3 ms·
Good for fraudsters and spammers, bad for anyone who ever hoped to make a living from voice acting. I'm perplexed by AI technologists' seemingly incessant drive
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Good for fraudsters and spammers, bad for anyone who ever hoped to make a living from voice acting. I'm perplexed by AI technologists' seemingly incessant drive to automate away the existence of artistic performers.
- croes 3y agoWhy spare artists if everyone else gets replaced by technology?
- anigbrowl 3y agoThey don't, otherwise there would be many former CEOs living in tents. In reality, those who control large amounts of capital are quite willing (and increasingly, say so in the open) to to deprive others of their livelihoods, homes, and ability to feed themselves in order to realize a marginal increase in their own wealth.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThe function of CEOs and board members are closer to being replaced than, say, roofers or garbage workers. It will be interesting to see what happens when that pressure is applied...
- krapp 3y agoCapitalism will never allow capitalists to be made redundant - that's not how it works.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoIt will if its more profitable, which it is.
- Legend2440 3y agoYou are being deliberately pessimistic. There are a million fantastic, practical uses for text-to-speech.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI am not. The use cases like interactive assistants for the blind will generate very little commercial activity compared to the uses (and abuses) for entertainment and marketing purposes. A good example of this from the real world is the absence of cheap/open ASL interpretation for deaf people.
- Legend2440 3y agoImagine having an app on your phone that turns any ebook into an audiobook. Imagine replacing crappy phone menus with polite virtual assistants that actually understand what you're saying. Imagine an AI language tutor that speaks every language in the world fluently. Or a universal speech-to-speech translator. And that's just off the top of my head. Clever people will come up with a lot more uses, I'm sure.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI don't need your help imagining use cases; I've been in this field a lot longer than you, and have talked up the technological possibilities of AI-powered TTS here for *years. I understand the technology very well and am bullish on it. What I'm saying is that too much of the effort is being spent in solving the wrong problems. Please try reading what I wrote instead of your imaginary subtext.
- signatoremo 3y agoEver notice big huge font on the phone of older people? So big that a screen may only contain a few lines of text. Or that people has to pull out their reading glasses every time they check their phone? Text to speech is a godsend in that case. Enormous benefits to an increasingly older population.
- wg0 3y agoLLMs aren't great and can't be relied upon in business setting or at least I would not. But think open world games. GTA VII for example where all NPCs have their dialogs auto generated in real time but also converted to audio in real time. That's going to be a world which would be a lot more spontaneous with lot less effort. Right now, If memory serves me right, GTA V dialogs alone are 5000 pages or more, hand written.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThat's all true, but I think it's a pity that the jobs that currently exist for voice artists will disappear. Gamers and consumers will have somewhat better interactive experiences, which is good. Indie game developers will also be able to put out games with lower budgets, which is nice for them. But the market for voice acting work is largely going to dry up and blow away for people who are not already at the top of that field. People who could previously have made a modest but sufficient living as voice performers will be replaced by computer-generated voices. It will be almost impossible to make a living in that field within 5 years.
- wg0 3y agoGenerative models around images are nothing new and have been around for a while already. But even today, if you really want creative control and expression, you need a designer that's good with Photoshop or Illustrator etc. This is applicable to LLMs as well. You can get it to write plausible BS but if you really want a rooted in reality, well articulated write up about something, a human has to be taken onboard. This equally extends to voice over. If you really want expressive and creative control to put some outstanding rendering of something, AI isn't going to cut it.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThis is only true if you assume AI isn't going to keep improving. It gets significantly better on a quarterly basis, far faster than the time it takes for an actor to develop their craft and career. The output quality of todays' cutting edge models would have been science fiction only 2-3 years ago.