3 ms·
In most countries buying a house doesn’t involve taking out loans that take 30 years to pay off in the first place.
by paxys 3y ago
In most countries buying a house doesn’t involve taking out loans that take 30 years to pay off in the first place.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoTrue, you get robbed much quicker.
- Macha 3y agoI don't know, high house prices are pretty much all over the west
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoWhat does the process look like in Europe?
- CalRobert 3y agoUsually an overpriced 30 year ARM (with a fixed period at beginning) and a restriction that you pay it off before retirement (so no 30 year mortgage if you're 45 for instance). Also a much tougher application process where people without "permanent" jobs are screwed. Of course, many, many people are on temporary contracts (because firing perm employees is hard). Possibly a stiff deposit req (I'd need a 20% deposit) and you can only borrow 4x your income. Having kids counts against you too. At least this is the case in Ireland. I bought my house in cash.
- SoftTalker 3y ago20% down and strict underwriting standards used to be the norm in the USA also. I know a guy who just did a refinance with equity cash out for 30 years. He’s nearly 70. He clearly plans to die broke.
- bradlys 3y agoSome of these aren’t that far off from the American process. It being an ARM, not being able to get a house if you’re going to retire, and the impermanent job type are a bit weird though. Usually for Americans, you need to show some years of steady income to qualify. It doesn’t entirely matter what your job is - as much as you can show with your tax returns that you’re making steady money (for years) that can afford the home. The having kids thing is weird and I don’t get why that would be against you. I’m guessing there are much stronger tenant rights in Ireland where they have a harder time evicting the person and making it impossible for them to find housing later. (Credit score, legal records, etc.) The 4x income and 20% deposit is very common here too. Going past 4x would require unusual circumstances. People doing lower deposits and/or higher ratio incomes are not common especially in the major cities. You might qualify for a special loan from the VA or through FHA but it has penalties like having to pay PMI and being locked to only homes of a certain price.
- CalRobert 3y agoInteresting, thanks. I came of age in the mid-noughties (and then moved to Ireland) so my perspective on US is skewed. Reposession in Ireland takes years. And the existence of strong protections against firing means banks only (usually) lend to people with permanent jobs, even if you have years of income on temp contracts.
- rsynnott 3y ago> Possibly a stiff deposit req (I'd need a 20% deposit) Note that, for Ireland, this is because you're a second-time buyer. It's 10% for first time buyers. Today, mortgage rates in the US start at about 6% for a variable rate, or 7% for a 30 year fix. If you have <20% deposit you'll pay about 1% PMI, too. In Ireland, the age of the 2% mortgage is definitely gone, but you'll pay about 4% variable, or 4-5% for a normal 10 year fix. Avant will give you a 30 year fix for about 4%, though there is limited actual demand for such a product in Ireland. By the way, you can get a mortgage that goes into retirement, though the bank will certainly want to see evidence of a pension... You can also get a mortgage if you're self-employed; you'll want about three years accounts and for either of these cases you'll probably need a broker. So, really, it's swings and roundabouts to an extent; Irish mortgages are a lot cheaper than US ones. To some extent this is structural weirdness; the banks have more deposits than they know what to do with, and under ECB stress testing rules they have limited things they can feasibly _do_ with those deposits, so their cost of funds is relatively low.
- ghaff 3y ago"Most" is probably literally true but I don't see people talking about the cheap housing in European cities like London. Yes, most people have historically taken out 30-year fixed rate loans in the US, in part because they are tax-advantaged. But nothing is keeping you from taking out a loan for a shorter period. I did when I refinanced my current house.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWhat are you talking about? It's exactly the same in Europe. Unless they get help from their parents, most middle class people need 30 years to pay off their homes here too. It's the same shit everywhere in the west. Real estate is priced at the maximum amount the market would bear.
- oldgradstudent 3y ago> It's the same shit everywhere in the west. Real estate is priced at the maximum amount the market would bear. And the market would bear to pay the amount banks will allow buyers to borrow (to first approximation). So if banks allow 30 year mortgages, the market would bear up to 50% or so more than if banks allow 20 year mortgages.
- mannyv 3y agoIn most countries only the rich can buy homes. So yes your statement is true, because most people can never buy a home so there's no loan involvement at all. But I'm pretty sure that's not what you wanted to say.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoOn second thought, this comment is a mix of peak anti-Americanism combined with a lack of financial knowledge. If you have ever taken a mortgage in the US, you know there are a lot of time horizons available.