8 ms·
> E.g. If you have been professionally diagnosed with ADHD, the FAA bans you from any pilot's license ever, even a student license Not quite true. They just ne
by godelski 3y ago
> E.g. If you have been professionally diagnosed with ADHD, the FAA bans you from any pilot's license ever, even a student license
Not quite true. They just need you to be evaluated where you've been off medication for at least 90 days. But if you're on Adderall, you're shit out of luck. Which is pretty dumb since the medication resolves issues.
Other dumb things that will/can prevent you from getting your license: AIDS, diabetes, obesity (BMI >35), anemia, depression, gender dysphoria (they more recently updated for trans, but hormones or surgery can make it difficult), color blindness (not that impactful these days, and there are many types of color blindnesses), and many more.
Side note: I was working on my pilot's license before I went to grad school. No problems, despite a history of depression too. In grad school I got diagnosed and Adderall really made a big difference (even helping with my depression). So gotta make the choice of being able to fly or being able to do productive work which I'm passionate about. Private pilots are a dying breed, and the FAA is only doing things to accelerate this.
https://pilot-protection-services.aopa.org/news/2015/september/30/what-is-attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-and-how-does-the-faa-look-at-this-condition https://pilot-protection-services.aopa.org/news/2015/septemb...
- srvmshr 3y agoWhy discriminate against diabetes. Of the things listed, this is probably the most common one & a lifestyle disease. This can have a onset in mid-40s to 50s for some genetically predisposed people. Are they not allowed to fly then?
- Kerb_ 3y agoDiabetic shock while flying would be pretty bad. They seem to do individualized assessments, it's not an instant removal. https://diabetes.org/tools-support/know-your-rights/discrimination/employment-discrimination/pilots-with-diabetes https://diabetes.org/tools-support/know-your-rights/discrimi...
- godelski 3y agoThis is the reason. Nuance is also common for some things on the list (e.g. HIV/ADHD but not all things, e.g. AIDS/Color blindness). But all these things are still lacking of a lot of nuance and things like diabetes has only recently been partially resolved due to large lobbying efforts of the ADA: https://diabetes.org/tools-support/know-your-rights/discrimination/employment-discrimination/pilots-with-diabetes https://diabetes.org/tools-support/know-your-rights/discrimi...
- foldr 3y agoDifficult to see what the “nuance” would be for HIV. If someone knows they have HIV, is receiving treatment, and passes other general health checks, then there’s really no risk. It smells of 80s prejudice.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tonyarkles 3y agoYeah, in undergrad I worked with a guy who was very bad at managing his blood sugar levels. One weekend he was alone in the lab and up on a ladder adjusting a ceiling-mounted camera; he passed out, fell, ripped the $30k camera out of the ceiling, caught the PC it was connected to on fire, and woke up on the floor a while later with no recollection of any of it. Another time he was biking home in the winter and passed out, luckily to be discovered in the snow by another colleague who happened to be walking home.
- consp 3y agoWait until you want to get a driver's license in Europe. You'd be surprised how much bs you'd have to go though to get one in some countries as a diabetic. Also funny sidenote where I live: if you got type 1 diabetes before getting your license you are legally bound to report it, if you got if after getting your license you have to make your own assesment if you should report it (my not legal advice: never do that, it shortened the license from 10 to 5 or 3 years and puts you though whatever the approving person wants to put you though which can be extensive)
- lelanthran 3y agoI'm diabetic. Not too bad, if I forget my meds I get sleepy. I think they are trying to cut out those people who, when they don't get their meds, literally pass out. Because the diagnosis doesn't specify a severity, all they can do is deny all diabetics. I don't think, under the current way that diabetes is diagnosed, that these rules are especially unfair.
- mschuster91 3y agoBecause diabetes events (both hypo and hyperglycemia) due to human error can and regularly do lead to accidents. It's bad enough in cars, but a plane? Hell no.
- Ekaros 3y agoI think they focus on type-1 not the type-2 that is likely common even in professionals. Type-1 can cause many immediate issues. And thus likely they don't want pilots with it.
- paulddraper 3y agoI can't recall all the specifics, but if you are evaluated and disqualified, it can be worse than if you were never evaluated. Often the doctor's office will try to prescreen to prevent this.
- techwizrd 3y agoThe FAA's Office of Aerospace Medicine is actively researching can improve or rethink the aeromedical certification process. We need to do a substantial amount of research with very limited resources, especially when we have limited data to conduct safety risk management and safety assurance. It's a tough nut to crack, but there's a lot of smart people working tirelessly to make this better.
- paulddraper 3y agoWith all due respect, "tirelessly" might be an understatement. Six years ago, they added BasicMed. And they've been updating the SSRI list. But that's it. For years of work. Why don't they just relax the third class medical requirements specifically? Only affects private pilots, nothing for hire. Currently, the FAA makes zero distinction between health conditions/medications for a Cessna 150 and a Boeing 747.
- hnta1024 3y agoBasicMed is a step in the right direction but still a bit of a joke in itself. And you have to go through the regular medical first to even be eligible for it. 1000% agreed that they should relax third class and how absurd it is that private pilots flying a little 2 seater are held to pretty much the same standard as someone commercially flying a passenger jet. I had two loss of consciousness episodes very close together a number of years ago due to some very extenuating circumstances (and never had an issue before that or since) and was told I will never pass a medical to get a private pilot cert. Want to barrel down a busy highway at 70 MPH in a 6500 lb SUV where you are pretty much guaranteed to hurt multiple people in an accident? No problem! Fly an 800 lb Kitfox over fields in a rural area? No way, you could hurt someone! Funny enough, practically everyone in aviation I talked to more-or-less told me to just lie about it and pass my medical. It seems like quite a common trend for pilots - the FAA almost certainly is doing far more harm than good with these oppressive restrictions by forcing pilots away from treatment they need for fear they may be permanently grounded. I'm certain I'd pass with flying colors if I just "forgot" that one detail but I'd rather be honest about everything.
- flangola7 3y agoI don't understand the 90 days part. Why would someone discontinue the medication that controls their symptoms? I have ADHD and take Adderall, and plan to pursue a recreational/personal license next year.
- ryanmercer 3y agoI'm guessing because a Google search of "Adderall side effects" immediately returned this: "Rare but severe side effects of Adderall can include emotional instability, psychiatric disorders and cardiovascular events. Adderall misuse can lead to seizures and death."
- flangola7 3y agoThere are rare but terrible side effects for virtually all medications. What is your point?
- ryanmercer 3y agoThat you don't want people with suicidal ideations flying planes. There are plenty of medicines that warn against operating motor vehicles or heavy machinery, off the top of my head some blood pressure meds like Losartan and HCTZ because they can make you dizzy/prone to blacking out. I imagine there's similar logic here for pilots.
- godelski 3y agoIt's worth mentioning that people who take Adderall medicinally are taking substantially lower dosages than those who take it recreationally. Medicinal users take on average 20mg and can have dosages down to 5mg where a recreational user is taking 40mg and maybe up to 100mg. Sure, Adderall can cause the things you mentioned, but the same is actually true about sugar (a highly addictive substance, high potential for abuse, and limited medical usage). These bins are arbitrary and dosage matters. It would be perfectly acceptable for the FAA to require 3 months of usage, at a specific dose, wherein a pilot is stable on their meds and an FAA doctor (which they must visit anyways) approves them. You can get a good idea of risk factors and stability by doing this.