2 ms·
Australian banking regulator appears to think there is a natural floor cost of interbank payment settlement, which I am going to call "rent" and basically said
by ggm 3y ago
Australian banking regulator appears to think there is a natural floor cost of interbank payment settlement, which I am going to call "rent" and basically said as long as it doesn't exceed some metric for CPI related costs, it's fine to charge it no matter what the impact on transactions.
This is a loaded comment, because I think it's bullshit. The cost to process any payment of any size under the $10,000 AML threshold is constant, and functionally zero. As consumers, we've become a profit centre, and there is between $600m and $1b of "cost" which is being met by a % value of transaction fee, irrespective of the real costs of operation. It's regulated theft. Tax office loves it because the black economy is shrinking, small traders are wearing processing costs, intermediaries like stripe are hoovering up data, alongside p2p and inter account direct debit and payment models. Credit unions and banks have an uneasy alliance with "key" and "associated" status to inter bank clearing data networks.
The direct payment scheme we have (osko/payid: typically Australia they couldn't decide a single branding) is seconds to complete sometimes and competes with other forms of transaction clearing for cost and time.
We still have chequebook process clearing times. We still have "not on weekend" and "3 business day" rules. It's totally Bizarre.
When they spun credit and debit card fees out from each other I asked some questions of the finance regulators and they said "works for us, cheaper overall" but I think they left this $600m+ profit component in on bogus logic:
Tl;Dr real costs of settlement per transaction do not relate to how costs are met. Banking is highly profitable and is a protected industry under a benign regulator.
- paulusthe 3y ago> This is a loaded comment, because I think it's bullshit. The cost to process any payment of any size under the $10,000 AML threshold is constant, and functionally zero. Your argument fails here, because you are wrong here. The cost is not zero, because what the bank does for interbank payments is subject to the same regulations and procedures as everything else a bank does. Banks charge money for transfers because there's regulatory overhead and shared liability. What happens if they've missed you're a money launderer for the cartel and have to pay a $2bn fine because they processed your transaction for nearly nothing, instead of doing proper checks and stopping it? Sorry, but you're just plainly wrong here. Very populist and very wrong
- ggm 3y agoFine, call it risk cost. Noting, the AML limits were in my statement and the post transfer processing to find multiple conjoint sub AML represent washing is sitting out there. Functionally zero per transaction (sorry I should have been more explicit) obviously there are real world data comms and CPU and compliance costs. They are not "equal" to the amount of revenue the system is extracting. The absence of variance in system costs unsettle me when a % transaction value price is applied. under the AML reporting limits Fund the risk side from proceeds of crime! What they've done is spread throughout the system the risk costs onto all of us. I, not "plain wrong" we just disagree about cost assignment, risk, and benefit. Do you disagree that the banks and fintech are profiting from their transaction cost models? Hint: in 2029, about 36% of card transactions were Debit cards, with no component of credit card interest or risk: it's money held in account earning banks profits twice: once as deposits earning far lower interest (bank gets to leverage the money) and once again as merchant fee and transaction cost. 80% or more of profit comes from the other side: credit card interest, and you can certainly assign income from card fees to a "cost" bucket for tax purposes but we and the merchants pay it!
- paulusthe 3y agoAnyone who runs a business knows you can't just apply your overhead costs to one part of it but not another. If I have to pay the energy bill, that applies whether or not I had the gas on. You're trying to handwave your way into saying we should care only about the specific cost of one specific bank function, which is silly. Interbank transactions cost money for the same reason every other service costs money, because you're paying a business to do something for you. Climb off the soapbox and enter reality.