4 ms·
There's a difficult question to often answer with these kinds of things, because it isn't as straight forward as it seems. Using AI workers seems like a big ben
by godelski 3y ago
There's a difficult question to often answer with these kinds of things, because it isn't as straight forward as it seems. Using AI workers seems like a big benefit for some things because there is a huge demand for workers and not enough workers, so even a very low quality worker (i.e. AI) appears beneficial. But once AI enter a job it is entirely possible that this prevents future people from pursuing it, meaning that actual people get replaced with them. Through an entirely implicit process and not because the machines are better, thus lowering the quality of the market which was already suffering. But we don't know if this is going to happen or not and can be quite hard to predict. So do you fill in the gap with anything, even subpar, to benefit people now or do you hold off because doing so can prevent a lot more harm down the line. And that's just with all good intentions. Obviously the situation can be worse when people are willing to make substantial tradeoffs in cost for quality (which I think we've all see this to be quite common practice).
I really do think that a lot of these ethics questions are a lot harder than the public discourse (or even more savvy like HN) give them credit for. I don't think a strong stance can be taken unless you study these specific areas in depth, and even then there's a hell of a lot of noise. I think one of the best things we can do is to at least acknowledge the level of noise in our opinions/stances. It would be quite naive to take a hard stance on a solution method when such uncertainty exists in our models.
- totetsu 3y agoIn the case of japan, This focus on robotics and ai workforce is at the expense of working on the problem of proper support an integration for nurses from overseas.
- visarga 3y ago> But once AI enter a job it is entirely possible that this prevents future people from pursuing it, meaning that actual people get replaced with them. Through an entirely implicit process and not because the machines are better, thus lowering the quality of the market which was already suffering. The opposite is also possible - AI entering a field would produce many new capabilities that require humans to be involved in their development, deployment, supervision, or working in supporting tasks. AI is probably the field that will generate the most demand induction. See "lump of labour" and "Jevons paradox", they are related to this topic of demand growth vs automation growth. - demand depends on supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand - work depends on demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy - increased supply leads to increased demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- ChatGTP 3y agoThere are just motivational aspects to it too, like do you want to supervise a bunch of AIs? Do you want a bunch of "AI" systems supervising you ? As much as we love AI and as much as it is getting shoved into our lives whether we like it or not from the tech overlords. I'm not sure everyone wants to be living in an AI world by default.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"I'm not sure everyone wants to be living in an AI world by default." I sure don't. The problem is that the AI will be integrated into society far before people realize that they don't really want it, and it will be too late to turn back...
- yyyk 3y ago>>But once AI enter a job it is entirely possible that this prevents future people from pursuing it, meaning that actual people get replaced with them.... thus lowering the quality of the market which was already suffering. >The opposite is also possible - AI entering a field would produce many new capabilities that require humans to be involved in their development, deployment, supervision, or working in supporting tasks. A lot of humans entering a slightly different field may lower total unemployment, but parent was worried about quality, not unemployment per se.
- godelski 3y ago> The opposite is also possible Of course! That's what makes this hard. I apologize, I assumed we were already working with this prior but I think that was a bad assumption. It's just hard to see if things are cotton gins or the power loom.
- jvvw 3y agoMy sister is a translator, a field where AI has already had a huge impact. She can still get high-end translation work (she has 25 years experience, a Masters in translation and is an extremely good writer in English) - some people do need really good translations. However it would be a daft field for anybody new to go into, which makes me wonder who will do that type of work in future. Of course there is a possibility that AI translations continue to improve so human translation isn't needed at all, but AI translation isn't that great at the moment, especially in languages which are less widely spoken.