5 ms·

Physicians are absolutely reimbursed per procedure, per surgery, per test, etc. OB specifically has a higher concentration of employed doctors, but the hospital

by pc86 3y ago

Physicians are absolutely reimbursed per procedure, per surgery, per test, etc. OB specifically has a higher concentration of employed doctors, but the hospitals are still reimbursed the same way, and these numbers are 100% taken into account when determining things like bonuses and promotions. But other specialties (like family med) are still dominated by private practices where physicians directly earn more by doing more. The balancing act of this is that oversight is (typically) by qualified medical professionals who can judge whether a given procedure, test, surgery, etc. was medically indicated or not.

Calavar 3y ago
> 100% taken into account when determining things like bonuses and promotions Eh, there's some truth to what you said but it's a bit of a stretch. For bonuses, it depends on specialty and practice. In my current job I have zero incentive structure, period. If by some miracle, zero patients showed up on my shifts over the course of an entire year, I would make exactly the same as if I averaged 20 patients per day. I also don't get any reimbursed for any of the procedures I do -- 100% of that goes to the hospital. This is an increasingly common compensation model in pretty much every nonsurgical speciality and even in a small number of surgical ones (Ob/Gyn, as you mentioned). As for promotions, I don't think that's true at all. First, physicians tend to have a very flat hierarchy outside of academics. (At many hospitals, you're either CMO, a department chief, or just some guy.) What this means, in my personal experience, is that promotion is such a remote possibility that it's something that 80 to 85% of physicians don't spend any time thinking about. Second, productivity is not a principle criterion for promotion. When a hospital or clinic promotes a physician, they take a large chunk of that physician's clinical time and replace it with administrative work. If you're trying to maximize revenue, your most clinically productive person is precisely the last person you want to do that with. > But other specialties (like family med) are still dominated by private practices Family medicine is definitely not dominated by private practices, at least for new grads. Private practice is quickly going extinct everywhere except for those specialties that have a high proportion of out-of-pocket payors (plastic surgery, dermatology, orthopedics) or those specialties where the demand is high but the supply is so thin that hospitals can find themselves battling with each other to sign contracts with the one of the few practices in their area (neurosurgery, otolaryngology, CT surgery in some parts of the country).

by pc86 3y ago

Calavar 3y ago

> 100% taken into account when determining things like bonuses and promotions Eh, there's some truth to what you said but it's a bit of a stretch. For bonuses, it depends on specialty and practice. In my current job I have zero incentive structure, period. If by some miracle, zero patients showed up on my shifts over the course of an entire year, I would make exactly the same as if I averaged 20 patients per day. I also don't get any reimbursed for any of the procedures I do -- 100% of that goes to the hospital. This is an increasingly common compensation model in pretty much every nonsurgical speciality and even in a small number of surgical ones (Ob/Gyn, as you mentioned). As for promotions, I don't think that's true at all. First, physicians tend to have a very flat hierarchy outside of academics. (At many hospitals, you're either CMO, a department chief, or just some guy.) What this means, in my personal experience, is that promotion is such a remote possibility that it's something that 80 to 85% of physicians don't spend any time thinking about. Second, productivity is not a principle criterion for promotion. When a hospital or clinic promotes a physician, they take a large chunk of that physician's clinical time and replace it with administrative work. If you're trying to maximize revenue, your most clinically productive person is precisely the last person you want to do that with. > But other specialties (like family med) are still dominated by private practices Family medicine is definitely not dominated by private practices, at least for new grads. Private practice is quickly going extinct everywhere except for those specialties that have a high proportion of out-of-pocket payors (plastic surgery, dermatology, orthopedics) or those specialties where the demand is high but the supply is so thin that hospitals can find themselves battling with each other to sign contracts with the one of the few practices in their area (neurosurgery, otolaryngology, CT surgery in some parts of the country).