4 ms·
“Spun” and “span” are both past tense forms of “spin”, but “span” is both archaic and singular, and so would be an odd choice in any current writing, and a disa
by dragonwriter 3y ago
“Spun” and “span” are both past tense forms of “spin”, but “span” is both archaic and singular, and so would be an odd choice in any current writing, and a disagreement in number where, as here, it is used with a plural subject.
- Thorrez 3y agoDifferent past tense for singular vs plural? Are there any other words that have that besides "is"? Wiktionary doesn't seem to mention it being singular, although I might be misunderstanding it: > (dated, now uncommon) simple past of spin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/span#English https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/span#English
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Different past tense for singular vs plural? Are there any other words that have that besides "is"? Non-archaic? Quite possibly not. English has done a very good job of shedding inflections. But “span” (as a past tense of “spin” isn’t non-archaic). > Wiktionary doesn't seem to mention it being singular, although I might be misunderstanding it: My sources were citing discussion in the OED, but I haven't verified them.
- mathieuh 3y agoWhat do you mean singular? I span, you span, he/she/it span, we span, you span, they span. These all sound grammatical to me. I can’t think of many English verbs that inflect differently for the same person but different number. In fact off the top of my head the only one I can think of is “to be” (I am, we were)
- coldtea 3y agoThere's nothing about it being singular in the dictionary. And I've seen both used in modern writing. Perhaps a US vs UK vs rest of the english speaking world thing?