4 ms·

So why aren't new doctors opening their own practices? What has changed in the last 20/30/40 years that are leading up and coming doctors to choose working for

So why aren't new doctors opening their own practices? What has changed in the last 20/30/40 years that are leading up and coming doctors to choose working for someone else instead of opening their own practice?

fiprofessor 3y ago
I think they will over time if PE deals start to implode or reveal themselves to be as bad as people claim. But the reaction will take a while to happen. With partnership-based models, it's not necessarily the case that most of the doctors who owned their practices were necessarily that entrepreneurial. Many probably joined the practice and then became partners after a few years with buy-in and sweat equity. There's some risk and business management involved, but not the same as really doing your own thing. The path was laid out. (Kind of like lawyers at big law firms.) The real entrepreneurs were the ones who initially founded a practice from scratch. But for some specialties where PE has taken hold, you need a group of people with enough capital to do that, negotiate contracts with hospitals for admitting privileges, wait-out a non-compete from a prior practice, etc. That takes time, and meanwhile, the net share of PE held firms may still increase for a while as other firms continue to sell out.
lapcat 3y ago
Possibly medical school debt. And of course nobody has sympathy for doctors with student loan debt, but the debt may still have important effects on the economy down the line.
lotsofpulp 3y ago
Because the ROI dropped precipitously. Governments were paying much better, insurance companies were paying much better, liability was a lot less, documentation and paperwork was a lot less. The 80s to 00s doctor years were very good. Now the power is in the hands of the government and huge insurance companies, and to compete with them, you need to be part of a large healthcare provider group, which ends up happening as an employee. Plus medical school debt and increasing years to become fully practicing like having to do longer residencies and fellowships.
vkou 3y ago
> So why aren't new doctors opening their own practices? For the same reason that nobody builds out a second set of power lines to compete with an incumbent power utility. It's capital-intensive, the size of the medical market for the area is fixed, and you'll just be fighting the established practice for it in a zero-sum game. You can win, but it's going to be way more work for less reward than just finding a PE practice that's hiring/a traditional practice with spare space that's looking for a partner.

fiprofessor 3y ago

I think they will over time if PE deals start to implode or reveal themselves to be as bad as people claim. But the reaction will take a while to happen. With partnership-based models, it's not necessarily the case that most of the doctors who owned their practices were necessarily that entrepreneurial. Many probably joined the practice and then became partners after a few years with buy-in and sweat equity. There's some risk and business management involved, but not the same as really doing your own thing. The path was laid out. (Kind of like lawyers at big law firms.) The real entrepreneurs were the ones who initially founded a practice from scratch. But for some specialties where PE has taken hold, you need a group of people with enough capital to do that, negotiate contracts with hospitals for admitting privileges, wait-out a non-compete from a prior practice, etc. That takes time, and meanwhile, the net share of PE held firms may still increase for a while as other firms continue to sell out.

lapcat 3y ago

Possibly medical school debt. And of course nobody has sympathy for doctors with student loan debt, but the debt may still have important effects on the economy down the line.

lotsofpulp 3y ago

Because the ROI dropped precipitously. Governments were paying much better, insurance companies were paying much better, liability was a lot less, documentation and paperwork was a lot less. The 80s to 00s doctor years were very good. Now the power is in the hands of the government and huge insurance companies, and to compete with them, you need to be part of a large healthcare provider group, which ends up happening as an employee. Plus medical school debt and increasing years to become fully practicing like having to do longer residencies and fellowships.

vkou 3y ago

> So why aren't new doctors opening their own practices? For the same reason that nobody builds out a second set of power lines to compete with an incumbent power utility. It's capital-intensive, the size of the medical market for the area is fixed, and you'll just be fighting the established practice for it in a zero-sum game. You can win, but it's going to be way more work for less reward than just finding a PE practice that's hiring/a traditional practice with spare space that's looking for a partner.