3 ms·
The evolution of what it means to be human
- slowmovintarget 3y agoThis essay doesn't actually say much, but it sure wraps itself in much jargon. > "...what is called for is a theory of governance that recognizes the promise while affirming the autonomy of humans, albeit reconfigured through a new awareness, by striving to shape what we now understand as anthropo-technogenesis."
- blueflow 3y agoMany of the Noema articles are like that. I looked it up and found that its made by the Berggruen Institute, a US-based think tank, but i have no idea what their interests are. The sprinkled-in jargon seems to be an aspect of self-promotion, overdoing it to the extent that it starts to read like a poem instead of having content.
- the-printer 3y agoMy guess is that their interests lie somewhere near the advocacy of something like a techno-democracy. Where "tech" is used dually to refer to "technocracy" in the traditional sense and as alluded to in this article, "technology", as an extension of government. https://www.noemamag.com/approaching-the-infopocalypse/ https://www.noemamag.com/approaching-the-infopocalypse/ https://www.noemamag.com/participation-at-scale-can-repair-the-public-square/ https://www.noemamag.com/participation-at-scale-can-repair-t... An interesting NYT profile from last year on Nicolas Berggruen: https://archive.is/ScoBe https://archive.is/ScoBe
- underlipton 3y agoReading between the lines, it's basically advocating for not (over)regulating AI. It's definitely dancing around its central argument, yes.
- haswell 3y ago> Bratton’s view has significant implications for how we see and approach the accelerating advances in science and technology. This is where things run off the rails a bit for me, and I feel like this is a bit of a sleight-of-hand. Up to this point, almost everything was the good kind of thought provoking. Not new stuff if you've steeped yourself in philosophy or have spent time going down consciousness rabbit holes, but very thought provoking stuff if you haven't encountered these ideas yet. There is value to be gained from challenging traditional modes of thinking about the nature of reality, and how human-centric thinking/awareness can also leave you susceptible to blind spots. But what I see beyond this is a repackaging of the usual AI optimist's argument, trying to sneak in under the guise of some other deeper understanding of things. The argument goes something like: "Humanity has always gone through major changes, just look at the printing press", coupled with "and for all the possible harm of AI, it will be balanced out by all of the possible good". But I find it difficult to accept the analogy that the advancement of AI is equivalent to humanity's history of technology advancement and it seems foolish to equate this with the gradual but steady growth of the past (obviously punctuated by big jumps). It may be that it is fundamentally human to adapt and be adapted by technology, and that's a premise that is worth considering. But what this misses is an assessment of how we're doing with the process of integrating the last 100 years of technology advancement. Right now, we're getting a solid F if you look at our track record of coexisting with the environment. Social media has gone off the rails, and we've got a mental health crisis we don't fully understand yet. And now, while we're still looking for solutions to the last 100 years of problems, an explosion of AI advances brings new questions and problems we don't have the words to fully describe yet. The philosophical framing is fun to wrap your mind around and worth thinking about. But the completely unrelated and heavily implied conclusion that AI is gonna be just fine based on our history of evolving alongside technology seems to be ignoring just about everything about our track record of evolving alongside technology in the era of computing.