2 ms·
Maybe I'm crazy, but why is it bad to release a phone with 2.3 and update it to 4.0 a month or two later? Apart from the blog reviewers and the early adopters
by ZeroGravitas 15y ago
Maybe I'm crazy, but why is it bad to release a phone with 2.3 and update it to 4.0 a month or two later?
Apart from the blog reviewers and the early adopters who actually even gets to see the old version? Would they really be served by delaying the hardware? Just to satisfy some neat-freak OCD tendency? How is this different from someone buying an iPhone a few months before the new one comes out with an iOS bump? Is that a horrifying experience too?
- gnaffle 15y agoThere's nothing wrong with that. The problem is that Sony Ericsson (and others) have made many promises on upgrades that they have been unable to keep. If Apple released the iPhone 5 running iOS 3 while promising to update it to iOS 5 later, at the very least people would be thinking that Apple could use some improvement in their development process. If Google had been more open in their development of Android, all members of the OHA would have had repository access before release of a new version, and manufacturers would outside of the launch partner would have been able to develop their new hardware on the latest OS release.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoYou're begging the question. Apple doesn't do it for iOS, but why does that make it unthinkable? Apple don't perfectly sync up their Mac OS X and hardware releases, you buy your hardware and then shortly afterwards you pay(!) to upgrade. If Apple can do it for laptops (and the first iPad), why can't Sony do it for phones? Because a third party has released a device with a fourth parties updated software? I understand that Google's releases schedule is different from Microsoft Windows and Apple's Mac OS X and iOS, I'm looking for reasons why a consumer should care. Personally I see benefits to their approach e.g. rapid evolution. (Note, I understand that making promises and breaking them is bad, it just seems most of the comments focus not on the breaking of a promise, but the very thought of disjoint hardware and software release dates)
- gnaffle 15y agoThe focus of the comments is not the disjoint between software and hardware releases, but rather that manufacturers are very slow to update to newer software releases. That's what everyone's complaining about. Sony Ericsson releasing a new phone with an old operating system is just another indication of that. For your comparison to be accurate, Apple would have had to release a new Mac that didn't run Mountain Lion, two months after Mountain Lion was released. Or, HP would have had to release a new laptop that didn't run Windows 7 after Windows 7 was released. There's nothing wrong with doing that, but it's unlikely to happen simply because Microsoft is providing HP with prereleases way before a new Windows version is announced, while Google is currently only providing that service to their Nexus launch partner (at least that's the excuse that Sony Ericsson had).
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoOther people not doing it doesn't mean there's anything wrong with it (as you yourself have pointed out twice) so... what makes it bad? Google lets consumers use products that it labels as "beta"? Is this bad? Why? Google only let people with invites into Gmail at first. Is this bad? Why Google tests changes by pushing them to random subsets of web visitors. Is this bad? Why? Google pushed the last version of the market to 2.3 devices before it pushed it to 2.2 devices. Is this bad? Why? Android updates seem to roll out by country over a period of weeks. Is this bad? Why? A lot of Android functionality is in Apps rather than the OS and the trend is to increase this (e.g. Chrome on a 6 week update schedule). Is this bad? Why? You could have interesting, enlightening debates about any of these decisions and reasonable people could argue either side of each of them. But it seems we skipped that step for Android updates and decided that if it wasn't the same as Apple it must be bad. I'm just looking for an actual reason why an average consumer (or indeed any particular subset of consumers) would prefer everyone to adopt Apple's model to justify these strongly and loudly held opinions. Note that "not having the latest version of the OS" is not a reason why not having the latest version of the OS is bad, it's just restating the question.
- gnaffle 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]