. What effect would it have on silly hat population if you explicitly invited people to wear silly hats on your island?
- sattoshi 3y agoIt’s going to birth an empty fad, where every island is a silly hat island, but most people don’t wear one. But anyways, why does it matter? Will my silly hat experience not be as good if other people aren’t wearing one? I’m wearing for myself.
- rhn_mk1 3y agoI'm not so sure about something unusual becoming an empty fad. Medieval fairs are enclaves of the different, and yet you don't see every event turning into a medieval fair to dilute the idea. A designated place matters for the experience: you can expect that the door frames and ceilings will be adjusted to accommodate your hats (i.e. no one will require a phone from you to do basic things). You may also expect other people to already be in the same mental space as you, or learning to see the world from a new perspective at the same time as you are.
- lixer 3y agoYes, for the most part if other people around you are doing something, you'll be more tempted to do the same thing. There are exceptions to this (and you might be one of them), but I know that I'd feel awkward using a phone on a phone-free island.
- onion2k 3y agoThat's not how human nature works. The fact that the island is set up to be 'mobile free' means there'll be a strong stigma about using your phone there. Everyone will stare, some people will give disapproving tuts, and I wouldn't be surprised if some even ask you to put the phone away. If you're really unfortunate people who feel very strongly will be quite angry about it. You need a strong personality to ignore 'society' when practically everyone wants you to stop doing something. Social pressure is very powerful. The island will not just be a few signs you can easily ignore. Using your phone there will be considered antisocial behavior.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hugh-avherald 3y agoPretty sure Lord Howe Island still doesn't have mobile phone coverage.
- optymizer 3y agoWhat I'd love to see is a drone free island. It feels invasive to have a drone hover over you at the beach and not even know who is filming, not to mention the annoying noise. When you look at a peaceful valley and drones are flying all over, it just kills the vibe. I wish I could disable drones with some kind of device so it would fall down and its owner would have to at least look me in the eyes to get it back.
- perceptronas 3y agoSadly, in most places (AFAIK) its outright illegal to disable drones which are even in (or over) your yard
- dustymcp 3y agoi had a wifi jammer i bought from some chinese site killed everything in a sphere around you, fairly sure it would disconnect drones aswell, we had some fun times with that :)
- sofixa 3y agoIn all European countries I've looked the regulations of (Portugal and France), it's illegal to run drones without prior permission from the relevant authorities (in Portugal if it's near the coast, you need permission from the coast guard too), over people, and over protected places (which in France it's most of it).
- lencastre 3y agoThis is great!! In Germany there is a map with the areas that are strictly forbidden (all private areas of villages and cities, residential areas, and I think all governments buildings and security at-risk facilities), those that require permission (certain city areas and parks), and those which no permission required (middle of the woods). Also the height matters, often only above 100 m is allowed — there is a whole ordnance about this which surely is constantly being updated. My co purchased a drone and I had to test before shipping it abroad and I risked running for 1 minute in my garden area flying over 100 m. But then I found out that I could film our head office premises closer than 50 m height but not the streets around it. Finally I found that the parking place of the park could be filmed but not the park. All this was duly cataloged online with overlapping areas. In the end too much hassle. When the drone was abroad (in South America) no trouble whatsoever…