5 ms·
Human-powered air-compressor and energy storage system
- debbiedowner 3y agoUsed in foiling boats in America's cup and similar races.
- n40487171 3y agoI believe those use a hydraulic accumulator system rather than compressed air.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoGuess what's on the other side of the membrane or piston in a hydraulic accumulator?
- n40487171 3y agoI would guess that it would be a metal spring of some sort that doesn't lose energy to thermal side effects of compressing and decompressing gas, for a higher round trip power efficiency. Or else it could be a relatively large gas reservoir so that it doesn't heat or cool the gas too much.
- gotts 3y agoI'm far from foiling boats would you mind explaining why are these compressors human powered and not gas/battery powered? Is it something from racing code?
- BrentOzar 3y agoRacing code - America's Cup races prohibit stored energy aboard the boat, for example. Exceptions are made for certain springs, valves, and batteries for electronics.
- bombela 3y agoWhat a refreshingly clean, quick to load website. I would have done without the email popup. But I can forgive that. If I trust the footer, the server is solar powered in Barcelona.
- pwg 3y ago> I would have done without the email popup. With uBlockOrigin blocking all Javascript by default, there is no "email popup".
- ReactiveJelly 3y agoIt does load fast, but I'm pretty sure the ditherpunk aesthetic is bogus. Byte for byte, JPEGs should beat dithered PNGs / GIFs, and they never proved that the end-to-end costs of JPEG encoding and decoding are worse than dithering. It just looks distinct.
- BHSPitMonkey 3y agoI'm not sure how that makes it "bogus". The site also uses CSS styles that technically use more bandwidth than vanilla HTML. The point was never to find the most optimal solution.
- lowtechmagazine 3y ago[dead]
- detourdog 3y agoI just wish the article contained the duration of a bike session and the run time of 90 gallons at 100psi. Myabe its there and I missed it.
- woutgaze 3y agoNice setup although I remember that the efficiency of air tools is very low like around 1%. That’s also why they get replaced a lot.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoA massive amount of power is lost in air tools. They're also painfully loud, the hose is annoying in a variety of ways, and the air system in the shop is expensive to install and involves periodic maintenance. Most mechanics use battery tools these days. Impact drivers for all but the biggest stuff, with handheld drivers having enough torque to work on a lot of suspension components easily, and there are even electric ratchet drivers now with sufficient torque for a lot of smaller stuff under the hood that require little more space than a hand ratchet, and no room for swing needed. Battery tools are faster, quieter, easier to control. The system scales linearly in capacity, charging speed, etc. Add two mechanics to your shop where you're only using air? You're looking at thousands of dollars to upgrade a compressor, maybe a tank too. If you're concerned about still being a mechanic when you lose power, put a solar panel on the roof, attach it to a MPPT solar charger and a couple of car batteries you recycle from customers' cars, and have an inverter ready to switch on if you need it. What mechanic has the energy to pedal this thing just to work? What mechanic does so little work with their tools that the system can be infrequently refilled by a guy taking an hour or more to fill the tank? This is at best useful for a shadetree mechanic and the article is fetishizing low-tech BS with no practicality. Replacing a 7hp compressor that was chewing up his electric bill...with something he pedals? If it was chewing up his electric bill, then there's no way he could replace it by pedaling.
- DannyBee 3y agoI mostly agree, but the first part is not universally true. My 30cfm compressor is 45db. Basically noiseless. You can easily have a normal conversation with it running. The air itself makes more noise than the compressor. It is happy with any duty cycle from 0-100%. Maintenance interval is about every 5 years. It produces oil free air. I can use it for breathing air (spray finishing) and not worry about things as much (I have proper gas sensors on that part anyway but it's nice to know i won't get poisoned by oil in some fashion) I pay for this in efficiency. A oil sealed rotary screw would be about 30% more efficient (maybe a little more) but have some carry over and be about 65db. Not hugely noisy but still. My pneumatic sanders have much lower vibration (30-40%), are quieter, smaller, weigh a lot less, and are essentially maintenance free. They can be repaired easily if I ever need to because they are very simple devices. The mechanism lends itself well to really good dust collection. As a result They are much nicer to use than even the nicest electric festool and mirka sanders (I have both). The electrics are massively improved over two decades ago but still. I don't woodwork or metalwork without mask or ear protection at all times so even if they were noisier I'd be fine. The air drops are set up to be convenient from anywhere in the shop. All that said, I do agree with the rest and the main point- for most people, battery is a better bet. I use what I do for convenience and comfort, not for cost or effectiveness. There are times using air is just a better way of doing that than batteries.
- karaterobot 3y ago> The process of filling the empty tanks to 100 psi takes 5-10 pedaling sessions per day for roughly a week. The main thing I wanted to know from this article is how much peddling it takes to keep the tank filled, and I don't feel like he answered that: how long is a peddling session? If it's 5 minutes, that's about four and a half hours of peddling to fill the tank. If it's 15 minutes, that's about 13 hours. And how often does he empty the tank? How long does it take just to keep it topped up in an average week? Details, man! He must know this if he uses the thing.
- brnt 3y agoI love lowtechmag, but it's almost a rule they are economical with details too, and often to hide a (pretty obvious) compromise that not everyone would be willing to make.
- antisthenes 3y agoThe extremely obvious compromise is that you need to have a high-PSI air tank on hand as well as a donor bike. The donor bike can probably be gotten for very cheap or free, but the tank... I looked at the prices of 80-gal 200 PSI rated tanks online, and the conclusion is...not great. It's going to run you roughly $1000, for which you can realistically buy a whole set of cordless battery powered tools AND an outlet-powered air compressor on top of that.
- tshanmu 3y agoobligatory: fifteen million merits https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2089049/?ref_=ttep_ep2 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2089049/?ref_=ttep_ep2
- umtksa 3y agodid same thing but smaller scale to use with usb powered devices https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMBtU3irxLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMBtU3irxLo
- aziaziazi 3y agoAuthor also did something similar with usb and different voltages https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2022/03/how-to-build-a-practical-household-bike-generator/ https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2022/03/how-to-build-a-pra... Well worth a read!
- maxerickson 3y agoArticle is wrong about energy. Gonna keep getting cheaper. For instance, that's the long term trend: https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/electricity-prices-adjusted-for-inflation/ https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/electricity-... Reliability is a little less of a given, but it's not unreasonable to expect grid operators to seek to continue making profits.
- midoridensha 3y agoHe's probably a typical person that looks at the dire conditions in his mismanaged small locality, and thinks the entire world is like that.
- JohnFen 3y agoYou're probably correct, but these are times of great uncertainty and I wouldn't currently be willing to lay any bets one way or the other. There's nothing wrong with exercising design skills to address living without reliable (or any) electricity. If nothing else, it's a hobby and keeps your mental juices flowing. If such bad times never happen, you still get the benefits that come with such projects. If they do happen, such skills can become invaluable. And there are many parts of the world where the reality is that something like this could be practically useful right now.
- fragmede 3y agoDesigning for lack of access to global supply chains that currently exist makes this more of a design exercise rather than a practical solution. That is to say, with money, just buy a couple hundred watts of consumer-grade available solar (eg by Jackery; not a collection of no-name eBay special parts that you need to be an electrical engineer to setup), a solar inverter, a large battery pack for storage, and then a charger for battery packs for tools, instead of an air compressor-based system and this bicycle thing. This is practically useful right now, and can be ordered via HomeDepot.com. Yes, this is harder to arrange without access to HomeDepot, which most of the world doesn't have, and it's not the cheapest of systems, but a) that's a lot of bicycling; b) solar power is finally here and accessible and c) as long as we do have access to global supply chains, might as well use it. If you're really worried, buying a bunch of backup/spare parts in case we do lose global supply chains seems like a far more viable solution. If you're really that worried about losing access, there are steps you can take, like buying copper plates and photo-resist to make your own, really shitty solar cells, from "scratch", or buying 18650 lithium ion batteries and a 3d printer (along with a plastic recycler) to print your own tool batteries from renewable plastic. If bad times never happen, then what of what practical use is it to know which wild plants in my area are edible and which ones are poisonous, or which storage unit has 10 years worth of MREs inside? People are free to invest time and money in whatever hobby they want, and in case of global (or local) calamity, my prepper friend is my going to be my first stop. I just personally don't believe it's an especially useful hobby, any more than, say, my hobby of Lego building, which has super useful practical applications in my daily life as a Duplo builder for my nephews.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- andylagzdins 3y agoIt was good to find this forum- I have been looking for constructive feedback on my human-powered air compressor. I have been working on the project for 3 months, and I am still making many improvements as I use the machine. The configuration featured in the LowTech Magazine has been updated considerably, and I am now getting close to the performance limits of the basic design. If anyone has any questions or suggestions, please feel free to comment. Some quick replies to previous comments: -The amount of pedaling needed to keep the tank topped off depends on the amount at which air is emptied from the tank. -A steam engine powered design would be cool to see, but not currently in my skill set. Steam power might also prove challenging in an indoor environment. -The total cost to build this machine was roughly $1000USD in parts, but I could have lowered the costs considerably by sourcing more used components. I also bought some parts to try that were updated to an improved design. I did just score another 80gal tank for $20USD, so the deals are out there if you take the time to look for them. -The pedaling effort is easiest when the tank is empty, and gets progressively harder as you build pressure. -The air system has no noticeable leaks, and I monitored tank pressure closely for a few weeks with no measurable pressure loss. -Energy will not get cheaper.
- ralfblake 3y agoInformative read! This article sheds light on the potential of solar energy for rural communities. Empowering them with clean, sustainable solutions is a significant step towards a greener future.