8 ms·
I went back and forth on the idea of sharing such a negative take here, but... here goes. > You'll need to find a truck that is at least 25 years old. In the U
by kelnos 3y ago
I went back and forth on the idea of sharing such a negative take here, but... here goes.
> You'll need to find a truck that is at least 25 years old. In the US, cars more youthful than that must comply with FMVSS (safety standards).
> No air bags, [...] power steering, or crumple zones.
I feel like this sort of thing is a fantastic illustration of the irresponsible level which most drivers (in the US at least; can't speak to other countries) feel that they are just so so good at driving that they believe all these safety features are fine to go without.
Sure, this is presumably not your sole vehicle or daily driver. And sure, you're not going to be taking one of these on a 65mph highway. But a 30mph head-on collision with another vehicle will almost certainly kill you in one of these trucks. And I know if I was the driver of the other vehicle, and survived, even if I wasn't the one at fault, I'd probably need years of expensive therapy to get past it all.
The thing that boggles my mind his how this 25-year-old grandfathering thing works. I think it's totally fair to allow old vehicles on the road that may not comply with today's standards, but did comply when they were originally made and titled (in the US). But there's no good reason we need to allow people to import old, unsafe vehicles like this.
- willcipriano 3y agoI don't understand the anger and disdain from people about others potentially hurting themselves. The only thing I can think of is they are jealous of someone who doesn't have these sort of intrusive thoughts about safety all the time and how they get to do something cool like the OP every now and then.
- thebigjewbowski 3y agoI was thinking about something similar the other day — why does anyone besides my family really care if I wear a seatbelt or not? You know what vehicle I see all the time that doesn’t require a license or minimum age, doesn’t have any safety features and can go 15-20 mph alongside traffic and often on a city sidewalk amongst pedestrians? A bicycle ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- habosa 3y agoI’d really prefer not to kill anybody else I’m sharing the road with, all else equal. It would be quite traumatic for that persons family and for me too.
- renewiltord 3y agoTrue. Which is why I would like to make it the law that all motor vehicle occupants should wear helmets. This will mean saving billions of life years lost through traumatic brain injuries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HWR_14 3y agoWhat if the helmets were giant (unlike bike helmets, the rider doesn't have to carry the entire weight or air resistance). Then, instead of filling the helmets with hard styrofoam, we could fill them with something even softer, maybe a compressible gas. People could obviously store them in the vehicle. It might be annoying to wear them all the time, so we could mandate that cars detect when you are about to be in a crash and slam a helmet on your head. Although, come to think of it, it doesn't need to surround your whole head. What if we could make it just appear between your head and anything you were going to hit. Hey, we could even have those things hold the micro helmets. Since they are filled with air, we can use air pressure to deploy them fast, these flexible bags of air.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're kind of making their point for them. It's dumb to mandate helmets or any other specific technology because it removes the possibility for something better or for context-based decisionmaking. Suppose you ride your motorcycle into the desert and then lose your helmet into a canyon. Your phone is dead. Your choices are a thirty hour walk out of the desert which might cause you to die of dehydration, or riding your motorcycle without a helmet. Should you get a ticket for making the obvious choice?
- metalcrow 3y agoTechnically it's a drain on society's safety nets. If people hurt themselves it requires investments of health care workers and tax dollars. Now this isn't a really strong argument in the US, since we don't have socialized healthcare, but it's not nonexistent either. Also, the other argument goes that "people don't know how to actually get what they want for themselves, and will act against their own true self-interests". Which is definitely true to an extend but the devil is in how far you're willing to stretch that.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Technically it's a drain on society's safety nets. The solution to this is to replace safety nets with transfer payments. Don't provide people with healthcare, provide them with money with which they can buy healthcare or insurance. This also stops the subsidy from ratcheting up the cost of the thing, because if you can drive 30 minutes out of your way to save a thousand dollars you do it, but if the government is paying either way then you don't. And then if people want to buy less safe cars, insurance carriers will charge them higher premiums. > Also, the other argument goes that "people don't know how to actually get what they want for themselves, and will act against their own true self-interests". This is nothing more than paternalism and has proved wrong time and again. It turns out that on average people understand their own situation better than far away generalist policymakers, even before you add in lobbyist influence. Which isn't to say that an individual will never make a mistake. But legislators make mistakes at scale. Whereas if you want to get individuals to change their behavior in a way that genuinely benefits them, all you have to do is tell them about it, not punish them if they hear you out and still want to do something else.
- namdnay 3y ago> This also stops the subsidy from ratcheting up the cost of the thing, because if you can drive 30 minutes out of your way to save a thousand dollars you do it, but if the government is paying either way then you don't. If the government is paying, why would it be cheaper 30 minutes away? One of the main features of single payer systems is that the single payer can impose a price list, and control any “ratcheting of prices” as you put it
- nine_k 3y agoPotentially hurting themselves only is okay: ride some extreme mountain bike, lift extreme weights, ski on risky slopes, consume strange substances, etc. But on a road people don't just hurt themselves by reckless conduct. A collision usually has a second participation vehicle, and sometimes many more if a pile-up occurs on a busy road. The other participants did not sign up for hurting themselves, and can be hurt more than the original reckless driver.
- ilyt 3y agoRight but smaller kei car have less mass and gonna induce less damage in crash. So you should be cheering for people to get them as if they crash into you, you're safer
- bowsamic 3y agoI'm sorry to be blunt, but do you really not understand that you are not the only one hurt when you crash a car? I often see this with regards to car crashes, people often say "the only one you hurt is yourself", and I feel like I must be on drugs or something, because I am pretty damn sure that this is not true
- AussieWog93 3y agoI'm not a car guy, but I do know that people get really passionate about them, join local clubs and make new friends through their shared love of some particular old vehicle. They also put huge amounts of effort into maintaining them, learn new skills and keep themselves busy. So while vintage cars and the culture around them do obviously cause deaths due to accidents, I'd suspect they also perform a huge amount of social good in terms of reducing social isolation, depression/despair, Alzheimer's and a whole lot of other subtle things I didn't even consider.
- o1y32 3y agoThat's a real stretch and a weak argument.
- sentientslug 3y agoThat’s, like, your opinion, man.
- sellmesoap 3y agoI'd note that pickup trucks made in north America were last to have such simple safety equipment as head restraints in the back seat. Whereas I'd note that import trucks on the domestic market had them first. Some of us aren't made of money and a Japanese import even at 15 (Canada) or 25 years old may have a much better price and lower milage then a domestic vehicle half as old. Trucks have been last to the game for safety and emissions standards. I'd argue these imports with engines half the displacement of sub-compact cars are a boon for DIY and handy-people.
- caconym_ 3y ago> The thing that boggles my mind his how this 25-year-old grandfathering thing works. I think it's totally fair to allow old vehicles on the road that may not comply with today's standards, but did comply when they were originally made and titled (in the US). But there's no good reason we need to allow people to import old, unsafe vehicles like this. If safety was a primary concern for U.S. regulators, large consumer SUVs and trucks would not exist in their current form. As of ~2019 (the last such study I know of) trucks killed occupants of other vehicles at 2.5x the rate of cars and "SUVs" (an increasingly useless category as it includes everything from small unibody crossovers to enormous body-on-frame Canyonero-style monstrosities). I am not aware of any comparable headline figure for how pedestrians fare against them but I would put money on their pedestrian safety performance also being atrocious. They are quite literally an atrocity against the American people, a public health hazard of the first order, and our regulators evidently do not give one single shit. Through that lens the opinion you've expressed here—that people should not be allowed to drive cars that make them more unsafe—is extremely ironic, because the semiliterate chuds who support the unrestrained escalation of larger and deadlier and larger and deadlier vehicles on public roads make the exact opposite "argument" as a justification of why they should be allowed: freedom, personal responsibility, etcetera. I elide the details because it's mad-libs anyway, not any kind of coherent position unless one discards the notion of a social contract entirely. I'm not suggesting you yourself hold an opinion like that, but it seems a uniquely American dichotomy that one is not allowed to drive a car that makes oneself more likely to die, but there is absolutely no problem with driving a car that's several times more likely to kill somebody else.
- 13of40 3y agoI think it might be a little more nuanced than that. I have a friend who's still alive today because he was driving a Lexus SUV when a Honda Accord blew through a red light and collided with him at speed. Should he downgrade his car so he's more vulnerable next time?
- COGlory 3y agoEveryone should constantly buy a bigger car than what everyone else is buying. It's the only way to stay safe.
- habosa 3y agoDriving in the US is such a nightmare because everyone seems to think it’s their own video game and where they are the main character avoiding cops and NPCs.
- nateberkopec 3y agoAll your points about 25-year-old safety standards is perfectly valid. However, re: "crumple zones": The streets of the USA are basically an arms race. Bigger and bigger and bigger because "it's safer". Safer for you, maybe. This is how we ended up with pickup trucks that have hoods as high as your shoulders. Kei trucks and cars are great, and in Japan they're quite safe (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24499113/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24499113/) but the context is completely different. Cars weigh half as much, the drivers are twice as careful and traveling at half the speed.
- skhr0680 3y agoI can remember at least one instance this year where an entire family died from when their Kei car got rolled over in what would have been a survivable accident in a vehicle built to full size safety standards. Kei cars are popular because they’re cheap to run and small, but they are a tin can on wheels.
- rhaway84773 3y agoThe 25 year thing is a loophole intended to allow for the import of vintage cars.
- joecool1029 3y agoA kei truck is still safer than taking a bicycle or motorcycle on public roads. Do you propose banning those? How about the giant trucks with huge blindspots known to roll over kids in driveways, where's the outrage there? > But there's no good reason we need to allow people to import old, unsafe vehicles like this. Sure there is, there's a gap in the market for small efficient light trucks/vans for around town and in urban environments, things that don't need to go on interstates. Light vehicles that don't mess up the roads like 6000lb+ vehicles. But we aren't allowed to have nice things like this due to the tariff situation, so the 25yr loophole is currently the only way.
- o1y32 3y agoNah, this is some terrible whataboutism. Stick to the topic.
- subsistence234 3y agono it's not, it addresses the core of the idiotic argument. "we should ban participating in traffic without the safety features of a new car." No we shouldn't for the same reason we don't ban bicycles, motorbikes, scooters,... which are at least as dangerous to drive as an old tiny car.
- refurb 3y agoThe one thing that opened my eyes about this view of safety is living in a developing country. Riding a motorcycle without helmets, kids on their laps, cars without seatbelts, makeshift trucks with cargo randomly stacked and not strapped down. They are completely oblivious to the safety risks. But you know what? 99% of the time it doesn't matter. They live long and healthy lives. I get the sense the West has progressively improved safety to the point that even small incremental improvements are viewed as "you'll be dead without them".
- Shaanie 3y agoThe ones that don't die or get permanently maimed in an accident live long and healthy lives, you mean. Which is still a very large majority, sure, but dying from a road accident is still a way more common way to die in those countries (7-15 times more likely than where I live), and it's a sudden death that can happen to anyone of any age. A kid needlessly dying because his parent irresponsibly carried her on their lap is such a waste of a life.
- tehwebguy 3y agoOne of the wildest examples of literal survivorship bias I’ve ever heard
- refurb 3y agoIt's not. Even with their lack of concern around safety the chances of dying in a motor vehicle wreck are almost nil. Like I said, in the West, people are so concerned about safety they loose all sense of relativeness. Saying that "wow, your car doesn't have airbags, you're as good as dead" is a ridiculous statement.
- tehwebguy 3y agoWhat are you talking about? Hitting your head really hard can permanently injure you, or kill you.
- 3y ago
- ApolloFortyNine 3y ago>And I know if I was the driver of the other vehicle, and survived, even if I wasn't the one at fault, I'd probably need years of expensive therapy to get past it all. >But there's no good reason we need to allow people to import old, unsafe vehicles like this. If this is your argument, motorcycles seems like a much better target.
- chipsa 3y agoEven if it did largely comply with FMVSS, it wouldn't be importable if less than 25 years old, because it doesn't meet US specific regs, including US crash testing. I couldn't buy a brand new Skoda and bring it over, even though it met all the Euro crash testing and safety regs, because it doesn't have everything done to be sold over here. The only exceptions are stuff that's 25 years old, and stuff that's so limited production that it doesn't have to meet it (like a Koenigsegg, I think).
- quailfarmer 3y agoHaving driven these quite a bit, I think its important to understand that while they're not particularly safe, they don't _feel_ particularly safe. 25mph feels incredibly fast, sort of like riding a bike. I think it's far easier to drive 75mph in a small sedan and have a close call with a large truck, and not recognize the danger. I think this added caution likely mitigates lack of safety features at least somewhat.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>I feel like this sort of thing is a fantastic illustration of the irresponsible level Motorcycles are much less safe when compared to this truck. Would you also ban them, or do they receive an arbitrary exception?
- xsmasher 3y agoI had a similar thought today about e-bikes and other micro vehicles; why do we allow e-bikes to ride on the road, but ban small trucks and tuk-tuks like this one? https://electrek.co/2021/10/25/i-actually-bought-a-cheap-electric-pickup-truck-from-alibaba-heres-what-showed-up/ https://electrek.co/2021/10/25/i-actually-bought-a-cheap-ele...
- Eisenstein 3y agoBecause e-bikes are hard to differentiate from pedal bikes legally and we haven't done it yet, and if you advocated banning bicycles on roads I wouldn't like you very much.
- harambae 3y agoA better comparison, as far as flowing with traffic, is a moped (i.e. Honda Navi, top speed 55mph) rather than a motorcycle (i.e. Suzuki SV650, top speed 130mph). I had to look it up myself, not being sure, but "the Navi isn’t freeway-legal in many states" [0] So probably allowing them on city streets but not highways is what I would propose, to answer your question. I don't think banning them altogether is right (for the Kei truck or Navi) since micromobility has all sorts of benefits where it fits. [0] https://ultimatemotorcycling.com/2022/07/28/2022-honda-navi-buyers-guide-specs-ride-review-and-27-photos/ https://ultimatemotorcycling.com/2022/07/28/2022-honda-navi-...
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoAre there companies making modern versions of these vehicles (with the same small size and great fuel economy but with modern safety features)?
- quickthrower2 3y agoHow does this reconcile with motorcycles? Ok that is whataboutism I will admit! But this is going to be safer than a bike most likely.
- hakfoo 3y agoAs I understand it, there was a time when people would buy expensive luxury European cars in their countries of manufacture, and import them for their own use, which cut out the local wing of the manufacturer, local dealers, etc. This probably offered a broader range of models and options and may also have saved money. They could care less about the 25-year-old cars-- it's the new ones, the ones that probably meet or exceed the spirit of US safety standards but have some marginal differences from US norms or lack a formal certification, that they're after. They probably offered the 25 year carveout to make sure they could get the restriction on the important commercial market without creating a dispute with a niche community (the vintage-car enthusiasts) that could derail the whole regulatory process. To me, the equally weird part is the car-of-Thesus situation. We have a regulatory environment that says basically "here's a block of rust that was demolished in an accident and sat for 25 years in the rain in a scrapyard, but because it has the VIN plate from an ancient Mustang/Defender/Porsche/etc. on it, you can build basically an entirely new car around it and not have to honour modern rules about safety or emissions." There isn't an obvious way to incentivize the classic-car people to think in terms of those standards when they retrofit.
- agloe_dreams 3y agoI’m going to guess that you also want to outlaw motorcycles?
- Gordonjcp 3y ago> But a 30mph head-on collision with another vehicle will almost certainly kill you in one of these trucks. A 30mph collision in the average American SUV will kill all the occupants too, because they have absolutely no safety features.
- ghaff 3y agoExcept for airbags, seatbelts, crumple zones, automatic braking, etc.
- Gordonjcp 3y agoYeah, they don't really have crumple zones, that's kind of the problem. "Look at how strong this truck is, it survived an accident with barely a scratch!" just means it transferred all the energy to the wet squashy piles of mixed meat inside.
- nequo 3y agoThe NHTSA publishes safety ratings for every vehicle. You can look at their crash test reports. The 2021 Chevy Tahoe[1] and the 2020 Ford Explorer[2] are comparable to the 2022 Toyota Corolla.[2] The photos clearly show the presence of crumple zones. In each of the PDFs, you can find the occupant data summary on page 6 and the photos starting around page 42. [1] https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v11300/v11350R001.pdf https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v11300... [2] https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v11000/v11053R001.pdf https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v11000... [3] https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v10600/v10651R001.pdf https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v10000/v10600...
- ilyt 3y agoWell, motorcycles are allowed and they are far less safer in crash than any kei-truck would be. I'm not getting one because of reasons you mentioned (litte kei tipper would be perfect size vehicle for my needs) but I don't see why other people should be stopped from. If you want safety ban anything bigger than 2 ton for non-commercial use first, the SUVs and trucks sizing gonna kill more people than some random buying a kei truck for themselves.