6 ms·
Evidence for a gravitational wave background from a galaxy-sized detector
- danparsonson 3y agoThis is just mind-blowing - what a time to be alive!
- SoKamil 3y agoI read it with the voice of Károly Zsolnai-Fehér
- not_your_mentat 3y agoHold onto your papers!
- 29athrowaway 3y agoThat man needs a voice coach.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoCan you ELI5 why the fact we have evidence of Hellings and Downs correlations is mind-blowing?
- danparsonson 3y agoI was referring more to the measurement of slight variations in pulsar frequencies across decades used to detect background gravitation waves - I'm afraid I have no context besides this article to ELY5 the science they're trying to prove.
- nonameiguess 3y agoI would agree with the other comment that the fact we can measure gravitational waves at all using pulsar timing with data collected over decades is what is mind-blowing, more than the actual waves being detected. However, depending on their nature, there is a possibility that this is still a pretty significant event. When we observed the cosmic microwave background, because this is light emanating from everywhere at the very first time photons decoupled from ionized matter and the mean free path exceeded the particle horizon (the universe "became transparent" as they say), this is the furthest back you ever see using light. A much earlier event can possibly be observed via the cosmic neutrino background. The universe would have been transparent to neutrinos much earlier, when the electroweak force first decayed into the weak and electromagnetic forces. This is a big difference, fractional seconds after the Big Bang compared to I think 379,000 years or so for light. However, the very earliest event that could ever be observed by any means at all would be the cosmic gravitational background expected to exist when gravity first decoupled from strong and electroweak forces. If that's what this is, we're not seeing the literal beginning, but it's the closest we can ever get by any sensor we currently have the ability to conceive of.
- dredmorbius 3y agoOne lesson from the history of science is that new developments in detection and sensing capabilities often herald tremendous increases in knowledge. Lenses, and the telescope and microscope, both advanced astronomy and biology tremendously. Interferometry grows out of optics, spectroscopy, and the ability to detect interference at scales. Chemical tests, electromagnetic principles, radiation, and the ability to detect electromagnetic radiation outside the visible spectrum (infrared, radio, ultraviolet, x-ray, gamma ray) had similarly large influences. Another area of progress is increased precision in measuring both space and time, which this discovery addresses. I've also done some fairly casual eyeball-assessments of trends in Nobel-awarded research in physics and chemistry since roughly 1960, which is a convenient demarcation between the period of profound discovery through the earlier part of the 20th century, with fundamental laws and particles making frequent mention, to the past 60 or so years in which it's often been measurement or emission capabilities (think LIGO and blue LEDs) which have been the subject of awards. In one sense, these seem less significant than the earlier work, and that's been my own tendency in ascribing heft. But if this does in fact represent a gestation period in which new observational tools and techniques are being cultivated, there might well be more impact than appears initially. We're in what may well be the early stages of gravitational wave measurement and detection, and we're figuring out how to "build" galactic-- and intergalactic-scale measurement "devices" which are necessary to detect this pervasive but very low-energy effect. It is exciting, and I'm thinking over the past record of sensing technologies to think how these might inform us. My initial read is that gravitational waves are very low frequency, which is to say, low resolution, but because they have extraordinarily high upper bounds on magnitude (unlike, say, magnetic or electromagnetic events associated with stars, galaxies, and even black-hole and neutron-star interactions, though the latter play a strong role in gravitational wave phenomena), what I suspect we'll find is a general sensing capability which can "see through" cosmic structures that are otherwise opaque to us (gravity isn't bothered by dust and other matter), and also provides a mechanism for directly observing dark matter, which is defined by the fact that it does interact gravitationally but does not with the electromagnetic spectrum. That's a lay view, no specific expertise, but informed by a model of technologies and capabilities afforded, one element of which is information, itself comprised of sensing, processing, storage and recall, and transmission.
- 3y ago
- lsp_trw 3y agoAre there sites like astrobites for other fields?
- ramchip 3y agoThere's a whole list of "sister sites" in the right sidebar
- c7DJTLrn 3y agoSo when we say that a star is N light years away and therefore it would take N years to reach at the speed of light, is that not true? If the speed of light is changed by gravitational waves. How does this play into our understanding of the size and expansion of the universe?
- Beldin 3y agoIn addition to multiple sibling comments answering your actual question, I'd like to point out the following: > when we say that a star is N light years away and therefore it would take N years to reach at the speed of light, is that not true? That is not what "N light years away" means. It means that the light we're right now seeing from that star was emitted N years ago. But stars don't stay put. If you point a rocket at the star and fly N light years of distance, you won't end up inside the star -- it'll have moved on. This seems pedantic (and it is), but consider the expansion of the universe. You're seeing light from N years ago - when the universe was smaller. Suppose expansion is more or less uniform, i.e. something like "every 1000 years, each meter becomes 0.1% longer" (it isn't, but reasonable approximation). Then: the greater the original distance was, the faster the star is moving away due to expansion of the universe. After all, each meter in between expands x% per second, so more meters in between is greater increase in distance every second. If the distance is great enough, then each year, the universe expands that distance so much, it increases by more than 1 light year. That means that light from that star can nerve reach us again (unless the universe starts contracting). This phenomenon is called the Cosmological Horizon.
- raattgift 3y agoThe millisecond pulsars in the international pulsar timing arrays https://ipta4gw.org/ https://ipta4gw.org/ are all within the Milky way. There is no metric expansion of space within the Milky way. The pulsars (and our solar system) are all on ~Keplerian orbits through the galaxy, and relative motion between us and them is small. > If the distance is great enough It's not, in this context. > Stars don't stay put Close enough, in this context. The uncertainties ("red noise") in PTA timing residuals from scattering in the interstellar medium and local properties (mostly internal structure) of the pulsars dwarf the uncertainties in relative motion. PTAs also care about the pulse timing not the carrier of the pulse. That is, the beam points at us with a predictable period and that period evolves (in parts per million) in the presence of nanohertz gravitational waves. The beam itself is broadband (radio to gamma rays) and any spectral line structure could be anything (most likely the interstellar medium). Detailed redshift studies look at the spread of spectral lines, particulary the Lyman and Balmer series, and pulsars are what you get when there's no hydrogen left to fuse. ("Finally, pulsars have broadband continuum spectra, so if there are gas clouds along our line of sight, pulsars can be used to probe the ISM via absorption by spectral lines of Hi or molecules. Such absorption spectra can be used to estimate pulsar distances" -- end of §6.2 of Condon & Ransom's Essential Radio Astronomy advanced undergraduate one-semester-course textbook (2016 ed.), web version at https://www.cv.nrao.edu/~sransom/web/Ch6.html https://www.cv.nrao.edu/~sransom/web/Ch6.html ) I have a related comment in this thread if you're interested.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoHow are we certain that it's GW that's doing this and, not, say, ripples in dark matter?
- raattgift 3y agoHow do you get nanohertz quadrupole gravitational radiation out of dark matter? If you can't think of a physically plausible mechanism, then that's your answer. The GW spectrum and in particular the brighter sources makes it really hard to come up with something astrophysical that isn't an essentially isotropic set of shells of inspiralling supermassive black hole binaries (~billions of solar masses, orbital periods of about a third of a year to a couple of years) with scattering and orientation statistics similar to the observed distribution of galaxies (including nonspirals) and our view of spirals as edge-on vs face-on.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoThis is just my gut speaking, but it feels like when something is nanohertz it could literally be anything, especially an anything that could have arbitrary distribution. Why not have periodically distributed dark matter?
- raattgift 3y agoOne answer to that is observation: eventually a nHz-GW-bright source should be localized to a bright electromagnetic source (e+e- synchrotron radiation of a jet from one member of the smbh binary, for instance). If we can't trace a bright source to an SMBHB candidate eventually, back to the drawing board. > Why not have periodically distributed dark matter Big warning: I don't do galactic dynamics! That will colour my approach to answering your question. It's a neat question though. Second big warning: in no way is this rigorous, and I won't feel bad if someone blows me up with math. Think Lorentzian rather than Euclidean. The dark matter (DM) blobs have to move around the pulsar timing array (PTA) members in order to induce longitudinal redshift and blueshift, and also (because the beamline is dragged by the other polarization) brightening and dimming. DM is famously bad at dimming background objects... DM is also really hard to compactify (you need it to couple with gravitationally collapsing hot baryons and get the latter to cool fast) and has tiny bulk viscosity. So you're going to need really weird initial conditions to get the overdensities you want in place. Cold DM is also really hard to lift to a higher gravitational potential. Around the PTA pulsars its even hard to lift baryonic clouds since our galaxy is super-quiet (no AGN outflow or feedback) and the PTA millisecond pulsars are well out of the central bulge. That ties your hands a bit on Lorentzian periodicity, and my bet is that from generic initial values you end up with a pulsar with a sparse but fat ~spherical "atmosphere" of DM. Euclidean v Lorentzian in a nutshell. Euclid: take an equilateral tetrahedron (to keep things nice and simple), spatial lengths in lightseconds (and setting c=1). You and three friends at the vertices stay put with respect to each other. Lorentz equilateral tetrahedron: put one vertex a second in the future, and its opposite side in the present. You and two friends at the vertices of that past side move at c to the future vertex. We can take you and your two friends' movement timelike and to the non-relativistic limit through rescaling. We can rotate the E vs L tetrahedra or change the areas of one or more sides so that the points trace out the worldlines of some DM masses. Thinking E-style you arrange four blobs of dark matter at the vertices of a tetrahedron around the pulsar enclosed by a (not necessarily equilateral and not necessarily unchanging in edge length or face area or volume) tetrahedron. Invites Kepler thinking. But we don't have Euclidean symmetries in our universe, we have Lorentzian ones. Thinking L-style you arrange three blobs of dark matter around the pulsar enclosed by the L-tetrahdron, and blobs and the pulsar eventually collide (that's basically Raychaudhuri's focusing theorem). Evading eventual Raychaudhuri collision is hard because there's basically no contact forces within the DM blobs or between them and the pulsar (so no outward acceleration), therefore you need to rely on vorticity to oppose collapse. And the point of the exercise is to introduce or at least mimic nonzero shear (sphere->ellipsoid), which acts against vorticity. It's not quite "CRUNCH" because the DM blobs will sail through each other and the pulsar, but the pulsar won't move the way you want and dynamical drag effects will settle the DM blobs into an atmosphere around (and through!) the pulsar. Thanks to the pulsar spin, high frequency multipole gravitational radiation from bumps on the crust and interior quakes and things (yay, pulsar glitches) will dominate the GW spectrum. Lots of wiggling, and not obviously the wiggling you want. I'm inclined to demand a description of initial conditions that leads to the wiggling you want (in-flight frequency and brightness evolution of the emitted beam), because in all honesty I don't trust my intuition that the IVs would be really non-generic in angular momentum but I'd think it's really really cool if I were wrong on the "there's no way that would work" reaction to the DM blobs mimicking nHz GW background idea. Final two things: I kept editing in and out dissipation and viscosity, because I don't do and don't want to do galactic dynamics. However, subgalactic DM overdensity blobs are unlikely to stay blobs.